The original article can be found here:
The idea is that the plane takes off on a conveyor belt going in the opposite direction at the same speed and the plane achieves flight… right? But that’s impossible.
The flight of an airplane is based on lift and I don’t think I have to explain that in detail.
Here’s a question… when you run on a treadmill does wind suddenly accelerate past you? No… it doesn’t. The air current stays relatively stable. If you were to run outside though you would notice as you run you feel wind resistance against you. Stick your hands out a car window on the highway and you can experience lift for yourself. I guarantee though that if you put your arms out the wind while you are car was accelerating on a moving platform going in the opposite direction at equal speed… you would be disappointed.
The only thing really being worked on a plane in that scenario is the wheels of the plane. You still don’t have enough fluid force going around the air foils to create any upward lift even though you have acceleration.
To further my point… imagine a plane in a vacuum with this same set up. Obviously there is no lift because there is no air flow. The plane can’t take off. But it’s not just the lack of air, but also the lack of acceleration AGAINST the air.
You are accelerating the plane in this scenario, but you’re not accelerating it against the air current. Ever notice that a in a wind tunnel a model plane can be in a still state and attain lift once the wind is turned on? The acceleration isn’t what is important. It’s the air going around the foils at increased speed.
:\