According to this Slate.com article, it’s not so easy for a lawyer to drop a client. I actually didn’t realize there was an issue. I’ve always figured that a lawyer works for the client but can still make decisions on whether or not he’s able to fulfill his contract. If he can’t, he can quit
Here’s the part of the article that bugged me, and I severely disagree with this:
And people wonder why lawyers get a bad rep sometimes. If I’m reading it right, the lawyer’s not even supposed to be only defending or upholding the law, but also the client’s interests, and if there’s a conflict, it’s not automatically what’s legal that wins out???
Why is this allowed? Specifically, a court is supposed to get to the truth, protect people, uphold our society, yada yada yada, but here you have a lawyer who knows the client’s going to lie and he can’t tell anyone?? Fuck that! Shouldn’t the law be able to step in at this point and say “You know what? We have laws against perjury, you can’t lie to a court, so if a lawyer finds out about the client lying, then yes, go ahead and spill the god damn beans. The client’s a liar and he should be punished. If he doesn’t want the jury to suspect something, then DON’T FUCKING LIE”.
I’m not a lawyer, and I’ve had issues with how the law works, but this seems like cutting off the nose to spite the face. Laws are supposed to be followed. If they’re not, there’s punishment. To get to the truth and find out the proper person to punish or the correct and just conclusion, everyone must tell the truth. Then the judge or jury will decide. If you needed to break the law, that’s where the decision should rest. It seems like this “trilemma” is saying that if you really really think you’re innocent, or even if you just want a Not Guilty verdict, then it’s ok to lie as long as the result would have been what it would have been had you not lied in the first place.
I guess I wouldn’t make a good lawyer or a legislator, because the first thing I would do upon hearing my client’s gonna lie is to tell him don’t do it, and then call him out on it in the middle of the courtroom if he does lie. And as a legislator, I would strip that mandate from the law saying that lawyers can’t tell anyone their client is lying. That’s the truth. No one should ever be in trouble legally from telling the truth in a courtroom.