PDA

View Full Version : You lose.


xenophon41
04-05-2001, 06:27 PM
To my ex-wife, mother of our son:

Thank you for giving me the opportunity to keep our wonderful son with me on a permanent basis; to have him near me is a thing I've coveted every day of the four years since our divorce. By demonstrating to the community, to your friends, and most importantly to the Superior Court judge your complete disregard for our son's welfare you've inadvertently opened up so many doors for him!

Although I long ago realized that you're not, by nature, a good person, I might still have found enough compassion for you in my heart to forgive the incident which resulted in your arrest in front of our child. I might have listened sympathetically as you explained that your medication was unbalanced, and that the depression simply became too much for you. I might even have helped you after you lost your job. I might have done all that, had I not spoken with those who were present, and with your friends, and with our son's school. I might have, had I not found out from our son the things you've been hiding from me. And I might've given you some benefit of the doubt that you were merely an incompetent but well-meaning parent, had I not seen the changes in our son in the three weeks he's been with me and his stepmother, and had I not spoken at length with his doctor.

Were you to actually care about our son, you would be pleased to know that his chronic eczema completely disappeared after the first week with us. The daily baths and clean bedding possibly may help explain that, although the fact that he doesn't use that special lotion you provided may be significant as well. He has had no asthmatic episodes while in our care, possibly due to our insistence that he actually use his prescribed medications, and not the "extra" inhalers you've had him using. It might surprise you to know that all of his teachers have remarked on the "dramatic" improvements in his self-confidence and demeanor over the past few weeks. This may have to do with the regular meals he now receives, and the cessation of the constant scolding he was used to. You see, his stepmother and I feel it's not entirely sensible to let an 11 year old "decide" to live on ramen noodles and macaroni and cheese dinners, and we keep clear and consistent rules of behavior for him. Believe it or not, he's adapted quite quickly to having a structure to his daily life; something he's previously been accustomed to receiving only two weekends every month.

You would also note with approval that our son is quite well dressed lately. Thank you so for denying us access to his clothing; you can keep the stuff, as he prefers his new outfits. It's amazing how far the child support money will go when actually spent to support the child. It would warm your heart no doubt [if we were to suppose your heart was capable of warmth] to see the confident way he speaks to me, and the easy smiles he frequently wears. Such a relief this cheerfulness is, considering that you had him diagnosed for depression last November. It's probably a good thing you never gave him the Prozac they prescribed for him so you could use it instead; he doesn't appear to have needed it. (But don't worry; I consulted with his doctor and we've stopped the refills on that Rx.)

I'm sorry you didn't get to see our son's face last Thursday when he told me how he'd run the mile race that day in school. He was so happy and proud! They'd given the kids 15 minutes; he finished in 12 minutes, 38 seconds. Not a blistering pace, but pretty good for a kid who was convinced not too long ago that his asthma made such a feat impossible for him. Sadly, I'm not sure you can appreciate that accomplishment, but that's your loss now, not his. As he said to his stepmother that evening, "I'm pretty healthy. [i]I can admit that now." You, see, he no longer has you to explain to him every day how sick he is.

I wonder how long it will be before he feels ready to tell us everything he's feeling. I wonder what secrets he'll keep inside as he grows older. I wonder when he'll come to terms with what his mother truly means to him. He's too young, you see, to do the research yet; he doesn't have access to message boards like this, and to search engines that enable people to find out about such esoteric psychological mysteries as MBP (http://www.mbpexpert.com/definition.html) and other factitious disorders. I'm certainly not going to force him into any realization for which he's unprepared. He will ask and tell me the things he needs to ask and tell when he is ready.

But I know these things, now. I see you more and more clearly each day, my dear ex-wife; the act can no longer fool me.

And I remember things. I remember the way our child could never hold his milk down as a baby, how we tried so many formulas until we found only one that he seemed to tolerate, and how the doctors couldn't give a sensible explanation for his problem. I remember what a good eater he was for me when I started him on juice and cereal, and how he seemed to prefer to be fed by me. I remember the horrifying rashes, and how, whenever it seemed we had his skin under control he'd flare up again. I remember the food allergies that seemed to cause such strangely disparate symptoms, and how he was always inadvertently eating things he knew he shouldn't. I remember the dramatic ways you would describe his problems to our friends, and the way you would exaggerate the slightest problems to his doctor.

