# "A well regulated militia"

**URL:** <https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950>\
**Category:** Great Debates\
**Created:** [June 12, 2004, 6:40am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950 "2004-06-12T06:40:51Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 20\
**Page:** 4

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![BrainGlutton](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/b/82dd89/32.png) [@BrainGlutton](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/BrainGlutton)\
**Post date:** [June 14, 2004, 3:30am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/61 "2004-06-14T03:30:06Z")

</div>

> [@silenus](#):
>
> The scary thing is that I think you actually believe that. If the Government doesn’t trust me with my guns, why should I trust them with theirs? I have absolutely zero faith in the Government to do anything “in my interest.”

**silenus,** it’s obvious why the government has to have guns. But what do you actually, sincerely think you can do with your guns, that can stop the government from doing anything it decides to do?

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![XT](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/xt/32/456_2.png) [@XT](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/XT)\
**Post date:** [June 14, 2004, 3:53am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/62 "2004-06-14T03:53:00Z")

</div>

> [@chula](#):
>
> This survey does not measure Americans’ support for the right of individuals to bear arms, as xtisme claimed. It measures Americans’ knowledge and understanding of Constitutional law.

Thats an interesting interperatation. Is that your interperatation or are you getting that from somewhere? If you are getting that from somewhere, could you provide the cite so we can take a look at it?

Here’s ABCNEW’s interperatation:

> [@](#):
>
> May 14 — Americans overwhelmingly agree with the Justice Department’s new position that the Second Amendment guarantees the right of citizens to own guns. But most also favor some restrictions on that right.
> 
> After hearing the Second Amendment verbatim, 73 percent in an [ABCNEWS.com](http://ABCNEWS.com) poll said it guarantees the right to individual gun ownership. Twenty percent said, instead, that it only guarantees the right of states to maintain militias — the government’s longstanding position until the Justice Department reversed it in a U.S. Supreme Court brief last week.
> 
> Most do support some restrictions on this right, with 57 percent of Americans favoring “stricter gun control laws.” That’s about the same as it was last year, but 10 points below its peak. And “strong” support for gun control, at 39 percent, is down seven points since last year, to its lowest in 10 years. (The government’s new position, likewise, says gun ownership should be “subject to reasonable restrictions.”)

> [@](#):
>
> Constitution grants right to guns Favor stricter gun control  
> All 73% 57
> 
> Men 80 44  
> Women 66 69
> 
> …
> 
> Democrats 66 69  
> Independents 75 64  
> Republicans 82 42

You will notice that while a majority of people favor some form of gun control (as do I) and regulation, the overwhelming majority of American’s in every category from sex to race to political affiliation feels that our right to keep and bear (god, that still cracks me up) arms is something that is and should be guarenteed by the constitution. Do a google search on “poll” “right to bear arms”…I haven’t found a poll yet that contridicts this. If you have some opposing data, by all means lets look at it and see what it means in light of these other polls.

> [@BrainGlutton](#):
>
> By reframing the debate as follows: The Second Amendment should be repealed, not because the right to bear arms is illegitimate or even unimportant, but because it is not important enough to rank with free speech and the right to trial by jury, etc., as something deserving of constitutional protection, of being set above and beyond the ordinary political-legislative process.

By what standard to you judge which rights should continue to be important enough to be guarenteed by the constitution and which aren’t? Its not important to YOU, but it IS important to others. How do we judge which rights should continue to be guarenteed by the constitution and which shouldn’t be? Its pretty obvious to me that the majority of American’s DO feel its important, that it IS a right that is guarenteed by the constitution. If a minority of American’s feel the Freedom of Speech isn’t important enough to be guarenteed by the constitution (not to say that it would be revoked mind you, but that its not important enough to be guarenteed and should be subject to the individual states…as I assume you’d put the right to keep and bear arms), should we then go with that minority over the objections of the majority…for the good of the public of course.

