I love the original movie. (I have grave suspicions about anyone who doesn’t. Wanna make something of it?) I haven’t seen the Broadway version of The Producers and most of the reviews of the movie haven’t been promising. But, hey, it was supposed to be good, old fashioned Mel Brooks. And the last movie I saw The History of Violence and I had to wash the awful taste of that puke out of my brain.
And the movie is funny. Not great, but funny. The funniest movie I’ve seen in a long time, in fact.
I was really worried at the beginning, though. The first few minutes are a near exact replica of the original film and all any fan can think during those few minutes is how great, how much better, how irreplaceable Zero Mostel and Gene Wilder were. Much the same feeling I had while watching Spamalot. Comedians don’t get full credit for originating roles, even though normal actors can never step into their shoes and be as, well, comedic. Lane and Broderick are road company imitations of their betters, and my skin crawled.
Fortunately, the new material mostly makes up for it. Once the musical kicks in and the silliness starts, Brooks’ inspired bad taste sweeps you along. There’s a real difference between Brooks’ offensiveness and that of modern comics, at least in this movie. His bad taste makes fun both of what it’s satirizing and of itself. The stereotypes are so over-the-top that they become huggable.
Uma Thurman is totally miscast as Ula. She plays it as a role rather than inhabiting the part. Will Farrell, to my surprise, does the Nazi playwright to a fare-thee-well. He’s not Kenny Mars, but he isn’t Will Farrell either. Jon Lovitz has a scene-stealing little role that’s excellent. Roger Bart and Gary Beach are carried over from the play and know exactly how far to stretch believability. Far.
And the Springtime for Hitler play inside the play is a killer.
Yes, the reviews are right when they call it a filmed play rather than a movie. So? Why would you want to open this up and let the real world in? The movie is only a shaggy joke story to begin with.
Fans of old time comedy, relax and rejoice. It’s safe to go back to the movie theater.