Those things I will always remember. I don't know how much of it our son recalls, and I don't really imagine he needs to remember. Somewhere deep in his mind, he knows. But it doesn't matter, really. Because YOU LOSE. He will never be in your care again. He survived the game. He beat you, the best way he could possibly have done so. Living well is the best revenge, they say. Sooner or later, he will know this for himself. With every accomplishment, every milestone he achieves, every healthy moment in store for him, our son will celebrate, consciously or not, his victory.

You lose.

Scarlett67
04-05-2001, 06:34 PM
A Pit thread with a happy ending? Who'd'a thunk it?

Bravo -- and good wishes for the coming years for you and your son.

Medea's Child
04-05-2001, 06:40 PM
Way to go!

Yea!

Thanks for the story, I really, really enjoy triumphant stories. People overcoming evil and living life well. This is such a story and I truly thank you for sharing it. I'm going to save a copy on my comp, if you don't mind. Tales of triumph have power.

Scylla
04-05-2001, 06:49 PM
Ain't it just grand when the good guys win?

They usually do, you know.


Congratulations. Your son knows who the hereo is.

dublos
04-05-2001, 06:50 PM
xenophon41

You sir are a truly wonderous person. That was a great combintion rant/proud parent story.

Bravo!

-Doug

Hippy144
04-05-2001, 06:53 PM
I read your thread and now realize that all people in this world aren't bad. You may have inspired me to rethink not having children, for I figured I was surrounded completely by selfpitting, prescription popping, antisocial, narrow minded, already-in-my-death-bed assholes. But I guess if those of us who aren't like that don't populate, it will become even more one sided. I'll be damned, a flower blooms in shit.

Guinastasia
04-05-2001, 07:10 PM
MBP? *shudders*

That was beautiful.

Stoid
04-05-2001, 07:34 PM
Hey Xeno... I'm very, very happy for you and for your son. It's lovely to hear the GOOD news for a change.

I'd feel sorry for your ex, if she hadn't been hurting your child with her own sickness.

How excellent it is for him that he has you for his dad. Bravo!

stoid

Freedom
04-05-2001, 08:56 PM
Man Xeno...

I don't think I can ever be short and snippy with you again.



Brief interludes of humanity are such an exception in life that they come with the force of a slap in the face.


Best wishes to you and your son.

Mnementh
04-05-2001, 09:28 PM
That was great reading. I love stories like this, happy endings are all.. well, happy.

Go Xeno!

Saint Zero
04-05-2001, 09:29 PM
Living well is the best form of revenge. Better words were never spoken.

Just teach him not to hold a grudge against his mother the rest of his life, if possible. No need to let her run the rest of his life from bad memories.

Duck Duck Goose
04-05-2001, 09:41 PM
Score one for the Good Guys. :)

Er, is it permitted to ask for more details, such as what exactly the ex- got arrested for, and whether she's being put away permanently, or is she gonna be back again in 6 weeks demanding custody and/or visitation rights? The kneejerk stupidity of Family Court judges who firmly believe that "the child is always better off with the mother" never ceases to astound me. So is the lid on the can of worms really good? Better hammer it down, with the butt end of the screwdriver... :D

Sterra
04-05-2001, 10:07 PM
Hmm, reminds me of my mom:)

Spiritus Mundi
04-05-2001, 11:41 PM
Amen.

Lux Fiat
04-06-2001, 12:05 AM
Nice.

It's good (necessary, even), to actually hear a child-custody story wherein the good guys win. Usually all one sees are horror stories. Thanks for sharing, and congratulations to you, your wife, and your son.

straykat23
04-06-2001, 12:06 AM
Congratulations on a beautiful story.

You loved her once; she's mentally ill. It might be better to accept that and forget about revenge.

matt_mcl
04-06-2001, 12:30 AM
Hot damn and hallelujah!

To you, your wife, and Xeno Jr.

TVeblen
04-06-2001, 01:03 AM
Thanks for sharing that, xeno, and I mean that most sincerely. Sounds like it's been endless miles of rough road. There's no greater victory than rescuing a child.

You, your wife and your remarkable, loving son have earned every bit of joy. Let the bad past stay in the past. None of you will ever forget it; the important thing is you're all building a life where it won't taint the future.

Health, happiness and hope--but you have those now.

Veb

Gadarene
04-06-2001, 01:07 AM
Damn, xeno. Well done.

yosemite
04-06-2001, 01:20 AM
Many good wishes and blessings to your family unit, and thanks for sharing. What a wonderful outcome to a nightmare.

