|
|
|
|||||||
| View Poll Results: Of the stories in this Anthology Thread, which are your favourites? | |||
| The Infinite Theater, post #2 |
|
3 | 20.00% |
| The glitch, post #3 |
|
4 | 26.67% |
| A Prince of Parys, post #4 |
|
3 | 20.00% |
| Tough Love, post #5 |
|
5 | 33.33% |
| Collisions, post #6 |
|
4 | 26.67% |
| The Wages of Sin, post #7 |
|
1 | 6.67% |
| Old business, post #8 |
|
1 | 6.67% |
| The Sliding Floor, post #9 |
|
3 | 20.00% |
| With All The Lights On, post #10 |
|
6 | 40.00% |
| Three Drops, post #11 |
|
2 | 13.33% |
| The End, post #12 |
|
9 | 60.00% |
| City of the Living, post #13 |
|
4 | 26.67% |
| Party at Billy's, post #14 |
|
4 | 26.67% |
| Last Night, post #15 |
|
2 | 13.33% |
| The Luck of the Draw, post #16 |
|
5 | 33.33% |
| Multiple Choice Poll. Voters: 15. You may not vote on this poll | |||
![]() |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
#1
|
|||
|
|||
|
Voting produces endorphins! - try the Anthology Thread, SDMB Short Fiction Contest, May 2012 edition
Hello, everyone, and welcome to the Anthology Thread of the SDMB Short Fiction Contest, May 2012 edition. The poll will appear in about 58 hours.
A quick recap of the rules - At 9 AM EDT, Friday, May 4th, 2012, I posted a link to a photo (found by random means) and also three words (again, obtained by random means) in an auto-reply message at sdmbpoetrysweatshop at gmail dot com. Writers still have until 10 PM EDT, Monday, May 14th, 2012 to write an original piece of short fiction, no more than 2,000 words in length, based in some way on that photo and those three words. All interested participants will be working from the same compulsory material. As of the posting of this thread, there will still be ~58 hours left to any interested participants. Writers - send your completed work to me, preferably in a .doc format, at sdmbpoetrysweatshop at gmail dot com before 10 PM EDT, Monday, May 14th, 2012. I will verify that it is 2,000 words or less, and I will post it in this Anthology Thread. Please include your SDMB username, and please let me know if your story incorporates any special text such as bold, italic or underline. (These codes do not always transfer directly, and I do want your stories to look right.) I will post the stories as a ~100 word teaser, followed by the rest of the story in a spoiler box, (Click the button labeled 'spoiler' to reveal the text, for those not familiar with the SDMB.) with the authors' names in separate spoiler boxes. At 10 PM EDT, Monday, May 14th, 2012, a multiple choice poll will be established to determine the readers' favourite story. I would also ask voters to choose those stories that have incorporated the compulsory material in the most interesting manner. At the end of a week, the poll will close and we will declare a winner of the PoeHenryParkerSaki award. The poll, once established, will be a secret ballot type poll. No one need ever know how you voted. I would, however, encourage everyone to please vote. You are providing an important source of feedback to the writers. While we welcome readers' comments, may I please request that readers hold off until after the poll is established. That way, the first posts in the thread will all be the various stories. After the poll is established, your comments are enthusiastically encouraged. The compulsory material is - The Photograph and the following three words - Anonymity Drift Radar And now, here are the stories that this contest has produced. I want to point out - the authors' user names are in spoiler boxes at the end of the stories. Please do not be fooled by the fact that they appear in 'replies' sent by me - only one of these stories is mine. Enjoy! Le Ministre de l'au-delà |
| Advertisements | |
|
|
|
|
#2
|
|||
|
|||
|
The Infinite Theater
Benjamin Green said, to no one in particular, “I need a change in perspective,” not suspecting his absent minded utterance would later be heeded.
He sat at his desk, hunched over his computer, with shoulders pulled taught towards his neck and stomach clenched, despite the fancy Swedish chair he had acquired to help with his posture. One hand draped lazily over the mouse, with his forearm perched painfully on the edge of the desk. The other hand digging into his thick black curls as though expecting to snag them on a loop, pull his skull open, and start tinkering with the clutter inside. SPOILER:
SPOILER:
|
|
#3
|
|||
|
|||
|
The glitch
I called myself an artist, but in reality I was just drifting through life with no clear purpose. I was working on a little photo project, a little time lapse thing to sell tourists of various San Francisco landmarks. I set my cameras up around the city and programmed them to take a picture once every half hour. I decided to include one house on a steep street that had always intrigued me. I was looking through the proofs, trying to find the right mix of pictures to photoshop into the time lapse when I saw the picture. At exactly 1:05 pm the picture of the house was tilted.
SPOILER:
SPOILER:
|
|
#4
|
|||
|
|||
|
A Prince of Parys
I’ve always loathed calls from family, as they usually mean one of two things: either said family member is in trouble, or said family member *is* trouble. Neither is preferable to the other as both usually mean a good deal of work…and I am nothing, if not lazy. So when I began to feel that distinctive tingle, that prickling in the back of my head that felt like a combination of pins and needles and dread, I have no doubt that the subconscious sneer that came to my lips transmitted perfectly across the connection that began to form in my mind.
SPOILER:
SPOILER:
|
|
#5
|
|||
|
|||
|
Tough Love
I drove up the hill, parked my truck where I saw an empty spot on the side of the street, and checked the address next to the angled door. This was the place. I could hardly that there was a free parking spot, right where I needed it to be. "Every job should be so easy."
That made me laugh. This job was not going to be easy, and the hard part hadn't been finding Felicia's address, or even the parking spot. It wasn't going to be a question of overpowering her physically either, or magically - so I guessed. Maybe I should just give up - go down to Fisherman's wharf and find something good to eat. Or maybe try the Mission... SPOILER:
SPOILER:
|
|
#6
|
|||
|
|||
|
Collisions
We're like planets floating through space sometimes. Endless, graceful, sometimes lovely, but often so far apart we don't connect at all, our faces and names all wrapped in a cosmic anonymity. It takes a collision to make us notice. Those collisions are almost always random-seeming, usually painful, but every once in a great while lead to something breathtakingly beautiful.
It was colder than I'd expected it would be. I was walking through the streets of Sunrise Acres in Arizona in February. Somehow I'd always pictured Arizona as desert, and, by association, hot. As the bus had traveled there, however, it had actually snowed, and the desert had been, at least briefly, a blanket of white drift. It made the whole trip so far seem both serene and unreal. SPOILER:
SPOILER:
|
|
#7
|
|||
|
|||
|
The Wages of Sin
Anonymity was his friend. The best friend he had to help him keep under the radar of anybody who might take an interest in him and his chosen career. After all, to make a successful living as a burglar, one has to be careful and keep as low a profile as humanly possible. Not even his own parents knew where he was or what he did: he had not had contact with them in years.
SPOILER:
SPOILER:
|
|
#8
|
|||
|
|||
|
Old business
-Encrypted message-
“If my sources are correct, you need to leave the bay area.” “That’s lovely”, said Maya but I told you before to never bother me in this channel unless it is for business purposes.” Steve noticed that Maya was “typing” a reply on what it was likely a virtual keyboard on the carpet. “Maya, Is that weasel bothering you again?” “Yes, but he may be...” “Steve interrupted, I showed you the evidence, he is likely the one that sabotaged your early projects, whatever feelings you have for him you have to cut any communications with him. He may be the best inventor since Tesla but he may be trading with the enemy.” SPOILER:
SPOILER:
|
|
#9
|
|||
|
|||
|
The Sliding Floor
At first, I thought it was an earthquake. The ground shook, yes, but the only house that was affected was the coral pink three storey house that I had been keeping an eye on. There had once been a creek that ran through this area; it had been buried sometime around 1830. Once the house started to tip into the sinkhole, there was no time to think about why.
