So I ask Le Companion to pick up a block of cheddar while in store for other things, and I add “get the sharp or the extra sharp”. I am asked “How is it different?” I answer in a somewhat disparaging manner that I am astonished that she does not know. Sharp cheddar is
…sharper?
Well, OK, I could describe the difference in taste with other adjectives, but I was in mid-realization, as it was now dawning on me that unless each hoop is sampled and graded by cheese samplers, that wasn’t much of an explanation. If there’s something different that they do to it to make it sharp or mild or extra sharp or medium or whatever, I don’t know what it is any more than she does.
Any of you Vermont or Wisconsin folks in a position to clue me in?
It’s definitely the aging time. I once bought a block of mild cheddar cheese, put it in the refrigerator and forgot about it. :smack: When I rediscovered it, I was able to enjoy a small feast of extra sharp cheddar cheese.
So, if he messes up and gets mild, just age it yourself.
I was unable to view the Powerpoint linked by QtM but I would suggest that the flavour development in Cheddar is not only about thiols. Proteolysis of the milk proteins is significant but breakdown of the milk fats or lipids is also important. The textbooks from my cheesemaking days are long gone but I found the following pdf which is consistent with what I was taught:
It must have been a long time. If I remember my cheese package right, sharp cheese is aged anywhere from 6-12 months, wheras mild seems to be around the 3 month mark. So that’s 3 months in the fridge. A block of cheese the size of a car battery wouldn’t last that long in my fridge.
An interesting fact: some cheeses are colored by dyes. Renard’s sells an excellent 2-year old “white” cheddar without the traditional dark yellow dye. It’s not pure white, just a very light yellow. Mmmmm. Slice me a slab and hand me a beer.
Feh. That’s mild to me. I’ve a block of cheddar in my fridge 9 years old! For me, aged doesn’t even start until 2 years, and doesn’t get good until 3 or 4!
As far as I know, all orangeish and reddish cheddars are dyed. Traditionally, natural coloring made from annatto seeds (aka achiote) are used.
As for keeping cheese from getting moldy. In a reasonably dry environment, you don’t have to worry about that too much. But if the cheese does start getting molding, you just take a damp wet cloth and wipe the mold off. Another option is waxing the cheese.
It’s got a nice wax seal on it. I bought it at the specialty shop at age 8, and am keeping it around a bit longer.
I had a 5 pound wheel of cheddar we took to 10 years once before it got et. Now that was so sharp I could shave with it. But I used it on english muffins and in omelets instead.
To get to the cheese, you’ll have to get past the ostrich summersausage, the vegemite, the marmite, the habanero jelly, the pepper extract sauce, and some birch syrup. The spruce jelly went bad and had to be tossed.