“Our landings in the Cherbourg-Harve area have failed to gain a satisfactory foothold and I have withdrawn the troops. My decision to attack at this time and place was based on the best information available. If any blame or fault attaches to this attempt, it is mine alone.”
- Eisenhower’s drafted speech in case of failure.
Fortunately, he never had to deliver it. But the success of Operation Overlord was by no means guaranteed. In a short essay called D-Day fails: Atomic Alternatives in Europe Stephen Ambrose argues that had the notoriously unpredictable English channel weather suddenly turned on the 6th, the results would have been disastrous - turning the Normandy landings into a Dieppe, but on a much grander scale. If the weather turned, there could be no follow-up landings, no airborne support and limited naval support - those who made it ashore would be killed or captured, while the rest of the invasion fleet retreated back to England.
So; there’s the counterfactual - just after the invasion is launched, the weather turns, dooming the operation from the start. What next?
Obviously, we could just try again - but not straight away. The next available date was also damned by fierce storms in the channel, pushing the operation further back. In addition, any element of surprise has been lost - the meticulous planning, as well as the counter-intelligence that went into fooling the Germans that the real landings would be in Calais has been completely wasted (including a dead body, phony tanks and double agents - who even after the real landings kept feeding the Germans balony).
In other words, if we did try again casualties would be through the roof. Victory would be in even more doubt than it was the first time round. We could try supplementing Operation Dragoon in southern France with the force still in England, presenting a logistical nightmare and strategic clusterfuck - attacking up through Vichy France leaves us miles from the Reich heartlands.
Obviously the Soviets grab a lot more territory. But how much more? Stalin apparently quipped “Tsar Alexander reached Paris”, when congratulated on reaching Berlin by an American diplomat. Would the Red Army reach the Atlantic? What would be the reaction of the western Allies (the likes of Patton and Monty were muttering about the Reds in unfavourable terms in 1945 as it was)?
Then there’s the political fallout. Eisenhower resigns in disgrace, taking full blame for the debacle. So, no President Eisenhower. Who replaces him as head of SHAEF? Could Churchill’s government survive? Could we have a President Dewey elected in November 1944 (and thus no President Truman)? Would Dresden and Hamburg see the detonations of Fat Man and Little Boy? Last but not least - the implications for the Pacific theatre - would the U.S. abandon the Germany first policy, pursuing the Pacific campaign with increased vigour (maybe even necessitating an invasion)?
Lots of tangent questions there, so TL;DR - if D-Day failed, what would happen?