I knew the house had a gas stove and furnace. There was no telling where the gas line would have been severed, but there was no question that there would be a leak. Someone was bound to be phoning this in, but I knew there would only be seconds to get the old woman out. SPOILER:
SPOILER:
|
|
#10
|
|||
|
|||
|
With All The Lights On
Everything can change in a moment when you finally see. When you look at it from a different angle. Maybe the right angle, at long last. Because maybe you’d been wrong almost your whole life, and never knew it.
Bryan was special; anyone could see it. He had curly brown hair and grey eyes like summer rain. He had a quick grin and proud cheekbones. His mouth was just right: not too full, not too thin. He was both smart and a talented musician. He was slim and graceful, and wore an earring. He took it out go home that first summer, saying his parents would never understand. Never understand? In a city where people studded not just their ears, but their faces and lips, and inked their bodies with wild, colourful tattoos, how could his parents object to a small, simple gold hoop? It looked like a tiny wedding ring, and I used to imagine one of my own on my finger. Bryan and Jessie. I was just waiting. Sooner or later, he’d turn to me, and see me at just the right angle. See that I was beautiful, and he would want me. As much as I wanted him. But I was so very ordinary. SPOILER:
SPOILER:
|
|
#11
|
|||
|
|||
|
Three Drops
Finn moaned his distress, pale blue eyes rolling and dark hair slathered against his forehead with sweat. More animal than boy, his demeanour sought escape while his body was rooted to the marble floor of the clinic reception area. Sunlight flooded through the open door, golden and thick as treacle.
“He shouldn’t have his routine shattered like this.” His lead therapist insisted. The money wasn’t the issue, payment had been generous and in advance. It was genuine concern for the boy. There had been too many meltdowns, too many hideous, screaming rages. In fact, the boy shouldn’t be out of his secure room at this ungodly hour of the morning. Family visits weren’t scheduled until the afternoon. SPOILER:
SPOILER:
|
|
#12
|
|||
|
|||
|
The End
Mike felt the sun start to peek through the bedroom window and he rolled over on his side to wake Jeff, the love of his life and partner of 47 years. Unlike the touch of the warm sun on Mike’s back announcing the start of a new day, the touch of Jeff felt cold and final.
Jeff had died. Mike lay still. He thought of last night’s final kiss goodnight and how they had fallen asleep together on their sides, like proper spoons in a drawer, neither of them knowing this would be their last night together in warm embrace. Both would drift off peacefully in sleep, but only one would wake from that slumber this early morn. SPOILER:
SPOILER:
|
|
#13
|
|||
|
|||
|
City of the Living
The demon was staring at me again. Out through the park with the wire cart, over to Market and back down through the tree streets, picking up the beautiful things the dead ones can't keep in their suitcoats and pocketbooks and gas burners, end up near the bayfront again 47 and a half minutes and there he is three times in a row waiting. He had on a ball hat and blue t-shirt with a pocket on the front, and he squinted as he stared.
I can take staring, even from vaguely malevolent hell denizens. I just think it's rude. SPOILER:
SPOILER:
|
|
#14
|
|||
|
|||
|
Party at Billy's
As Marlon huffed up the hill in his new three piece suit, he wiped beads of sweat from his forehead with a handkerchief. He stood across the street from a house whose address matched the one he was given on the phone. The incline of the street Marlon had just walked a half mile up was so intense he had begun to sweat considerably.
The house, like the others in this neighborhood, was quite large and expensive looking. The half-mile long mountain-side of a street was one of many like it that were famous in San Francisco. SPOILER:
SPOILER:
|
|
#15
|
|||
|
|||
|
Last Night
December 21st, 2012
11:47 p.m. When the wind howled outside, drowning out the Christmas music coming out of his hand-crank emergency radio, Elliot wrapped his dirty blanket more tightly around himself and stared out the window. Even by the light of his sputtering candles he could see that the snow that had been steadily falling all night had begun to creep up to the midpoint of his windows. If the windows he was looking out of hadn't belonged to the house's second story, this might not have seen so strange. SPOILER:
SPOILER:
|
|
#16
|
|||
|
|||
|
The Luck of the Draw
It’s been thirty years now since The Big One. When I think back to my life before that, it’s as if I’m remembering someone else, a completely different person. I can live with that, not that I have much choice, ha ha. But still, sometimes, I hear this little voice asking me if I’d make the same choice a second time. And I’ll wish, just for a moment, that I could have a “do over”. The mood never lasts for long, but when it hits I’ll mix up a pitcher of Margaritas, take a big book I’ve been saving for the occasion, (I’ve got a big stack) , turn on the little reading light by the big recliner in my home library, and try to immerse myself in a new world. If the book is good enough, sometimes it works. My dachshund Limo likes these times, he gets a lot of personal lap time and cuddling. Old ladies who have been drinking Margaritas don’t move around much, It’s read, doze, slurp, pet the dog, rinse and repeat.
SPOILER:
SPOILER:
|
|
#17
|
|||
|
|||
|
When does the poll start?
|
|
#18
|
|||
|
|||
|
This evening after the contest entries are closed. I think it's in the OP.
|
|
#19
|
|||
|
|||
|
Subscribing.
Wow, there's some fine talent in here. |
|
#20
|
|||
|
|||
|
I'll check back a little later to see if the poll is up yet.
|
|
#21
|
|||
|
|||
|
There - the poll is established and the voting may begin. My apologies for the lateness of the poll - I just got back from a fantastic closing night performance of 'Les Contes d'Hoffmann' at the Canadian Opera Company.
I'd also like to encourage readers and authors to comment on any or all of the stories. Please, try not to mention the authors' names until the poll is closed. Authors - I'll leave it up to you to whether or not to mention your own name while the poll is still open. I'd also like to congratulate the group of writers once again - what an interesting diversity! I'm always amazed to see how the writers take the compulsory material in very different directions. And once again, I'm quite impressed at how well the authors have written within time constraints that don't allow much time for editing. Now, I get to read more deeply, and savour everyone's work. |
|
#22
|
|||
|
|||
|
It says to vote for your favorites. Is that one, three, five? I know three I'd like to check off.
|
|
#23
|
|||
|
|||
|
Quote:
I generally vote for every one that I really like, which can sometimes be almost half of them if not more. |
|
#24
|
|||
|
|||
|
I'd like to say that "The End" put some tears in my eyes. That was a sweet story, but so sad.
I envy those two guys, they know how "Mad Men" turns out! And to have found someone you could grow old with. |
|
#25
|
|||
|
|||
|
Wow, some people got through all these stories pretty quickly. I've only read the first five. Some great stuff in here so far. I'll comment on each one later.
|
|
#26
|
|||
|
|||
|
Le Ministre, please ignore the PM I just sent. The one selection I though wasn't showing does show now. Sorry about that.
|
|
#27
|
|||
|
|||
|
Wow - some really great entries here...my own feels rather pedestrian comparatively. :P Of the lot, two struck me as particularly tight stories: With All the Lights On and The End. I know that I struggled with the 2000 word limit, and felt my story was just getting started when I reached it and had to tie things up. I've also noticed that a number of these stories feel brief, abbreviated, which I feel is likely because of this as well. How odd that 2000 words seems so few to tell a story in!
