TVAA, you should know better than to be making such rash and ill-considered statements, or your training has been particularly poor. You would be better served by stating that the DSM criteria for certain diagnoses of mental illness are more well-defined or function better to identify people suffering from some conditions than others.
The characterizations of our diagnostic framework, inpatient hospitalization and third party reimbursement, and the commitment procedures that are being made here reflect a true lack of knowledge about these issues.
For example, the original MMPI was validated on a “normal” sample, excepting IIRC that they were relatives of the original mentally ill sample. The MMPI is an empirically driven measure, meaning that yes, it works by seeing if you answer in the same manner that someone else with a particular mental illness did. Hamlet is absolutely correct that it is used only as an aide to other clinical measures and tools.
DSM-IV symptoms are not simply “do you do more or less of something or other.” For example, depression symptoms are: depressed mood most of the day, nearly every day; loss of interest or pleasure in activities normally enjoyed, nearly every day; change in appetite (which can be reduced or increased); change in sleep (which can be insomnia or hypersomnia); being slowed down or feeling restless; fatigue; feelings of hopelessness, worthlessness or excessive guilt; problems with concentration; and recurrent thoughts of death, suicidal ideation or suicide attempt. Five of these nine symptoms must be present for a period of two weeks. A fairly large amount of research has gone into and continues to go into validating these symptoms, and we are always hopeful that we can improve our nosological framework.
These are the criteria to determine depression or its absence. What other mental illness would you like to discuss?
I have to say that the most difficult instances of providing treatment for me have been for folks with bipolar disorder who are manic. They seem to have the greatest difficulty recognizing that things aren’t exactly going smoothly for them. Discussions like this one remind me of the woman who was brought in after being missing from her family for 4 or 5 days. When she was found, she was three hours away in a hotel room with a young man not her husband, with some drugs of abuse. I felt terrible for her, and still do, but the majority of my time with her was spent listening to how I was the arm of the oppressive mental health fascists she was working to fight against. I have no doubt that in her retelling of the incidents around that time today, she might omit a fair bit of the details.
I have never seen anyone railroaded into treatment of any kind. I have never seen anyone mis- or unrepresented at a commitment hearing.
Well, enough of my yappin’.