Straight Dope Message Board

Straight Dope Message Board (https://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/index.php)
-   Cafe Society (https://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/forumdisplay.php?f=13)
-   -   Which fictional detective is the most personally miserable? (https://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?t=861152)

iiandyiiii 08-26-2018 09:46 AM

Which fictional detective is the most personally miserable?
 
Watching Hinterland on Netflix, I'm tempted to vote for Welsh detective Tom Mathias, but there's a long tradition of fictional detectives with absolutely pathetic personal lives. So who else is up there with Tom in terms of misery? Cormoran Strike might be up there too, though he's seemed to me to be reasonably content with his personal lot, pathetic as it might be in many ways.

Happy Lendervedder 08-26-2018 09:49 AM

Jessica Jones on Netflix seems pretty messed up and miserable to me. Utterly joyless, always drunk. Don't read the comics so don't know how she compares between the two.

iiandyiiii 08-26-2018 09:51 AM

Jones is another good example!

davidm 08-26-2018 10:27 AM

Sherlock Holmes needed to mainline cocaine to cope when he wasn't working.

Novelty Bobble 08-26-2018 10:27 AM

Wallander, Morse and Rebus?

I don't think you are allowed to be a male fictional detective and be chirpy.

davidm 08-26-2018 10:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Novelty Bobble (Post 21170177)
Wallander, Morse and Rebus?

I don't think you are allowed to be a male fictional detective and be chirpy.

What about Poirot? I haven't read any of the books but on the TV show he always seemed chipper enough. Eccentric as hell, but happy.

don't ask 08-26-2018 10:39 AM

Stuart M. Kaminsky's Lew Fonesca is as depressed as they come. He is a virtually penniless process server who lives behind his office, uses the bathroom in the building, showers at the gym and only has a bike to get around. He is seeing an 80 year old therapist trying to resolve his issues after the hit and run death of his wife. The novels are set in Sarasota which makes a nice change.

Robot Arm 08-26-2018 10:41 AM

Jim Rockford lived in a trailer, got beat up a lot, and the calls on his answering machine were never good news. He was cynical as hell, but seemed to be holding up okay.

Wolf333 08-26-2018 10:47 AM

Adrian Monk

DCnDC 08-26-2018 10:52 AM

Gregory House. He's a doctor by profession, but really his job as "diagnostician" is detective work.

wonky 08-26-2018 10:54 AM

Dick Francis has a protagonist in one of his books, Blood Sport, who is clinically depressed and suicidal. He was the first one who leapt to mind, though I don't usually think of Francis's characters as "detectives."

My guess would be something from Scandinavia. Or maybe they just make me personally miserable.

Irishman 08-26-2018 11:22 AM

I was gonna say Adrian Monk. Everything is an anxiety disorder for him. Going out, staying in, touching things, not touching things, being with other people, being alone....

Dewey Finn 08-26-2018 11:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Novelty Bobble (Post 21170177)
Wallander, Morse and Rebus?

I don't think you are allowed to be a male fictional detective and be chirpy.

I noticed Wallander and Morse's melancholy (never saw Rebus) and wondered about it. A couple of times in Morse episodes, DS Lewis even told him to cheer up. (And then when Lewis became the focus of his own show, he was melancholy.)

Bijou Drains 08-26-2018 11:53 AM

Columbo never looked all that happy.

Blank Slate 08-26-2018 11:54 AM

Ash Henderson. He is the protagonist in a two book (so far) series by Scottish author Stuart MacBride (best known for the popular Logan McRae books.) Now, Henderson has plenty to be depressed about. Here is a brief synopsis of the plot:

Quote:

Detective Constable Ash Henderson has a dark secret

Five years ago his daughter, Rebecca, went missing on the eve of her thirteenth birthday. A year later the first card arrived: homemade, with a Polaroid picture stuck to the front – Rebecca, strapped to a chair, gagged and terrified. Every year another card: each one worse than the last.

The tabloids call him ‘The Birthday Boy’. He’s been snatching girls for twelve years, always in the run-up to their thirteenth birthday, sending the families his home-made cards showing their daughters being slowly tortured to death.



But that's not the worst of it, because...

SPOILER:
He's too late to save his daughter and after endless scenes of beatings, torture and other assorted mayhem, he finds her mutilated corpse.