With All the Lights On runs a bit over the limit, but it doesn't feel like there is anything that can be shortened. It is a really good, really sad story of dreams destroying reality and likewise being destroyed by reality. The End is just sweet, sad, and touching...and I think my favorite of the lot. |
|
#28
|
|||
|
|||
|
These contests seem to get better and better. Of the stories that really clicked with me, here's my arbitrary impressions, in reverse alphabetical order by story title.
With All The Lights On (Post #10) Likes: The author took the idea of perspective as the theme and gave us a story about the shifting of an important personal paradigm. I appreciated the verisimilitude achieved in detailing the narrator's alienation and self loathing, and the disintegration of her marriage due to her growing apathy. The description is both painful and numbing, but the author's use of language is inventive and crisp, full of sensual imagery and evocative allusion which pulled me into the story and made me feel the main character's turmoil. You can't write a story like this and not care deeply about people, I think. Comments: I wish the final release of self blame and re-embrace of life / intended rapprochement with David had been portrayed as a bit more progressive over a period of time, to show a more natural course of Epiphany -> Internal Processing -> Behavior & Attitude Change. Arbitrary Rating on a xenophon scale of 0 - 41: 40 The Wages of Sin (Post #7) Likes: The story is well structured and the pacing is well done. The author dealt with the description and effect of the painting quite cleverly, and I liked this way of using the photograph in the challenge. Comments: This isn't, actually, the first guy-gets-trapped-in-a-painting story I've run into, but it's a good tight take on the idea. I wish there had been a bit more "value added" in the last scene -not to explicate the painting or the old lady's possession of it, but to deepen the mystery a bit. As it was, because of her muted reaction, it seemed a sort of pro forma ending to me. Arbitrary Rating on a xenophon scale of 0 - 41: 35 Tough Love (Post #5) Likes: The author chose wisely I think to concentrate more on the family drama than on the use of magic, which I think is used well in this story as a device to set up the conflict rather than as a central aspect. So the fantastical element seems to provide a solid background to the narrator's ethical struggle as a parent and officer of the [magical] court, rather than to get in the way of the telling. Good use of the arbitrary words, and I thought this story was written quite professionally. It felt like it could be a chapter within a larger story (where the ethics of magic could be explored a bit more deeply). Comments: I wanted the choice of the planarally challenged dwelling by Felicia to be a bit more meaningful to the character or the story. (By the way, did the author have actress Felicia Day in mind when naming the daughter?) Arbitrary Rating on a xenophon scale of 0 - 41: 38 Three Drops (Post #11) Likes: In this one, the magic is both central to the story & characters and the source of conflict between Ceridwen and Taliesin. Although preexisting knowledge of the characters isn't necessary to enjoy this story, I had never read the Tale of Taliesin, so I researched a synopsis - I like stories which prompt me to other, older works. I liked the playful use of the tilted houses photo. Comments: Some of the actions and dialogue are a bit confusing, but I can't tell if this is deliberate on the author's part. Arbitrary Rating on a xenophon scale of 0 - 41: 39 The Sliding Floor (Post #9) Likes: Nice urgency to the story that pulled me into the immediate dillema of the rescue and set me up nicely for the reveal of the narrator's true purpose in watching the house. Yet another interesting take on the contest image. Comments: Why did the firemen open the suitcase? Arbitrary Rating on a xenophon scale of 0 - 41: 39 A Prince of Parys (Post #4) Likes: Always glad to revisit Zelazny's Amber universe. I thought the tone and the intra family intrigue stayed true to the source material, and made me want to read the books again. Comments: This story would be good as an intro to a novella or as a teaser for same, but isn't actually very compelling as a stand alone story. Arbitrary Rating on a xenophon scale of 0 - 41: 35 Last Night (Post #15) Likes: Nice payoff here. [Clarke reference]Overhead, without any fuss, the stars kept twinkling just as they had been.[/Clarke] Comments: Points off for mispelling "Nietzsche" just a bit too egregiously. Arbitrary Rating on a xenophon scale of 0 - 41: 35 The End (Post #12) Likes:I'm a sucker for well delivered maudlin 'enduring love' stories. This one is well delivered and quite maudlin, so it pulled me in and choked me up. Comments: If the author knows how Mad Men ends, there's a certain ethical obligation to the rest of us that hasn't yet been fulfilled... Ahem. Arbitrary Rating on a xenophon scale of 0 - 41: 38 City of the Living (Post #13) Likes: I enjoyed the process of writing this one a lot, starting with considering the photo, and the ways one might accidentally or purposefully achieve the perspective chosen by the photographer. It led me to think about laying down on the sidewalk as a pov and what kind of person or situation would lead to that action, which set me up with the homeless man who became my unreliable narrator. Comments: This is a story I might go back to as a reclamation project. It could use a better paint job, perhaps an expansion and a new roof. Arbitrary Rating on a xenophon scale of 0 - 41: z |
|
#29
|
|||
|
|||
|
The Infinite Theater I found this overwritten the change came too fast, and the epiphany is not profound enough to justify the story.
A prince of Parys This was very well written, but I got lost quick and never really found my way back in. I felt like I was overhearing the last half of a conversation and never understood it. Tough Love Well written, the magic stuff was incorporated very naturally and the plot was done well. I never felt the characters were actually related though, there was nothing emotionally going on between them. Collisions This seemed to take forever to get started. Once it did it got really good though. Really liked the short scene at the diner. Wages of sin I really liked the bit at the end with the old woman. However, it felt rushed and I never felt anything about the burglar. Old businessI found this confusing. There was alot going on with the old lover, the rascist army guy, the beautiful genius inventor, the missile. I am still not sure what happened to incapacitate the sub or exactly what the setting was. The Sliding Floor Well written, but the part about him knowing there were only seconds to get the woman out and then he spends several minutes in the house, really bumped me. How many gas explosions has the protagonist been in that he knows exactly how much time he has at every stage? I like the ending but felt the papers idea should have been introduced earlier. With All The Lights OnGreat story, really well done. The character was very real and very relatable. Covered alot of time quickly but never felt rushed. I thought the ending would have been much more powerful written sardonically instead of hopefully. Definetly the best story. Three DropsInteresting story, but I am not sure what is going on. This felt like a small part of something bigger not a short story. The End Maudlin subject matter that felt more like an obituary than a short story. The main character seems entirely non-plussed to wake up next to his boyfriend's corpse. Taking an entire bottle of pills one at a time does not seem possible. I will comment on the rest later. Last edited by puddleglum; 05-16-2012 at 03:15 PM. |
|
#30
|
|||
|
|||
|
I finally got through all the stories. Here are just a few comments.
