Nobody seems to believe me, but I keep contending that hippies were essentially 0% of the youth population even in the 60s and early 70s.
The vast number of people were what the real hippies called “plastic hippies,” or people who mouthed the words without ever committing to the total package. They grew their hair, they smoked pot, they went to rock concerts and shouted whoooooo a lot – and then on Monday they went back to work and their normal lives.
Only tiny numbers ever lived on communes. And only tiny numbers of them lived there for long. Communes are farm communities and those are large amounts of backbreaking work. It wasn’t that hippies didn’t like work, as the stereotype had it. Intensive small-scale organic farming was dying everywhere by the 1960s. Farmers were mechanizing and chemicalizing and organizing like crazy just to keep alive. Even with a core of intensely dedicated and knowledgeable people, this would have been hard for newcomers to the land to pull off. Most, admittedly, were not dedicated and not knowledgeable, and certainly not intense. Communes have a long history in the counterculture of America (see Brook Farm) and they never last.
In between were the visible hippies, the ones who formed small communities in every city, and ran head shops or food co-ops or whatever. They existed everywhere, but were a negligibly small proportion of the population.
The rest of the population simply grew up and went on with their varied lives. Asking how the hippie generation could have voted for Reagan like asking in twenty years how people with pages on Facebook vote. By then, being on Facebook will be one small aspect of being young and have little to do with their everyday lives and opinions.
The 60s were massively important in many ways because they represented the rise of many serious changes in societal attitudes. The Civil Rights movement was one of the best things this country ever did. It also solidified Republican control of the south. The Womens Rights movement was long overdue, but it created post-feminism which is not tied to any party. Gay rights is still a work in progress. Repressive attitudes toward sex were battered aside, but large backlash groups exist to combat it. The country as a whole moved to what used to be the left, but the world just redefined right and left and created a new normal around a new center.
There were few hippies. There were tens of millions of plastic hippies, yes, me included. That’s the real answer. Nobody much likes to hear it, though.