Amedeus
04-06-2001, 05:14 AM
*Drops his bag of chips*

What, no, you can't be done yet. That was too good to be that short, keep going..

xenophon41
04-06-2001, 07:37 AM
Thanks for all the positive responses, gang. I want you to know that they helped. Once I started researching MBP, and all the puzzles started to click into place, I spent a few days beating myself up over it --- a parent is supposed to know if their child is being hurt. On many levels I think I failed my child by believing her, letting her deal with the doctors, thinking she was just "overprotective", etc. All I can do, though is move on with him. Like all kids, he responds well to consistency and kindness, and he's got a great positive outlook. He'll do just fine, because we're here for him.

Of course, we now have to question every food allergy and drug reaction we thought we knew about --- if you're trying to keep a kid sickly, denying him the most effective antibiotics is a damned good way to do it --- but that'll just give him more and more evidence that he's getting better.

DDG: I'll go a little spotty on the details, as they kind of read like bad fiction. Briefly, she decided the best way to get the karate instructor she had a crush on to respond to her was to physically attack him in front of a class (the one my son is in), give him a fake suicide note, and refuse to leave the studio. (Yeah, I know; you're thinking Jerry Springer right now.) She claims now that she knew "her" medication (my son's Prozac prescription) was not adequate, and that she did all this to get attention so she could get help. (Yes, I'm serious.) While she was in the fine county mental health facility, and after the school finally managed to contact me, I began to find out other things. It's amazing how "concerned" you find people to have been after something like this happens...

Suffice it to say that I'm fairly confident she won't fight this, and that if she does (she'll have to convince the same judge who gave me custody) she won't prevail. All child custody orders are temporary, but we're reasonably secure he'll be with us for as long as he wants.


And for those of you expressing some empathy for my ex-wife's mental illness; I have no problem with your point of view. While I can no longer find any room in my heart to feel pity or concern for her, I've always avoided saying anything negative about her to my son. My son loves his mother, as all children do. He can't help it, and I won't discourage it. But don't expect me to let my child back into the snake pit merely because I understand that the snakes are just following their nature.

John Corrado
04-06-2001, 07:58 AM
Bully for you, xen!

Sealemon88
04-06-2001, 08:03 AM
But don't expect me to let my child back into the snake pit merely because I understand that the snakes are just following their nature.

Oh hell no! It doesn't matter how tragic your ex's story is. There is absolutily no reason to poison your child's life with her presense.

I'm so glad that you got full custody. Great post, xeno.

Jonathan Chance
04-06-2001, 08:10 AM
Ladies and Gentlemen:

Without a doubt, the perfect rant. Controlled, angry and firm without being overtly hostile, and with a happy ending.

Xeno, congratulations on the perfect rant and taking care of your child. There's nothing more important.

I think we can close the pit now. We'll never top this.

Bravo.

Arden Ranger
04-06-2001, 08:18 AM
xeno, I am so thrilled for you and your son. Too many times in my stint as a daycare provider did I see mothers who had no business raising kids and fathers who should have had custody but were denied it by the short-sighted courts.

My you, your boy and your wife know peace and joy.

BunnyGirl
04-06-2001, 10:14 AM
Excellent! By jove, that's just about the best thing I've heard in a while.

I'll be praying for you that this will be permanent custody - that boy sure is lucky having you and your wife!

TPWombat
04-07-2001, 08:47 AM
{{{{Hugs}}}}} to all of you, Xeno :):):):):):)
May the winds be always at your backs!

Sterra
04-07-2001, 09:10 AM
My son loves his mother, as all children do

Give him a few years and any contact at all with her and I bet he will hate her. You should probably even try to limit a small amount of contact.

flyboy
04-07-2001, 12:16 PM
And I thought my ex was two-faced. Wow.

Good for you, and best of luck.

Hey, is it normal to get teary-eyed in the Pit?

iampunha
04-07-2001, 02:35 PM
Damn . . . that was the ending you could not predict unless you were a doctor. And I ain't. Youch.

{xen} and {xen jr}.

::shakes head:: I remember my father writing a story about a woman almost as sick. The truth is stranger than fiction.

flyboy88: No, not especially. It takes something special. Something poignant and . . . with that special something that only comes with experiences. It's that quality that makes or breaks things.

Ann Onimous
04-07-2001, 03:59 PM
Wow. Amazing. You've been through hell and back on this situation. I pray for blessings on the whole family: and yes, even your ex, that she may find peace and some kind of healing.