The Infinite Theater: This story kicked off what was kind of a theme for this go-round of short fiction literature. It was very descriptive, but focused on a single character, which means no character interaction or dialogue to speak of. The prose was very nice, it was well-written. Maybe a bit slow for me. The Glitch: I liked this story quite a bit. It was a neat concept. There was great dialogue. I especially liked that the release of a new chicken sandwich at BK would be the identifier of the end of the simulation. Pretty clever stuff. A Prince of Parys: Awesome character names. I don't know if they are original or not, but they are sure more interesting than the John Smiths of the literature world. The writer used nice prose and was able to do a pretty good job of building suspense. However, I expected more payoff at the ened. Tough Love: This was a nice, easy read. There was some nice dialogue between characters. Good use of magic. I think someone else said it well, the magic was a very minor plot device so it didn't distract from the main point of the story. Very well done. Collisions: Great story. A well-written, easy read that gives a reader a nice warm feeling. Everything comes together very well by the end of the story so there are no loose ends. The Wages of Sin: Very cool idea. This story seemed quite short, which is perfectly fine, by the way. It wrapped up nicely. It did focus pretty much on one guy. It was somewhat unclear if we are supposed to think the old lady has trapped more than one person in that painting. She seemed to know what had happened. It would have been cooler if our burglar was just one of many in a crowd in the painting or something. Old Business: This was a quick read, maybe a bit confusing with people's relationships to each other. But I like that there were at least multiple characters interacting that really drove the story. The Sliding Floor: I liked this one a lot. It was mostly a descriptive narrative, but it was far from boring. The writer did a great job building some suspense and mystery throughout the story. The final payoff was not what I was expecting, exactly, but it worked great. With All the Lights On: This is a very well-written story by what I would assume is someone with a bit of experience writing fiction. I could see this story being published somewhere. It's hot and steamy in parts, but keeps it very real. I felt like it could easily be someone's real life narrative. All that said, the pace was a bit slow and the introspective reflections don't really hold my attention as well as other things. Three Drops: More interesting character names! And some great interaction between them, too. Nice use of dialogue, althought I felt like some characters were speaking in a very old-fashioned way. I had a bit of a hard time following the story, not quite sure what was going on all the time. The End: Similar to "With All the Lights On," this one was very descriptive, featured very nice prose, but lacked dialogue. It certainly aims to strike an emotional chord and it does a pretty good job of it. It's well-written, I could also see this one published. City of the Living: Very well-written, clever story. Cool idea. There was dialogue and interaction and a decent pace to this story that managed to keep my attention. I actually kind of liked some of the unusual sentence structures like "...I reckoned I'd choices three..." Party at Billy's My own story, I can comment on it later. Last Night: This one pretty much amounts to a very well-written character study to me. The examination of Elliot is very thoughtful and features nice styling, but I don't know if the pace works for me, personally. But again, nice prose and nice structure. The Luck of the Draw: I liked this one a lot. It was a lot of fun to read with quite a bit going, what with the Big One and then the kind of nanchalance the character manages to pull off while being slightly (maybe very) selfish. Great story telling. That's about it. There were quite a few slow paced character study type stories going on here. I think almost everybody set their story in San Francisco, which is obviously because of the picture, and despite that there were still a wide variety of interesting uses of the picture in the story. As usual, great job by all the writers and thanks again Le Ministre de l'au-delà for putting it together. |
|
#31
|
|||
|
|||
|
City of the Living I had to read this twice before I understood what was going on. It was very well done as far as character but nothing really happened. Could have used more plot.
Party at Billy's Lots of interesting stuff but it never really explained anything that happened or if it happened at all. Last Night Really well done, the character was done in a real way and the crisis was introduced in a very realistic way. The ambiguousness of whether the protagonist was correct or crazy or both gave the story dramatic tension. I did not understand why he stayed in the house, when he would have been more comfortable elsewhere. The Luck of the Draw This felt cold and distant to me. There is no sense of the emotion, the fear, the sorrow, the guilt. This felt like the outline of a story and not the story itself. |
|
#32
|
|||
|
|||
|
Ok, now that I have put out a few work fires, I can give more detailed thoughts on each story. I will check each for length, use of the words anonymity, drift, and radar, incorporation of the theme picture, and then my overall impression.
The Infinite Theater Length: 1,511 words Use of words: All three used within the story Use of image: Integral to the story Opinion: I like the concept here, of a person gaining introspective from the zen of staring into an "infinite theater", but I think that story suffers a bit by being heavy in prose and light in action. There is some great, if sometimes overwhelming description here, but by the time we get to the "meat" of the tale, where the character begins his introspection, the descriptiveness is dropped, the journey hand-waved, and it feels as if we are shorted because of it. So much time is spent describing what leads up to the theater that not having an equally rich description of what happens within robs the story, and the prior descriptiveness, of its power. This was no doubt an artifact of the length limitation - I'd be curious as to what paradoxes the author would have lead us down if this were a lengthier piece. The Glitch Length: 1,805 words Use of words: All three used within the story Use of image: Integral to the story Opinion: I like the idea of the narrator as a "glitch" in the program. I like how the whole setup is for something as mundane as a Burger King Chicken Sandwich. I like the acknowledgement that such an artificial reality would lead to the downfall of civilization. The story feels a bit stunted, however, and just kind of ends. There is no character growth that doesn't come from exposition - you don't know that the glitch ever believes or disbelieves. It just kind of ends. Otherwise, fun story! A Prince of Parys Length: 1,894 words Use of words: All three used within the story Use of image: A background element within the story Opinion: This was my entry, and I admit, I'm not super thrilled with it. I was struggling with where to go with the picture, wanting to do something sci-fi/fantasy like with the story, and so I decided to turn it into a writing experience, attempting to imitate the style and intonation of Roger Zelazny's Chronicles of Amber, but set in a "side" universe therein. I've always been intrigued by Zelazny's mastery of dialogue and intrigue, and was trying to capture that here. Unfortunately, I really feel that the length limit killed me - I wasn't able to weave the Machiavellian machinations tightly enough while still establishing character and plot. As xenophon41 observed, my objective reading of it makes it feel more like an introduction than a story - I should have focused a bit more on getting somewhere with it. I still think I could weave a pretty fun tale with it, but I don't quite have the chops to do it in so few words. And like puddleglum's observation, I think the story is hurt by using an existing universe that the reader may not be familiar with and doing so with no exposition, so it feels like "half a conversation." Barkis is Willin', the name Corwin is from the original series, the rest are names I chose. Sorry there wasn't more payoff in the end - I found myself hitting 1,800 words and panicked about getting *somewhere* with the story! LOL! Tough Love Length: 1,846 words Use of words: All three used within the story Use of image: A background element within the story Opinion: So very Dresden-esque - I take this was intentional? This could have come right out of the Dresden universe, and the use of language reads very much like something Butcher would write. As a huge fan of said 'verse, I very much enjoyed this piece. Like others have observed, however, I think the characters would have benefited from a bit more emotional development - the dad should have perhaps had more anguish over catching his daughter trying to escape the justice he was bound to enforce. Still, loved it! Collisions Length: 1,149 words Use of words: All three used within the story Use of image: The result of an action withing the story Opinion: On my second rereading of the piece, I wish I had voted for this one. It's an amazingly concise piece of fiction, telling a neat little story in very few words, a skill I obviously have yet to master. The repeated allusions to metaphorical objects in space (the girl with white/blonde hair as a comet, drifting through the cold) helped tie it all together nicely, and I appreciate the idea that seemingly random events can have wonderful consequences, and that pain can also lead to healing. Only one thing, one tiny thing, struck me as off - who would drink a milkshake during a cold snap, when they are already unprepared for the chill? Other than that, very impressive!The Wages of Sin Length: 1,046 words Use of words: All three used within the story Use of image: Integral to the story Opinion: This reads like an episode of the Twilight Zone, or Night Gallery, or something else Serling-esque - as a fan of such shows, I definitely appreciated the nod towards that style of fiction. I did feel this story was a little too short, however; it felt almost more like an episode synopsis than a short story. I would have loved to have had more tension built in, as the burgler perhaps felt irresistably drawn to the painting, and maybe some sort of nod that the old woman was also a practicioner of some dark magic...maybe have the burgler run across a strange set of books that seemed unlikely for the old woman to have. Just something to set up the existence of the painting and its power, and the lady's calmness regarding it. Old Business Length: 1,997 words Use of words: All three used within the story Use of image: Incidental