Here’s my ‘what if’ scenerio for all this. It hinges on Hitler getting taken out early (say sometime around '35-'36) as well as most of the loonier Nazi leadership. I’m picturing a military coup, with one of the generals gaining power as a right-wing military dictatorship but still quasi-Nazi (but without most of the stupider baggage, and with someone at the helm that isn’t a complete wack job…leave the jews the hell alone you boneheads!).
I don’t think an absolute Nazi victory was in the cards reguardless of how you play it out, especially early on…later I think a Greater German Riche would have the chance to knock Russia out of the game (more on that later). I’d say the best possible senario for Nazi Germany would have been to play things exactly like they did early on. Conquest of western Europe, expansion into the Balkins, Greece and Africia, with a concentration of forcing Britian to either sue for peace or outright invasion.
At that point Nazi Germany should consolidate…definitely no invasion of Russia. It will take time to integrate the captured territories and exploit their resources and industries. TAKE the time. This was the worst mistake they made (i.e. invading Russia), followed by a declaration of war against the US without first getting an iron clad commitment from the Japanese to declare war on Russia and invade (which Japan had no intention of doing).
So, Germany instead continues to honor their non agression pack with Russia (Stalin is fat, dumb and happy, content to wack his own citizens and pose a few of his military officers for some gun fire). When Japan attacks America (as they planned too all along…that much was probably inevatible) Germany basically says so sorry…you didn’t check with us, you are on your own as far as this one goes, and stays the hell out of it.
Eventually Britian is either defeated or sues for peace (probably the later) as they are basically alone, except for US aid. Germany should back off the US and make sure they stay neutral…no sinking of US flag ships, no harrassment, etc. ALLOW the US to play the neutral game and supply the UK…in the end it won’t matter as they are all alone over there…eventually they will sue for peace. If not, use Germany’s vast resources to invade. If Germany concentrated on this and nothing else they could have done it…it would have cost them big time, but in the end they could have taken England out of the game.
So, a new Greater Germany is created from the ashes of Western Europe. North Africa is also a German/Italian possession (including of course the oil fields) and the Mediteranian is a German lake. Germany can now sit back and watch the US and Japan go at it hammer and tongs. The US will eventually win and emerge as a great power.
At some point, maybe by the '50’s, the inevitable clash will come between the USSR and Germany. But I don’t think the USSR will be any better prepared for that conflict than they were in '40…Stalin ALSO is a complete wack job (assuming no one manages to put a nice ice pick into his thick skull of course).
A fully prepared Greater Germany with time to build all those various toys (both a stategic as well as tactical airforce, a fully capable navy, and what they do best…an integrated and superbly trained army) and with secure strategic resources (especially oil) would give the Soviets a run for their money especially if the US is occupied with rebuilding Japan and if Germany can let America play the neutral game.
(I’m assuming the US did NOT use an atomic bomb against Japan but chose instead to keep it secret…however Germany would have observed things like strategic bombing and the use of aircraft carriers, etc, in the conflict between the US and Japan. Lessons learned and at no cost to them.)
LET the US send supplies to Russia if they want too. Hell, ask the Americans to send stuff to German too (‘are you neutral or what??’). In the end, if Germany can pack a sufficient knock out blow to take Moscow relatively quickly (which I think is possible) and if they don’t treat the Russians like sub-human trash but actually come in as liberators not conquerors, I think that they can knock the Soviets out of the game (IMO, without WWII, the Soviets would have been teetering on the brink of collapse by the '50’s anyway). After that, we’d either have a cold war between the US and the newly expanded Greater Germany, or a huge trading partner.
So, no Nazi flag over the world…but definitely a Greater German superpower stretching consisting of Western Europe, North Africa, through a large part of Western Russia.
-XT