> [@BrainGlutton](#):
>
> To put this in perspective: Even though I am pro-choice right down the line, I feel exactly the same way about abortion rights. They do not deserve constitutional protection. Roe v. Wade was a very poorly reasoned opinion, and if I were a Supreme Court justice I probably would vote to reverse it for that reason alone. Let the political process sort out all the problems and issues related to abortion.

I’m not sure I agree with this…I have to give it some thought. To be honest you’ve taken me aback a bit here with this position. My knee jerk reaction is you are just wrong…it IS important enough to be a protected right. Of course, it currently ISN’T guarenteed by the constitution afaik…

-XT

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![bump](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/b/7c8e57/32.png) [@bump](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/bump)\
**Post date:** [June 14, 2004, 3:57am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/63 "2004-06-14T03:57:40Z")

</div>

> [@BrainGlutton](#):
>
> Under modern conditions, the United States Army could defeat all the National Guard units together, assuming it were even possible for all of them to be united in revolt against the Army.

I doubt that… and even if somehow the regular Army were to fight the mobilized National Guard, it would almost certainly be a Pyhrric victory.

The NG has the majority of the Army’s combat power- this is something many people overlook.

The Army currently has 10 active-duty divisions(3 light infantry/airborne, 7 armored/mech infantry), 2 Armored Cavalry regiments, and 2 independent airborne brigades.

The NG currently has 11 divisions(mixed infantry/armor brigades), as well as 12 independent infantry brigades and 3 independent armored/armored cavalry brigades.

The Air National Guard pilots frequently outfly their active-duty colleagues because they have more experience.

So the NG has more people, similar training, and more unit cohesion due to longer time together than active duty units.

Both have similar equipment- NG has M1A1 tanks, F15/F15 fighters, Bradley Fighting Vehicles, etc… not old 1970’s stuff.

I think it’s pretty simplistic to say that the Army would always win- in this case, it’s entirely likely that the Army would NOT win vs. the National Guard.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![BrainGlutton](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/b/82dd89/32.png) [@BrainGlutton](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/BrainGlutton)\
**Post date:** [June 14, 2004, 4:35am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/64 "2004-06-14T04:35:28Z")

</div>

> [@furt](#):
>
> Perhaps our form of government is so stable and mature that there is no need for the “bear in the woods” threat of armed rebellion to curb the excesses of government … but maybe not. . . . even if the threat of armed rebellion isn’t needed now, it might be someday; and then it’s too late to start rearming. . . . But I am frankly glad that there are guys out in Idaho with their eyes on DC and their fingers on their Armalites. I’m not a member of the ACLU and frequently disagree with them, yet I’m glad they exist. Extremists make effective watchdogs.

😕 No, they don’t. Well, extremists might make effective watchdogs in a political sense, but they are no more effective for being armed. Do you think the Feds and the Army and your local police are afraid of the “bear in the woods”? They’re not. They fear the law and the courts and the voters and public opinion, and that is all they fear, and that is all they should fear.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![BrainGlutton](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/b/82dd89/32.png) [@BrainGlutton](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/BrainGlutton)\
**Post date:** [June 14, 2004, 4:38am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/65 "2004-06-14T04:38:41Z")

</div>

> [@bump](#):
>
> I doubt that… and even if somehow the regular Army were to fight the mobilized National Guard, it would almost certainly be a Pyhrric victory.
> 
> The NG has the majority of the Army’s combat power- this is something many people overlook.
> 
> The Army currently has 10 active-duty divisions(3 light infantry/airborne, 7 armored/mech infantry), 2 Armored Cavalry regiments, and 2 independent airborne brigades.
> 
> The NG currently has 11 divisions(mixed infantry/armor brigades), as well as 12 independent infantry brigades and 3 independent armored/armored cavalry brigades.
> 
> The Air National Guard pilots frequently outfly their active-duty colleagues because they have more experience.
> 
> So the NG has more people, similar training, and more unit cohesion due to longer time together than active duty units.
> 
> Both have similar equipment- NG has M1A1 tanks, F15/F15 fighters, Bradley Fighting Vehicles, etc… not old 1970’s stuff.
> 
> I think it’s pretty simplistic to say that the Army would always win- in this case, it’s entirely likely that the Army would NOT win vs. the National Guard.