background element of the story Opinion: I had a really hard time following this. The dialogue was very stilted and leapt about without much indication of who was speaking, the action within it seemed disjointed and confusing, and I just couldn't get in to it. I like the idea of a spy/agent/military themed story, but it just didn't connect with me. The Sliding Floor Length: 1,868 words Use of words: All three used within the story Use of image: Integral to the story Opinion: Another fun story - I love a good heist tale, and the idea of a would be thief risking life and limb to save the lady he was going to rob and than losing his target because of it is a fun one, even if it makes for a strange moral - Screw the old lady, next time, look for the loot! It took my second read through to realize that the old double spaced papers that surrounded the suitcase were the lost manuscripts - on my first read, I was wondering how he could have a memory of something he hand never seen, but a more careful reading revealed what I had missed. I do think it could have done with a better understanding of the narrator's motives - why was he willing to save her before going after his treasure? He didn't seem terribly concerned with her once they got to the room with the manuscript, even threatening to leave her if she didn't give him the location of the suitcase. Just a bit more insight into the mindset of the would-be thief would have been great. With All The Lights On Length: 2,292 words Use of words: All three used within the story Use of image: Sort of - the idea of angles and perspective, definitely, the actual image, no (unless I missed it) Opinion: Ok, so this one broke the rules a bit. Too long, no clear use of the image within the story, and yet...I think it's my favorite of the bunch. There is such a sense of reality to this piece, of honest, true emotion, of heavy regret and a broken heart. Strangely, though I pity the narrator, I don't care for her - probably because I have known too many who have wasted their lives languishing over what they never had rather than enjoying what they do have - and yet by the end of the story I feel such empathy for her. It is easy to imagine losing oneself in the fantasy of another, of being so desperately deep in unrequited love that the rejection of it casts a pallor over one's whole life. This may sound crazy, but in a way, the character her reminds me very much of my ex-wife, who in the end said she never loved me, and whom I long suspected had only married me because I was the only one who asked. That this story could elicit sympathy from me while at the same time reminding me of a very hurtful relationship is a definite achievement. Bravo. That's all for now - I'll finish up the rest tomorrow! |
|
#33
|
|||
|
|||
|
Yes, I know the feeling. My own story was starting to get rather lengthy, so I tried to wrap it up faster than I would have if I had another thousand words or so. And even when I finished the first draft I was about 50 words over, so it needed a little editing. Don't get me wrong, 2000 words is a perfect limit. I don't know how I'd read all those other stories if they were much longer.
|
|
#34
|
|||
|
|||
|
Earlier, I gave random impressions of the stories that most "clicked" with me, but I don't want to imply that the others didn't work for me on other levels. So here's my comments on the rest of the entries. No offense to anyone is intended; I'm truly proud to be among this group of writers and have enjoyed reading all of these stories.
The Infinite Theater (Post #2) Likes: The titular concept is a neat variation on infinite recursion, and the house of the photo seems like a good venue for such a project. Comments: I never got a feel for the background of the character's angst and didn't have any sense that the theater experience had helped him complete a path toward enlightenment or that he'd even been on such a path. The insights described in the story might have needed some more development of their significance. I think the author intended to render the zap! of an epiphany but it felt more like the whoa of Bill & Ted's Pop Physics Experience. Arbitrary Rating on a xenophon scale of 0 - 41: 32 The glitch (Post #3) Likes: The banal use of the technological advances in processing power and virtual world building is pretty funny, and probably the realest seeming aspect of the story. Comments: From a personal perspective, I find these 'universe is just a computer simulation' stories interesting mostly insofar as they show the high opinion programmers have of themselves, but they can be pretty fun. On a technical level, I found the exposition a little abrupt and contrived. Maybe it's the dropped punctuation and lack of contractions in most of the dialogue. Arbitrary Rating on a xenophon scale of 0 - 41: 30 Collisions (Post #6) Likes: The setup -the trip to Sunrise Acres without adequate clothing, the photo excursion to the monument, the cold and numbness and inattention leading to the collision- was all extremely believable and well rendered. I liked the consistent use of the metaphor, and the fact that the real lasting consequences to the narrator are due to the [gravitational] attraction of another sympathetic character into whose orbit the narrator has been jolted from the high energy 'collision' of the title. Comments: This is pretty much a "meet cute" story isn't it? The grandkids'll like it. Arbitrary Rating on a xenophon scale of 0 - 41: 38 Old business (Post #8) Likes: The situation and characters are imaginative. Comments: I tried my best to follow just the basic storyline, but the presentation is too disjointed for me. There's a lot going on and the storytelling doesn't give the reader a lot of help in figuring it out. Arbitrary Rating on a xenophon scale of 0 - 41: 26 Party at Billy's (Post #14) Likes: It's an intriguing puzzle for the young applicant and I looked forward to the solving of it. Comments: I never got the connection between any of the celebrities and Pres. Taft, other than that they all were alive during the 20's. I'd have liked some commentary from the guests, or some other discovery by the sleuth which developed this connection further. Arbitrary Rating on a xenophon scale of 0 - 41: 37 The Luck of the Draw (Post #16) Likes: I thought the pacing and construction of the story were good, and the convention experience was believable. Comments: Even though I knew the tone was intended to be more wistful than anguished, this story seemed like it should have been more emotionally involving, but it felt to me like a dry recitation of an old story. I wondered if that's what the author was going for, since the narrator is an octagenarian or better by the time of the telling. Arbitrary Rating on a xenophon scale of 0 - 41: 37 Last edited by xenophon41; 05-18-2012 at 11:39 AM. Reason: spelling |
|
#35
|
|||
|
|||
|
Some reactions as I read--
The Infinite Theatre Took the picture in a straightforward (heh) way and incorporated it into the story. Lovely paragraphs about San Francisco--made me long to visit the city again. I like the idea of working with the actual picture, and imagining what the building holds. The story wasn't at all what I was expecting. The Glitch Another writer who recognised San Fransisco immediately. "No more mistakes like the Edsel or New Coke..." made me laugh. Great ending! A Prince of Parys No fair! No resolution. I did like this, the sci-fi/fantasy theme. Tough Love I really liked this one. I liked the combination of magic and reality, and I liked the dynamic of the father-daughter encounter. Daddy's little girl isn't perfect. I liked the ending, as well. Yep, I enjoyed this story. I thought the writer did a great job of a beginning, middle, and an end, a climax, a resolution, and yet still left part of the story untold. Collisions Back to reality, and the magic of ordinary lives and coincidence. This one had a twist for me--I wasn't expecting the way it wrapped up. It felt a bit short; I could have done with a bit more detail at the end about the woman who would be so important. A nice tale! The Wages of Sin Interesting! Nice lead up, and I wasn't expecting the twist at all. A few typos near the end, but they didn't mar my enjoyment of the story. No wonder little security was needed. I felt this was tight and well-plotted, the author craftily leading us along. Very interesting usage of the prompt imagery, as well. Old Business I had a bit of an issue with the punctuation, as it sometimes made it unclear what was narrative and what was dialogue. But it was a fast-paced story, with a bit of danger, romance, humour, and tech all mixed in. It kept my attention. With a bit of editing for punctuation, this would be even better. I suspect that the writer's first language isn't English, if so, kudos all the more for writing a good story. The Sliding Floor Well done. Despite the chaotic setting, I could follow along, and the tension carried me through to the ending. Great twist, too. With All the Lights On Yeah, the narrator in this one was pretty grim. I wanted to slap her. Story was confusing, and too full of its own enjoyment of language. Needs a good editing. And word-trimming. Three Drops A little trouble with the punctuation; full stops in the middle of a sentence with dialogue. This chopped up the story in my head as I read it. I liked the usage of fantasy and reality mixed in together. I thought it was quite imaginative. The End This one really got to me. I thought it was very well written, and while I suspected what would happen as I read, it just felt natural. It was nicely paced, it seemed to be just the perfect length. The writing style is very good--no obvious errors that took me out of the story, and the feeling of something done by someone deft and talented. |
|
#36
|
|||
|
|||
|
City of the Living
I liked this one. I really liked the point of view it's written from, and the narrator. I thought it was really well done. Now when I see someone with a shopping cart, dirty clothes, and a distant look in their eye, I will think of this story, and wonder who pities who. Party at Billy's Not at all what I was expecting from the title! What an interesting idea. Dang, why can't I come with cool ideas like this? Last Night I liked this one, even if at first read I didn't know what made the house shift. Nicely told slide into obsession and despair at the end. The Luck of the Draw As someone who enjoys a thick book, an adult beverage and time with a little dog, this certainly appealed to me from the start. Really well written, and satisfied me as a reader. I liked the elements of luck and chance, and the narrator's admittance of what she'd done as well as the doubts about it, and the justification. |
|
#37
|
|||
|
|||
|
My votes are in. I wish I had the time to participate, but after reading these, I know I would have been up against some tough competition. Excellent work, all!
