FWIW some more info:
The reason the herniation hurts a nerve is that the nerve passes through a narrow bony opening called the foramen, formed by the butterfly-shaped bone sections to the rear of the disk. Your spine is a stack of cylinders (the heavy part of the vertibrae) with disks between them, plus these butterfly extensions. The extensions interfere with one another to limit twisting and bending backwards and to anchor many of the tendons and ligaments that create your back’s stability. The spots where the butterflies rub against their upper and lower neighbor are called the “facet joints”. If you look vertically through this bony assembly you see a canal bounded by the cylinders and disks in front, the butterflies in back, and the posts that bridge between cylinders and butterflies on either side. Your spinal cord runs through the canal. Nerve roots branch off of it and go out through the foramen on each side. When your disk herniates into these tight spaces, the nerve is crushed in there. When your disk herniates elsewhere, you may never notice.
Another bit: the probability that the patient feels long term relief from surgery depends on why the surgery was done. If it is supposed to fix pain in your back itself caused by a herniation, the success rate is only about 50% - and indeed it is not clear how disks cause pain locally, one theory being that the disks, which have no nerves in them, may open up cracks and tears which let nerves grow into them, nerves which don’t like being crushed as part of the normal function of disks.
But if the surgery is intended to fix pain felt in the limb served by the nerve the disk is crushing, success rates jump to 85%. I think this situation is like having your hand slammed in a car door, and people are offering pain killers and ice and special exercises, and all you want is for them to open the damn door.
My story: I herniated my L5S1 disk with massive pulp extrusion on 2/1/05, crushing my right sciatic nerve root and causing great pain that migrated around my right foot and leg, and some paralysis, leaving me walking with a cane for a few weeks. By a few months later some of the trouble had spread to the left leg (as a nurse said, “Oh! You’re going bilateral!” like it was the hot trend in GQ). I had 6 months of physical therapy, 3 stearoid injections, two MRIs, one of those nerve studies where they put needle electrodes into various leg muscles, 1200 Percocets, and finally surgery on 7/18/05 to cut away disk, undercut the spinal column itself 15%, and cut out some of the bone in the foramen to increase the size of the opening. I got much relief right away, and then they started me on gabapentin, a nerve med (best known by the trade name Neurontin). A few months of this gave me even more relief. Now I’d say the problem is at least 95% fixed and I am happy. I still can’t wiggle my toes on the right, and can’t stand on my heel on that side, and often fail to clear steps with my right toe; I have a drop foot. And my sensations are compromised somewhat. If I cut my foot or toes I often can’t feel it. The top of my foot feels very slight sensations as very strong, so that if one of the cats walks over my bare foot and the soft soft fur of their belly just slightly brushes it, I feel great burning pain. Yet, I can scrub the area with a stiff brush without discomfort. But I have my life back and am thrilled about that.
I guess my spine has other problems too. I had to get my bottom 3 neck vertebrae fused last summer (an even more rewarding trip than the back surgery), and am going to get an artificial disk next to the 4th one some time soon, having pain and difficulty with my arms and hands getting clumsy and weak, especially on the left. Doc says I chose my parents badly.
Last but not least, remember the motto of orthopedic surgery: “We may not make you better, but we’ll definitely make you different!”