But, **bump,** the federal armed forces have **nukes.**

And they also have legitimacy. In the eyes of the public, how much legitimacy do you think the National Guard of any state, or grouping of states, would have against the federal armed forces?

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Blalron](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/b/35a633/32.png) [@Blalron](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Blalron)\
**Post date:** [June 14, 2004, 4:52am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/66 "2004-06-14T04:52:59Z")

</div>

> [@BrainGlutton](#):
>
> To put this in perspective: Even though I am pro-choice right down the line, I feel exactly the same way about abortion rights. They do not deserve **constitutional** protection. _Roe v. Wade_ was a very poorly reasoned opinion, and if I were a Supreme Court justice I probably would vote to reverse it for that reason alone. Let the political process sort out all the problems and issues related to abortion.

Regardless of whether it was a good interpretation of the Constitution when it was originally decided, _Stare Decisis_ princples ultimately prevail. Stare Decisis (“let the decision stand”) says that even if we might have made a different decision if we were viewing things from afresh, if our system relies heavily upon it’s foundations then the decision should not be disturbed.

Even if Roe vs Wade was a legal error, it would be a disaster to overturn 31 years of constitutionally guaranteed reproductive freedom to correct it.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![BrainGlutton](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/b/82dd89/32.png) [@BrainGlutton](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/BrainGlutton)\
**Post date:** [June 14, 2004, 4:57am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/67 "2004-06-14T04:57:21Z")

</div>

> [@xtisme](#):
>
> By what standard to you judge which rights should continue to be important enough to be guarenteed by the constitution and which aren’t? Its not important to YOU, but it IS important to others. How do we judge which rights should continue to be guarenteed by the constitution and which shouldn’t be?

Look, apart from hunting and gun-collecting, there are a limited number of conceivable reasons why private citizens might want to own firearms:

(1) To commit crimes.

(2) To defend their country and their families from foreign invaders.

(3) To defend themselves, their families and their property from violent criminals, because they do not trust the police to do that job for them adequately.

(4) To shoot at the police or the Army or the National Guard, if, in their judgment, that should become necessary.

(1) hardly merits discussion. (2) is anachronistic. It might have had some merit in 1776 and 1812 but it would not apply to any realistically conceivable military threat the United States might face in the future, _Red Dawn_ notwithstanding. (3) is a legitimate concern but it is not really a question of personal civil liberties; it is, as I said above, an ordinary public-safety issue, a question of balancing the crime-deterrence value of armed householders against the obvious safety threats of personal gun ownership. As such, it should be left to the ordinary political process. (4) is the only concern of any **political** significance, of any relevance to the idea of personal liberties and civil rights; and I’ve already made clear how I feel about its relevance in that area. “The Constitution is not a suicide pact.”

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Blalron](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/b/35a633/32.png) [@Blalron](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Blalron)\
**Post date:** [June 14, 2004, 4:58am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/68 "2004-06-14T04:58:52Z")

</div>

> [@Crafter\_Man](#):
>
> When all is said and done, you are left holding your _ **beliefs** _, which never need to be justified. If you _ **believe** _ you have a right to keep and bear arms, then… you have a right to keep and bear arms.

Of course. Irrational beliefs need no justification. Like believing that you have a God Given right to posess instruments of death and the state is evil for wanting to restrict that.