|
|
#38
|
|||
|
|||
|
I voted ages ago. The hamsters ate my comments and I haven't had the time to go through the stories again.
From memory, The End was my favourite (it seems a winner for others, too). You made me cry, you bastard. Close second, City of the Living. Loved the narrator seeing these 'superior beings' and being wholly unimpressed. Both of these were excellent examples of 'showing, not telling'. Their narratives were clear and right on point without having to spell out the action. It's something I tried to do in mine and fell short. Other votes: Party at Billy's. A couple of plot holes but too much fun to miss my vote. The money seems excessive for the 30's and how did Billy place the ad? He didn't seem to notice anything off about that experience. Collisions. Sweet little story. Loved the twist ending, seemed to commpletely invert expectations. And the others. There were no bad stories in here. I just voted for those that either hit me very strongly on the first read, or stayed with me so I looked forward to reading them again. This thread reads like any anthology I've picked up over the years. My favourites are only preference, not judgement. And xenophon41, a very belated thanks for your insight and score. I'm honoured. I'll be re-writing this one and will take everyone's comments on board, but I'm glad there's someone else who enjoys looking up the references. |
|
#39
|
|||
|
|||
|
This poll closes in roughly 38 hours and so far only it has only gathered 11 voters. I've appreciated the commentary so far and would love to hear from the authors and innocent bystanders who haven't weighed in yet.
|
|
#40
|
|||
|
|||
|
^^What Barkis is Willin' said.^^
I look forward to the analyses and interactions with the other writers, and it would be wonderful to have some criticism from non-entrants as well. If you haven't participated in a group like this, you may not know how valuable your insights are! Particularly the comments which point out techniques or voices or aspects of style that didn't work for you. Thanks to everyone who's participated, and thanks in advance to those who will. |
|
#41
|
|||
|
|||
|
I am usually pretty good at getting my comments posted about the other stories, but I am running woefully behind this time. My only excuse is that it has been a rough two weeks at work - 11 hour days - and today I am the only one in the office (with a boss who pops in regularly to see how things are going).
Part of the reason it is taking so long is there are so many good stories and I don't want to short-change anyone with feedback. I know I always look forward to hearing what others have to say, so I feel it is only fair to take the time to reciprocate in kind. I have a start on the comments and, with any luck, should have some posted later this afternoon. Last edited by DMark; 05-21-2012 at 10:46 AM. Reason: Stupid typo... |
|
#42
|
|||
|
|||
|
I still have to finish up my commentary, but had a huge stack of work plopped on my desk Friday, and had no time over the weekend to visit them. I will try to do so today or tomorrow!
|
|
#43
|
|||
|
|||
|
Okay, my vote is in. Thanks to Le Min for organizing this once again!
Some very rough thoughts on the other stories: The Infinite Theater - the concept of the paradox movie was interesting, but otherwise this didn't really get a big reaction out of me. The Glitch - very fun, and a little spooky. I love the characterization of the programmer. A Prince of Parys - interesting, but I feel like I'm missing something because I've never really read Amber. Collisions - another really good one, I loved the subverted expectations in terms of the 'meet cute.' The Wages of Sin - interesting, and I liked the ending, but actually felt it was too short, that I'd have liked a bit more development. Old Business - This didn't quite come together for me. The Sliding Floor - very exciting, but I wasn't quite clear on the details of the ending - SPOILER:
With all the lights on - not an immediate wow, but I liked it. I was wondering about the twist before it showed up, but it was handled nicely. Three drops - I didn't understand enough of this. The end - very bittersweet, I wasn't wild about the ending, but I understood how that choice made sense for the protagonist. City of the Living - compelling stuff. I'm not sure if this is what the author meant, but I had a sense that the narrator was struggling with what most people would call a mental illness - and yet, it was easy to identify with his perspective. THAT'S not easy to pull off at all. Party at Billy's - fun story, but I did wish that Marlon had gotten a little something to make up for the pay that Billy hadn't been able to provide. Last Night - this had an interesting concept, but I felt that the buildup and the ending were weak. SPOILER:
The Luck of the Draw - a great character piece. The one thing I'd suggest to improve is putting a name on the disaster, SPOILER:
__________________
Stringing Words Forum Aspiring writers and authors supporting each other. Goals and resolutions our particular specialty - also sharing commiseration and triumphs. Join today! |
|
#44
|
|||
|
|||
|
Maybe next time I'll come up with some objective rating metrics, but this time I'm just going to offer some random comments.