But it couldn't get wore...could it?

SPOILER:
It sure could! Because after that, his other daughter is kidnapped by a copycat psycho. And guess what? He's too late to save her either. Yes, both daughters die horribly


One of the few times I was actually angry upon finishing a work of fiction. I love the McRae novels, but I'm not touching another Henderson book.

RobDog 08-26-2018 12:09 PM

Not quite a detective, but a criminal psychologist... How about Fitz from the Brit series Cracker? Wikipedia describes him as "alcoholic, a chain smoker, obese, sedentary, addicted to gambling, manic, foul-mouthed and sarcastic" which is a roundabout way of saying "Scottish"*

*kidding :D

cmkeller 08-26-2018 12:09 PM

I think Kinsey Millhone, in her fictional life, is miserable at the frustrating knowledge that she came so close to Z, but will never cross that finish line.

salinqmind 08-26-2018 12:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cmkeller (Post 21170316)
I think Kinsey Millhone, in her fictional life, is miserable at the frustrating knowledge that she came so close to Z, but will never cross that finish line.


*I'M* miserable, too, over this! I was hoping Z would wrap up with Kinsey writing from the present day in the 21st century, looking back on her last big case and updating us on what she is doing now, what happened to Henry and her exes, that kind of thing. As it is, I suppose she will forever be working away in the 1980's with the same old cast of characters, living in her tiny house, never moving on AFAIK.

Darren Garrison 08-26-2018 12:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wolf333 (Post 21170200)
Adrian Monk

Yeah, I'm suprised it took to the 9th post to get the obvious answer.

digs 08-26-2018 12:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cmkeller (Post 21170316)
I think Kinsey Millhone, in her fictional life, is miserable at the frustrating knowledge that she came so close to Z, but will never cross that finish line.

I happen to know that she's right in the middle of her last case as we speak! See, she got a call from an old high school crush, Matt, who's "working" in Switzerland, in a tiny mountain village (hence the "Z is for Zither" appellation). I won't spoil it, but the rumor is that at the end of the alpine adventure, she'll find out that Matt is actually Matteo von Graffengriff, next in line to restore the village's ancient-yet-quaint castle.

The reason we'll never read Z is for Zither is that Kinsey will be too busy making wedding plans and renovating the castle... and she'll never have time to type "Respectfully submitted, Kinsey Milhone."



ETA: She'll also have her hands full with the newest businesses in the village: Henry's Bakery and Rosa's Hungarian Café.

Riemann 08-26-2018 12:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Darren Garrison (Post 21170331)
Yeah, I'm suprised it took to the 9th post to get the obvious answer.

The "troubled genius" trope is so common in detective fiction that Monk seems no more than an average example to me! It's as though you have to go as horrific as Blank Slate's example of Ash Henderson to make the misery notable.

iiandyiiii 08-26-2018 12:40 PM

James Lee Burke's Dave Robicheaux is another example -- long-term alcoholic who has lost something like 3 wives to murder or accidents. And his best friend Clete Purcell, a private eye, is even more messed up. And they're both Vietnam vets who somehow are still getting into fistfights and chasing baddies well into the 2010s.

Riemann 08-26-2018 12:41 PM

Here we go

https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.p...ctiveDetective

iiandyiiii 08-26-2018 12:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Riemann (Post 21170359)

Great!

k9bfriender 08-26-2018 12:55 PM

I'd nominate Dirk Gentley of the Dirk Gentley books. Been a while since I read them, but he was pretty miserable in all aspects. No friends, no money, a feud with his house cleaner over his refrigerator, and his clients seemed to have a tendency to die before they had a chance to pay, when he did have clients.

Sefton 08-26-2018 12:56 PM

I nominate John River, whose only friend is the ghost of his former partner.

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt4258440/

Roderick Femm 08-26-2018 01:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Darren Garrison (Post 21170331)
Yeah, I'm suprised it took to the 9th post to get the obvious answer.

I don't think Monk is particularly miserable. He has lots of issues but he mostly deals with them, he's in therapy, and he gets a fair amount of pleasure out of life. Yes, his wife was murdered. There's lots worse in a lot of other detectives' lives.

