For the most part I liked it. Obviously, it was originally meant to be just the season finale, and the announcement of cancellation came so late that I doubt they had time to actually change anything, and although the show had been on the bubble for awhile, I haven’t heard any stories of them filming an alternate ending ‘just in case’ like Everwood did.
Mark: I wanted to slap him when he started drinking. But at least he pulled himself together in time to warn the world of the impending blackout. And we saw foreshadowing of a kickass throwing himself out of a window at the last minute to escape a huge explosion. Unfortunately, this seems like a doomed endeavor given that it would be hard to hold on to the helicopter when he passed out due to the flashforward, and it would also be hard for the pilot to continue to fly. But hey, if he had to go, this was the way to do it.
Demetri: I half expected him to throw himself into the accelerator to stop the impending reaction, thereby saving humanity and also self fulfilling his lack of flashforward. The other of me expected him to get knocked out by a bad guy and thus similarly fulfill his flash forward. I’m glad he completely and utterly defied his fate in all respects.
Simon: He redeemed himself for the most part, although he was never truly a bad guy, just someone caught in the net of more powerful and nasty people. I wonder what he would have thought, had he seen this moment instead of being immune to the flashforward from the ring? OTOH, if I realized that the reactor was about to go off, I wouldn’t bother trying to hack it, I would start pulling out wires and pulling power switches. Or maybe even shoot it. Of course, what would a second potential season do without another FF. OTOH, fool me once, shame on me. Fool me twice, shame on you. After the second time the reactor amplifies the FF, there would be riots around the world demanding the thing be dismantled and burned to a crisp.
Olivia: I wanted to slap her too for pressuring Mark to let millions of people die for the sake of their relationship when she couldn’t even be bothered to resist the charms of Lloyd for a few months. Geez. At least she tried to change things at the end by going to the beach. OTOH she really does seem to be better suited to Lloyd.
Nicole: Her real problem was, hiding that she knew where Keiko was, wasn’t so much a crime against Bryce, since he had told her he didn’t care about Keiko anymore. Rather is was a crime against Keiko who didn’t deserve to be in a detention facility, and didn’t deserve to be left in the dark if Bryce no longer wanted to fufill their flashforward. So I think Mark was justified in being angry at her, not for being a dick to him, but for being a dick to Keiko. I’m glad she went off the road by accident, and not on purpose. I’ve heard behind the scenes, that originally she wasn’t going to be drowning, instead she was going to be undergoing a baptism (hence the whole winder washer prophet guy thing that was set up).
Bryce: While what Nicole did was a bit cruel, he was a bit of a dick to her, too, in setting her up for disappointment. OTOH he and Keiko do seem made for each other. I actually really liked their overall plot line. Unlike other viewers, I don’t consider romantically theme plot threads to automatically be soap operas. I wouldn’t have wanted to watch the series if every episode was solely a detective story about Mark looking for the conspirators. What a wasted potential that would have been! There’s so many other stories to explore with this premise of knowing your possible future, and I’m glad they took the time to get into those.
Aaron / Tracy: Her having a low pulse and being thought dead only for them to realize that she was actually alive was silly. But I liked his phone call with Mark.
Stanford: well he wasn’t reading a newspaper, but he was in the bathroom. Not sure what to make of that.
Janis: I liked her storyline, trying to stop the accelerator, with her baby issues acting as a way to get the gat code and simultaneously letting her escape to the hospital. I also liked that the gender of the baby was different. It was a little freaky when we see X-Files chick wheeling her out of the hospital though.
The flashforwards: this was a little bit confusing. There was no clear correlation with each character and a specific flashforward like we had before, except for the last one with Charlie. We saw several dates - March 2011, I think 2015 also? And the implied farther future date of an older Charlie. So there’s a baby baptism, someone loading a gun, Charlie saying they found ‘him’, a wedding… Not sure what to make of that.
It was emotional. Got a little teary. Not sure if that was legitimate or just the use of the Funeral song by Band of Horses. Either way it worked.
I’ll miss this show. Whatever problems it may have had, the mystery part of it was smartly written and had well paced pay offs. And it leaves me wanting more. Here’s hoping there’s some kind of follow up.