The Infinite Theater, post #2 Well I can't imagine a better story in this history of the universe. OK you got me, I wrote it. Strangely, I seem to end up as the first post very often in these threads, no matter when I submit my story. This time it seemed apt, as I saw a few other stories with a similar location or theme. I think my premise was pretty cool, but I did run into time and word limit restraints. I did have a more elaborate explication of the character's journey to enlightenment - the abruptness was entirely due to the limits. The limits were not responsible for the other common complaint - that this story was rather insular, with no interaction with other characters. That was intentional - it was supposed to be an exploration of a character that experiences growth purely as the result of introspection. However, the abrupt sequence where he experiences this growth might have been more interesting as he "interacts" with his own mind. The glitch, post #3 Continuing the theme somewhat, with a bit of 13th Floor thrown in. Only ten years, even ten years of riches, is a bit bittersweet, but I like it. I'm curious what happens when the simulation runs out... A Prince of Parys, post #4 I recognized this as an Amber fan fiction right away. I had trouble remembering the use of the picture after reading it. Interesting that we have another reality bending story. Not sure what to say about it since it seems like the first chapter of a later book in a series. Tough Love, post #5 More reality bending narrative! Interesting premise and execution. Although Felicia is set up as the antagonist, there are some things about the Father that make me wonder. Collisions, post #6 I liked the titular concept, which was poetic, but I'm not sure the stuff about the father integrated into the rest of the story. It seemed odd to be taking a picture for someone who was already gone. It might have worked better if the father was still alive but near death. The Wages of Sin, post #7 Clever burglar trap! Old business, post #8 Something wonky seemed to be happening to the quotation marks and gender pronouns and grammar, so I'm guessing it's our ESL writer. With all the action and choice of proper nouns it kind of felt like an episode of a Mesoamerican anime. I'd like to see this in graphic format, perhaps with some mecha. The Sliding Floor, post #9 I guess this was well written, because I winced several times. I liked the first twist but didn't quite get the second one. With All The Lights On, post #10 So very very bittersweet! Three Drops, post #11 The set up was very interesting, but I never quite understood the premise. I guess the family are some sort of divine beings, and the son's autism has caused him to put things at an angle? It wasn't clear how the brother had caused his autism or why he needed to die. The End, post #12 Another bittersweet tale.I found it amusing because I sometimes think about sticking around as a ghost after I die to see how my favorite comic book or TV series turn out. City of the Living, post #13 Another radar story! This was a fantastic story. I love the way it played with the way the world looks from a different point of view. I wasn't quite sure whether to take it literally or metaphorically, but it worked either way - perhaps that was intentional. I'd love to read more from this world. Perhaps a few shopping cart detective stories. Party at Billy's, post #14 Definitely an intriguing mystery, but either a better an explanation or a denouement would have helped the ending. Last Night, post #15 Because this was a story, the last thing I expected to happen was what would actually happen if this wasn't a story. Nice use of a non twist as twist! The Luck of the Draw, post #16 I liked the set up and characters. Given the date, I was expecting some kind of mass prank, not a mass disaster. The resolution seemed to be a little dark compared to the tone at the beginning, and the quandary about the tickets seemed a little beside the point. I especially liked mine, The Glitch, Tough Love, Three Drops, The End, City of the Living. City of the Living was my favorite, and I'd like to see it expanded. Good work everyone! See you next time. |
|
#45
|
|||
|
|||
|
Short Story Evaluation Rubric
25 pts Intro – was it a dynamic intro that grabbed attention and made you want to read more? 25 pts Body – did the story move along, coherently, and keep interest? 25 pts Conclusion – did the story have an ending that felt complete and fit with story? 25 pts Overall – personal opinion and like/dislike of style, subject, feel. Total: 100 pts Disclaimer: Please take my suggestions for changes with a grain of salt – a huge grain of salt. I am basically just thinking aloud how I would have written it, just to show you how someone else would have changed/ruined your story. Title: The Infinite Theater 25 pts Intro – Nice job! A clear statement and a hint of what is to come. Got my attention. 20 pts Body – nice, deep, philosophical tale with some great insight. You might have added some more examples of the paradox to show how his life is both insignificant, yet also wildly significant, in the grand scheme of things. 23 pts Conclusion – a bit rushed, but you did indeed wrap it up nicely. 20 pts Overall – this was a cool story and concept – some good food for thought, but I think there could have been just a tad more food for the thought. Total: 88 pts Title: The Glitch 23 pts Intro – Nice job, but would have piqued my interest more if you had said something more mysterious - along the lines of “At 1:05 the picture of the house was tilted, but the picture of the same house at 1:35 wasn’t. Houses don’t normally right themselves, do they?” 22 pts Body – I would have preferred to meet the time traveler sooner than later, and let him have some more fun making off-the-wall comments about the future; “When Burger King starts to market Ostrich burgers…” and let him make some wild predictions, “Make friends with Arnold Pinkers from Butte, Montana – he is about to create the first great flying car….” 22 pts Conclusion – the story seemed to end abruptly – and why would anyone turn down the results of the next ten Super Bowl games?! 21 pts Overall – really great idea, but missed out on some of the fun. Total: 88 pts Title: A Prince of Parys 25 pts Intro – Excellent opening statement! Made me want to read more! 20 pts Body – I got a little lost – was there a coup or not a coup? Is the king dead or not dead? What is amber and should I be on alert? 20 pts Conclusion – The story did end, but it sort of escaped me exactly what happened. Perhaps a final phrase, “The King took his son to the land of the….” with a bit more explanation for people like me who got a tad lost. 20 pts Overall – I liked the style and majesty of the story, but felt like I was missing Book 1 and 2 and was coming in at the wrong time and not knowing who was who or what was what. Total: 85 pts Title: Tough Love 21 pts Intro – OK, but it would have been more interesting to punch right in there with “Good news, I found a parking spot – bad news, I was about to arrest my daughter.” or something equally shocking – especially since this wasn’t a big “reveal” later in the story. 20 pts Body – to be honest, not a lot happened. It was a pleasant enough diversion and a nice read, but more along the lines of 5 minutes in a magical Law & Order episode. Nothing wrong with that, but could have used a kick of some kind – perhaps a more magical slight of hand. 24 pts Conclusion – the ending was good – nice to see dad be supportive and certainly brought home the “tough love” aspect, so you wrapped it up nicely. 20 pts Overall – could have used more of the magic, or description of the magic, to make this story more magical. Total: 85 pts Title: Collisions 24 pts Intro – Very nice opening – almost poetic. 22 pts Body – I liked the simplicity of the story, but was hoping for more of a payoff/twist somewhere along the line. Maybe the woman in the diner was the blonde thief but now with black hair? Maybe instead of stealing the wallet, she put a different wallet into his pocket? Not sure what other twists could have come, but I kept expecting one to show up. 22 pts Conclusion – wrapped up story quickly, and would have been fun to have that extra kick or twist as mentioned – but you let us know what happened and left no loose ends. 20 pts Overall – nice breezy style and good flow of words, but still feel there was a missed opportunity for a good “gotcha” somewhere in there. Total: 88 pts Title: Wages of Sin 24 pts Intro – nice start, and good intro to the career choice and set up that he would not be missed. 20 pts Body – good presentation of his tricks of the trade and his stealth and cunning. The evil variation of a Dorian Gray painting was interesting, but it was a bit unclear what happened to him. He was uneasy and then…disappeared? Passed out? Eaten by wolves? Body gone or not gone? 20 pts Conclusion – liked very much that the poor old woman was hardly a poor old woman, but am still a bit foggy on what exactly happened. 20 pts Overall – I like crime and mystery stories, but felt ripped off by this burglar and his tale. Total: 84 pts Title: Old Business 24 pts Intro – Nice. You did get our attention right off the bat. 20 pts Body – I was getting lost quickly – and I am still not 100% sure I understood everything. I think it needed to be clarified a bit more, as I see elements of a good story in there, but it did seem to be a bit confusing. 