Zev -
Are you aware that “charismatic” has come to mean Christians who are open to “weird” manifestations of the Holy Spirit, like speaking in tongues and others? I believe that’s what SeaHawk is meaning.
Now, about SH, he’s acting nuts.
SH, just take five deep breaths and imagine I had come on here and made this kind of off base attacks, but on non-Christians.
I resent the implications that are all through here. Resent, I tell you.
I fully admit that there is a segment of the church that has in part turned off its mind. If you think it’s vastly different than the population as a whole, you haven’t tried having a deep discussion with random people:
“I think the Bible was just written to make money.”
“Even though texts were copied by hand at the time, and there was no method of enforcing copyright royalties?”
“I don’t believe in God. There’s just a life force that connects things. Oh, and everything happens for a reason.”
“Even though only a mind can make decisions and choices, or have reasons for things to happen? An inamimate force would not be able to have these mental processes.”
“Ummmmm…”
Lest you think I’m making these up, they are just paraphrases of real conversations.
Now, if you want me to rail on Christians who reject evolution without the first understanding of the subject, just ask. I can go on for hours.
My friend and his wife were just lastweek telling me about how their pastor is making weird statements that seem to have basis in nothing but some internal “revelation” he’s had. That’s why they’re looking to leave. We don’t all have our heads screwed on backwards.
I know this is not GD, and this kind of thing has been beaten beyond dead before, but I have to say here that the people who make wild attacks on Christians and imply that they’re automatically morons are being philosophically lightweights.
A key component of Christianity is that there is a spiritual world, and that their is spiritual, personal evidence that can not be truly related to others.
Attacks such as these unconciously use as a starting point the philosophy of materialism: there is only the physical world here, period. If you start from this supposition, then it’s easy to regard other beliefs as just dumb. However, it’s not very sophisticated or respectable.