The Irish detectives that I have read seem especially unable to be happy. There's Ed Loy, in a series by Declan Hughes, who seems to not only be pretty miserable himself, but brings misery to those around him. Then there's Quirke, in a series by Benjamin Black; he's the Dublin forensic pathologist who drinks too much and can't seem to keep his nose out of things that get him beaten up.

But the most miserable detective of all is Ian Rutledge, Scotland Yard inspector. An officer in WWI, he survived physically but his mental state is crippling. In the war he had to execute his Scottish sergeant for failure to order his men to charge as ordered, and now he carries the sergeant's voice in his head. The voice gives him no peace and no quarter, although it also occasionally warns him of danger, since the sergeant knows if Rutledge dies he dies finally too. Rutledge is a very good detective but he gets no kudos because of bureaucratic jealousies, and he can never allow himself to get close to anyone lest they discover his secret -- the voice in his head would get him diagnosed with shell shock and sent to an institution.

ftg 08-26-2018 01:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by k9bfriender (Post 21170378)
I'd nominate Dirk Gentley of the Dirk Gentley books. Been a while since I read them, but he was pretty miserable in all aspects. No friends, no money, a feud with his house cleaner over his refrigerator, and his clients seemed to have a tendency to die before they had a chance to pay, when he did have clients.

The guy had a really positive attitude! That's because of the whole holistic thing. He knew stuff would just work out.

Some of Douglas Adams quirks leaked into him, but not as much as Mr. Adams lived with.

Son of a Rich 08-26-2018 03:48 PM

Batman.

Siam Sam 08-26-2018 03:55 PM

No mention yet of Harry Bosch?

Thudlow Boink 08-26-2018 03:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Son of a Rich (Post 21170585)
Batman.

Depends on which Batman. In some depictions of superheroes (including Batman), they seem to be having a pretty good time being superheroes.

Siam Sam 08-26-2018 04:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Siam Sam (Post 21170598)
No mention yet of Harry Bosch?

There are also various Dashiell Hammett, Raymond Chandler and James Ellroy detectives among whom it would be difficult to choose.

There was a good one from 30 ears ago, The Crosskiller, by Marcel Montecino, and his veteran police detective Jack Gold certainly qualifies.

Colibri 08-26-2018 04:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by davidm (Post 21170176)
Sherlock Holmes needed to mainline cocaine to cope when he wasn't working.

But he's quite happy (after his own fashion) when he is working. He has a highly rewarding life, he lives comfortably, he has at least one friend (in his own fashion), and is the subject of public adulation. He's actually doing extremely well for a fictional detective.

The Other Waldo Pepper 08-26-2018 04:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bijou Drains (Post 21170297)
Columbo never looked all that happy.

How do you figure? Near as I can tell, he seems to genuinely like his job — and he seems genuinely fond of his wife, and of his favorite restaurant, and of his dog, and of the music he listens to, and so on; and he doesn’t seem to drink to dull the pain, but because he just enjoys it, same way he just enjoys ice cream. Or reminiscing about old times. Or watching a good film. Or hearing a good joke.

Most of the time, he just strikes me as an upbeat guy.

Tim R. Mortiss 08-26-2018 04:37 PM

James Bond, in the books, was generally pretty miserable. He hated his job, hated his boss, and continually tried to drown his sorrows with whatever alcoholic beverage was handy. Didn't have to be a vodka martini, either.

madsircool 08-26-2018 04:42 PM

Either of the two protagonists from Kill the Father.

Dewey Finn 08-26-2018 04:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roderick Femm (Post 21170410)
Quote:

Originally Posted by Darren Garrison (Post 21170331)
Yeah, I'm suprised it took to the 9th post to get the obvious answer.

I don't think Monk is particularly miserable. He has lots of issues but he mostly deals with them, he's in therapy, and he gets a fair amount of pleasure out of life. Yes, his wife was murdered. There's lots worse in a lot of other detectives' lives.

I agree with this. Plus Monk has the advantage of living and working in San Francisco. Wallander, for instance, is Swedish, so he has that whole Scandinavian depression thing going and Sherlock Holmes was living and working in gloomy, foggy London.

Beckdawrek 08-26-2018 04:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Colibri (Post 21170612)
But he's quite happy (after his own fashion) when he is working. He has a highly rewarding life, he lives comfortably, he has at least one friend (in his own fashion), and is the subject of public adulation. He's actually doing extremely well for a fictional detective.