20 pts Conclusion – OK, now I was really lost – did the bad guy get blown up, or did he blow up the other or was he the good guy. Needs to be a bit better explained – perhaps in a short synopsis like “….and Steve never knew that Maya’s secret contact was….and that is how she….because they…..” or something like that. 20 pts Overall – I think my GPS wasn’t working as I got really lost with this story. Total: 84 pts Title: The Sliding Floor 25 pts Intro – got my attention and nice use of a sinkhole to explain the house situation, and hint at what is to come! 22 pts Body – I think it would have been more interesting to hear how he came about the info of the manuscript, and what might have been written, and why it was hidden, and all the grit and gore that went into saving it and hiding it all those years. The fire and the escape could have been zipped into a short paragraph, panic ending to the tale. 22 pts Conclusion – Nice ending, wrapped it up, but then made me realize there was more to the story that I wish I had known earlier. 22 pts Overall – I liked this story but wish it had been a bit more of a “lost treasure hunt”, with clues and hints and the culmination of years of searching than a simple, frantic grab and run. Total: 91 pts Title: With All The Lights On 25 pts Intro – Excellent statement, nice set up, we know something is going to happen – not exactly sure what, but something is going to happen. Yes, I want to read more. 23 pts Body – we got to know Jesse well – the innocence of youth and the despair of lost opportunity and unfulfilled dreams. It is too bad one of the words required for this story was “radar” and not “gaydar” – it could have saved Jesse a world of grief. I will admit this story could have been the prequel to my own story, and perhaps because it was so obvious to me, there was little surprise when Jesse read the magazine article. But yes, I knew many a Jesse who didn’t quite put the pieces together until much, much later. 25 pts Conclusion – perfect ending, with hope for one last grasp at happiness and this time, on solid footing without feeling like you were “settling” for second best. This wrapped up the intro in a perfectly tight bow. Nicely done. 25 pts Overall – even though I could see this ending coming a mile away, it was still a very well-written, melancholy journey to get there. You could have chopped a few words off here and there with another edit, but I haven’t a clue exactly where, so I will just leave that point. Total: 97 pts Title: Three Drops 24 pts Intro – This story started off great. We knew immediately we were dealing with a special kind of boy. 20 pts Body – as the journey progressed, I sort of got lost along the way. Lots of traveling but unsure where and for what purpose? This would have been time for the mother to reflect aloud and maybe clarify some of the mystery of the story. 20 pts Conclusion – the story was certainly wrapped up, but I think it left more questions than answers. 20 pts Overall – great beginning, but the story sort of lost its way on the journey to the end and I felt I missed some element that would have explained a bit more about the back story and the purpose for doing what was done. Total: 84 pts Title: City Of The Living 24 pts Intro – You got my attention and set the scene quickly and nicely. 24 pts Body – Too often, stories about street people are just using them as a backdrop. I really liked this approach of using that person as the center of focus. You touched the right note between crazy person, but maybe not all that crazy as we might think. 22 pts Conclusion – the mission was accomplished, but I think I personally would have liked to have heard exactly what happened – in a short statement – after the messages were given and received. 21 pts Overall – I liked this approach to the story and using an oddball character as the narrator. I think the story could have been fleshed out more with a bit more info on why the money and what was about to happen after the deed was done. Total: 91 pts Title: Party At Billy’s 22 pts Intro – Direct and to the point and set the scene, but it might have been good to include the thoughts of mystery and foreshadowing of this odd request. Something like “Marlon was sweating and worried about ruining his suit, although he had no idea why some stranger would pay him $5000 to wear it.” 21 pts Body – I liked the idea a lot! I think there were some missed opportunities for a few snippets of wisdom, a few clever observations and maybe an offhand prediction of things to come that actually did indeed become true. 25 pts Conclusion – the story wrapped up nicely. It was all a blur, but a great memory despite being cheated out of his wage. 22 pts Overall – as mentioned, some missed opportunities to play with the characters and give some insight on history and the future. Plus, there should have been a clever way for him to take something from the party to make up for the lost fee – valuable info or a souvenir? Total: 90 pts Title: Last Night 22 pts Intro – descriptive and set the scene, it seemed to lack a bit of focus for what was about to happen. I think this need more of a sense of urgency and a perceived sense of impending doom. 22 pts Body – I always wondered what went on in the mind of people who bought into these doomsday theories and it was cool to see how this all evolved and then dissolved. Although tricky to do, this would have been a great chance to show the panic and urgency that comes as the time nears. After all this time, when you are counting down to the end of time, there has to be a multitude of feelings pouring out. 25 pts Conclusion – kudos for just letting it be “another day”. I probably would have screwed this ending up and tried to be clever, and this ending did not need clever. 21 pts Overall – liked this idea and concept a lot. I just think the main character would have been a bit more frantic and would like to have seen the adrenaline start to rush in and the thrill and fear and doom and exhilaration all come to a crescendo before the loud silence of nothing. Total: 90 pts Title: The Luck Of The Draw 23 pts Intro – Nice set up. J might have tried to be more blunt with something like “They say the chance of winning a lottery is less than being hit by lightning. Well, those are good odds compared to what I went through.” 25 pts Body – you zipped right along and kept my attention the entire way. Things were happening right and left and I had no idea where this story was going – a good thing! 23 pts Conclusion – wrapped up nicely, but not quite sure why the guilt as there was no mention of sharing the prize, was there? And she didn’t know who would have won – and after all those years, I would think she would be over it. 24 pts Overall – this story moved along quickly and kept my interest. A few quibbles about the guilt factor but it was still a fun story and a good read. Total: 95 pts Sorry this took so long for me to finish and post. Busy time at work and just took longer than i thought it would to finish. |
|
#46
|
|||
|
|||
|
Is it really less than 4 hours until the end of voting?
|
|
#47
|
|||
|
|||
|
Yes - the poll ends at 12 minutes past midnight my time. Just around 26 minutes left...
|
|
#48
|
|||
|
|||
|
And the winner is...
With the close of the poll, the SDMB Short Fiction Contest, May 2012 edition, has come to an end. First of all, a warm round of applause and my heartiest congratulations to our writers -
jackdavinci Puddleglum Woeg chrisk ArrMatey! JoseB GIGObuster Le Ministre de l'au-delà Savannah maggenpye DMark xenophon41 Barkis is Willin' Elfkin477 and Baker. Take a well deserved bow, everyone! And it's my special privilege to congratulate the writer of the favourite story, DMark, whose touching story The End earned the most votes. Well done! A warm round of applause, everybody! I'd like to take this opportunity to thank the Mods for their ongoing support. Their help was most welcome, and I am once again grateful. I also want to express a very special thanks to chrisk and xenophon41 for their help when the photo was temporarily unavailable due to 'exceeded bandwidth'. I really appreciate your generous assistance. I would also like to thank all those who took the time to read, vote and comment on the stories - on behalf of all the writers, we really appreciate your respectful and thoughtful advice. I hope to run another of the Short Fiction Contests around the end of July, 2012. In the meantime, if anyone is interested, I want to do another Poetry Sweatshop around the beginning of June, 2012. Meanwhile, please continue to discuss the stories and comment on them - it is very helpful for all of the writers to see how people reacted to their writing. |
|
#49
|
|||
|
|||
|
I am in both for the poetry and the next fiction contest!
I *will* be getting to the rest of my comments as soon as possible...just been crazy busy at work! |
|
#50
|
|||
|
|||
|
Congrats and well done, DMark! That story has choked me up every time I've re-read it so far.
And great job with the stories and comments, everybody! |
![]() |
| Bookmarks |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | |
|
|