View Full Version : hydration possible with sea water
1420Vel.GN
08-24-1999, 10:15 AM
I know shipwreck victoms cannot survive drinking sea water, but if one soaks in the ocean for about an hour the skin begins to wrikle. Is this the skin absorbing water, and if yes, will the skin sort of filter the salt? Could it be enough to survive?
Nickrz
08-24-1999, 11:46 AM
No, no, and no. The wrinkles are a result of the water washing away the oils in the skin. The same thing happens in fresh water.
Actually, here's what UC said about why skin wrinkles when soaked. (http://www.straightdope.com/classics/a2_317a.html)
According to Pliny
08-24-1999, 01:51 PM
This is just from personal experience, but I think soaking in salt water may actually make dehydration worse. I've noticed that on days that I go surfing without a wetsuit, I'm noticably thirstier when I get out of the water. Then again, it could just be my imagination.
Sonic
08-26-1999, 05:33 PM
I would think the skin would start to absorb the water and the salt. Then once in your system, your cells would have a hypertonic reaction to the salt and that would make you even more dehydrated. I don't think the skin can filter out the salt in the water.
------------------
Remember- If you're angry it takes 42 muscles to frown, and only a few muscles to smack the idiot that mad you angry in the first place.
DSYoungEsq
08-27-1999, 07:11 AM
No, no, and no. The wrinkles are a result of the water washing away the oils in the skin. The same thing happens in fresh water.
Nickrz
However, speaking in generalities, I might note that the top layer of the skin is composed of toughened, scaly cells collectively known as the stratum corneum. On most of the body, this layer is quite thin, just .015 of a millimeter, but it's 40 times as thick, or 0.6 of a millimeter, on the soles and palms.
Normally the stratum corneum is relatively dehydrated, but it absorbs moisture and swells up when soaking. This swelling occurs throughout the soles and palms, but it's most noticeable in the fingers and toes because of their restricted dimensions.
In extreme cases, e.g., so-called immersion foot syndrome, which sometimes occurs among soldiers whose feet stay wet for prolonged periods, the entire sole can wrinkle up and become painful to walk on.
The principle is the same in any case. Since the underlying tissue doesn't absorb water, the stratum corneum can't spread out and it buckles like asphalt on the highway in the summer sun.
Uncle Cece
Which is it? If Uncle Cecil is right, then basically the question from 1420Vel.GN was more correctly answered by noting that, while the stratum corneum might hydrate, the underlying layers refuse to and therefore, there would be no benefit to the immersion.
Nickrz
08-29-1999, 01:13 PM
Well, of course I was wrong as to the reason why skin wrinkles. I write that off to ignorance, as I did not recognize the link to Cecil's column offered above and had not read it. That particular error in my thinking has been admirably corrected.
Thanks for pointing this out.
All Hail Cecil!
vBulletin® v3.7.3, Copyright ©2000-2012, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.