Well, there was 'the woman'.

Alessan 08-26-2018 05:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Beckdawrek (Post 21170665)
Well, there was 'the woman'.

So? Every detective has one of those.

Scumpup 08-26-2018 05:21 PM

Bruce Wayne as they've been interminably writing him. Back when he was a smiling, happy psychopath...enjoying his wealth....trading quips with his ward while they laughingly maimed criminals...he had a certain joie de vivre. Now? Not an ounce of happiness in the man's lives.

Colibri 08-26-2018 05:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Beckdawrek (Post 21170665)
Well, there was 'the woman'.

At least in the stories (actually, story) Holmes only admired her for her cleverness.

Quote:

It was not that he felt any emotion akin to love for Irene Adler. All emotions, and that one particularly, were abhorrent to his cold, precise but admirably balanced mind.
-A Scandal in Bohemia

To all appearances Holmes was asexual, and happy that way.

Tapiotar 08-26-2018 05:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dewey Finn (Post 21170660)
I agree with this. Plus Monk has the advantage of living and working in San Francisco. Wallander, for instance, is Swedish, so he has that whole Scandinavian depression thing going and Sherlock Holmes was living and working in gloomy, foggy London.

I agree. I think that sometimes Monk is happy with all his peculiar quirks and tics.

Tapiotar 08-26-2018 05:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Other Waldo Pepper (Post 21170633)
How do you figure? Near as I can tell, he seems to genuinely like his job — and he seems genuinely fond of his wife, and of his favorite restaurant, and of his dog, and of the music he listens to, and so on; and he doesn’t seem to drink to dull the pain, but because he just enjoys it, same way he just enjoys ice cream. Or reminiscing about old times. Or watching a good film. Or hearing a good joke.

Most of the time, he just strikes me as an upbeat guy.

I think that Columbo is very happy. He loves his job, he loves his car, his dog, his wife. And especially his raincoat. He's one of the happiest of detectives.

Mr. Bill 08-26-2018 05:53 PM

DI Jack Lennon of Stuart Neville's Belfast series.

bmoak 08-26-2018 05:59 PM

The various Scandanavian detectives all seem to have bleak outlooks on life and the bleak lives to go with them. I would nominate Jo Nesbo's Harry Hole ("The Snowman", etc.) as the most miserable.

davidm 08-26-2018 06:23 PM

Stephen King's Bill Hodges was pretty miserable.

Siam Sam 08-26-2018 06:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tapiotar (Post 21170747)
I think that Columbo is very happy. He loves his job, he loves his car, his dog, his wife. And especially his raincoat. He's one of the happiest of detectives.

Side note: Until Mrs. Columbo got her own TV series, there was wide speculation that Columbo didn't really have a wife. You never saw her, and it was thought that making references to a nonexistent wife was one way of making the perp let his guard down.

Beckdawrek 08-26-2018 06:30 PM

Scooby and the gang seemed quite happy. Especially, Shaggy. What was in those Scooby snacks anyway?

The Other Waldo Pepper 08-26-2018 07:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Siam Sam (Post 21170795)
Side note: Until Mrs. Columbo got her own TV series, there was wide speculation that Columbo didn't really have a wife. You never saw her, and it was thought that making references to a nonexistent wife was one way of making the perp let his guard down.

But we’d see him telling other cops on the force about her at the end of an episode: after getting the perp to blurt out incriminating stuff, after which said perp was never seen or heard from again. Or, in the ‘vacation’ episode, we repeatedly saw a guy who works on the cruise ship flatly state that he’d seen her — including in the final scene, well after the perp had already been caught.

And et cetera, and AFAICT all before the other show ever hit the air...

Siam Sam 08-26-2018 07:16 PM

Don't kill the messenger. I'm just passing along the speculation.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:22 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2019, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.

Send questions for Cecil Adams to: cecil@straightdope.com

Send comments about this website to: webmaster@straightdope.com

Terms of Use / Privacy Policy

Advertise on the Straight Dope!
(Your direct line to thousands of the smartest, hippest people on the planet, plus a few total dipsticks.)

Copyright © 2019 STM Reader, LLC.