So, I trust we’re all familiar with Pascal’s Gambit. The cite brings up one of the thornier questions of the gambit, although doesn’t really address the question of whether doing good things to get a reward is a sufficiently pure motivation in order to get into heaven.
I’d like to focus on that question with regard both to my understanding of Christian theology (rather limited, will need some help here) and how to get into heaven, especially considering the Prodigal Son and related stories.
For simplicity, let’s say that “good” = things that when done will get you into heaven and “evil” = things that when done will prevent you from getting into heaven.
Pascal’s Gambit assumes that getting into heaven is worth doing the good things, which are presumably not as much fun as the evil things or else everyone would do the good things and not even thing about doing evil.
However, we have Christian stories of “prodigals” who either renounce or do not believe Christianity and perform all manner of evil acts until one day when they see the light (as it were), repent and begin doing good. The Prodigal Son and Agustine are the two examples I am most familiar with.
So, if that’s the case, it appears that I can still win Pascal’s Gambit if I were to, at some point before I die, repent and begin doing good. Why should I bother to do good for my entire life then? The only reason I could think of is that I have no knowledge of when I will die and if it so happens that I die while still evil, the I will not go to heaven.
Perhaps the question will need to bring in the additional factors of God’s will vs. free will and whether or not one is able to “believe” as easily as the Gambit supposes they can.
If God’s will is paramount, that is everything is predestined, than I don’t have to worry because what will be will be (of course, I get into the trap that my not caring is part of God’s will, etc.). But, if there is free will, I believe that my original question is still valid.
The matter of belief is more difficult. How much belief is required? Is it simply enough to do good things because one believes that they should be done and pay lip service to Jesus?