I'm a non-custodial mom myself, and I pray every day that my ex is not teaching her to hate me. I love her with all my heart. It tears me up to be away from her. But right now there's nothing I can do except pray.

If this doesn't offend, God bless, and I'll be praying for all of you.

Polycarp
04-07-2001, 04:29 PM
Now I understand your screen name, Xeno.

That was truly a climb uphill, an Anabasis.

Thank God that you won out.

As someone else noted, no story can top this. Thank you, from the bottom of my heart, for confirming that human decency can and does finally win out in the end. I'm proud to be a cyberfriend of someone as brave and determined as you.

{{{Xeno Jr}}}

==================

Which brings me to one important point:

If you're a parent, grandparent, aunt, uncle, adult friend, or whatever of a child...

Believe that child.

I know, in confidence, several horror stories told me by young people about things that happened to them in their childhood. Most of them have in common that they asked for help, for a way out of the horrible situation, and were not believed. "S/He'd never do anything like that. You're exaggerating."

Wrong.

Believe the child.

Yue Han
04-08-2001, 12:23 PM
Matt has apparently discovered the ideal phrase for conveying the appropriate response to good new such as this:

Hot damn and Hallelujah!

I tried to think of something else, but that's it exactly.

--John

casdave
04-08-2001, 04:49 PM
I hate the way that courts seem to automatically assume the mother is the best parent.

There has been a demonisation of male parenting by so many agencies who should know better.

Mothers can be just as mean, devious, and horrible yet in divorces this gets thrown to one side.

When will the courts learn, the best parent is the best parent, neither male nor female, just the best.

Good for you Xeno I can't imagine what the both of you must have gone through before you were able to get out from under.

Elenfair
04-08-2001, 07:10 PM
Let me join the Hot damn and Hallelujah chorus.

Munchausen scares me shitless.

*shudder*

Best wishes to you, the kiddo, and Mrs. Xeno (does that make her "Xena" and if so, can she make funny noises?)

E.

Drastic
04-08-2001, 07:22 PM
I'll join the chorus as well. I don't think any good parent period should beat themselves up for not realizing sooner--Munchausen by proxy is one of those things that's just so downright horrid to even think about it's natural for decent human beings not to expect to ever see it.

Thank everything sacred your child's free of it now.

(And as flyboy noted, jeezis, this puts a certain ex in a whole new and more forgiving light.)

Ann Onimous
04-08-2001, 08:26 PM
Originally posted by casdave
I hate the way that courts seem to automatically assume the mother is the best parent.

There has been a demonisation of male parenting by so many agencies who should know better.

Mothers can be just as mean, devious, and horrible yet in divorces this gets thrown to one side.

When will the courts learn, the best parent is the best parent, neither male nor female, just the best.

Good for you Xeno I can't imagine what the both of you must have gone through before you were able to get out from under.

And, in my case, the person who had the best connections and the best lawyer is the best parent.

Sorry, but my ex is on welfare, food stamps and Medicare, raising our child in an effeciency apartment, all because his uncle was a judge and his parents could afford a good attorney. Meanwhile, I'm married, have a great job with great insurance, was mentally and physically abused by this jackass, and can't even see my daughter.

In the case of the OP, the father is the best parent. But with this new trend, some mothers are getting shafted. It's not fair to anybody.

Kaz
04-08-2001, 08:57 PM
Xeno, thank you so much for sharing that. A great story with a great ending like that always makes me feel so powerful! I feel all tingly and warm inside, knowing that a child has a much better life because of someone that I know (well, kinda know, or at least have interactions with...). Best of luck for the future,for you and your son.

Manda JO
04-08-2001, 08:58 PM
And of course there is hte inevitable problem of when there is no best parent--sometimes two wonderful parents discover tehy can't stand to be married, and sometimes two horrible parents get divorced. I think that this, as much as anything, is why Judges have to latch on to arbitrary qualities to make decsions, though flipping a coin would be better--at least it dosen't pretend that one parent is more qualified or a better person.

AnnaLucretia
04-09-2001, 10:08 AM
Xeno, you have done the exact right thing - and may you continue to reap the rewards of being such a loving and committed father.

I have to agree that the family court system is woefully unprepared for the many permutations of divorce and custody that they are faced with. I know that if my ex and I had not come up with an arrangement on our own, the court would have given me full custody as a matter of course - and my son would have missed out on his terrific father.

Best of luck to you and your whole family. You are an example Dads everywhere.