And let’s face it, that’s what guns are. They are instruments of death. Guns are designed to kill, and they have no other practical use.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![XT](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/xt/32/456_2.png) [@XT](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/XT)\
**Post date:** [June 14, 2004, 5:30am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/69 "2004-06-14T05:30:09Z")

</div>

> [@BrainGlutton](#):
>
> Look, apart from hunting and gun-collecting, there are a limited number of conceivable reasons why private citizens might want to own firearms:

The reasons why people want to own their own fire arms are irrelevent IMO…the fact of the matter is, it’s their right to do so (guarenteed by the Constitution), and the majority of people in this democracy agree with that concept. Again, I ALSO think that the majority of the citizens would support a new amendment that is clearer and spells things out a bit plainer (i.e. one that makes sense would be nice), that sets the bounds and limitations…but that continues to guarentee the average citizen the right to keep private fire arms.

I can make similar arguements, btw, against free speech (or any other right guarenteed by the constitution) to limit it or control it (thought it makes me slightly ill to do so)…in fact there are several European countries that have already done so based on my examples. There are a limited number of reasons to allow, say, Nazi or racist propaganda or Holocaust denial, there are a limited number of reasons to allow pornography…hell, you name it and an excuse could (and probably HAS been) made to deny it. Yet they are all important to some people (just as the right to keep and bear arms are important to some folks), the the principal is important to the majority (and thats the key), even if the majority don’t agree with this or that specific instance (you’d probably be hard pressed to find a lot of support for Nazi or KKK propaganda). Hell, I can’t stand racists or Nazi’s but I’d fight to uphold their rights to say any damn fool thing they want, because failing that we start down a very slippery slope.

In fact I think there are several European countries that have already set foot on that path. Maybe in the various European nations the majority of their citizens support controls on their freedom of speech…and on completely or partially banning of fire arms in the hands of their private citizens. But in the US the majority do NOT support such things…and frankly I hope they never do. It won’t be the same country if that ever happens…

-XT

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![blowero](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/b/41988e/32.png) [@blowero](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/blowero)\
**Post date:** [June 14, 2004, 7:25am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/70 "2004-06-14T07:25:27Z")

</div>

> [@furt](#):
>
> Well, given that in 1787 there were plenty of people who A) owned guns and B) weren’t a part of a militia and there was no move to stop them, I suspect the founders might say the point of the thing is that you _could_ join a militia and overthrow any tyrranical government that arose.
> 
> But if you want to make the case that gun owners must be a part of an organized _private_ militia, go ahead.

You guys are missing a major point. If we assume that the 2nd Amendment protects the right to form militias, that doesn’t mean that you CAN’T own firearms individually, it merely means that the decision is left to THE STATES. So whether anyone made or makes any “move to stop them” is irrelevant. Just because something is not constitutionally protected does not mean it is ipso facto outlawed.

Under the collective interpretation of the Second Amendment, states _can_ pass laws regulating individual ownership of guns, but it doesn’t mean they _have_ to.

> [@](#):
>
> Those groups make most people a bit uneasy, that would at least make more logical sense than trying to argue that in contradiction of everything else they said elsewhere, in contradiction to the war they just fought and smack-dab in middle of listing the ten most important rights of private citizens they suddenly decide to announce that the government has the right to regulate firearm possession.

That argument doesn’t make sense. You’re saying that if we use the collective interpretation, it means the founding fathers were explicitly “announcing” a “right” to regulate firearm possession. But the states are given the power to make laws by the constitution. States don’t have to be explicitly given permission in the U.S. Constitution for every law they pass. Just because _one_ right is granted does not mean they are “announcing” that another right is taken away. It would mean that, like all other things not explicitly mentioned in the Constitution, it would be delegated to the states. It’s unneccessary to make an explicit negative declaration of every conceivable law that might be passed by the states.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Crafter\_Man](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/crafter_man/32/458_2.png) [@Crafter\_Man](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Crafter_Man)\
**Post date:** [June 14, 2004, 12:19pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/71 "2004-06-14T12:19:48Z")

</div>

> [@Blalron](#):
>
> And let’s face it, that’s what guns are. They are instruments of death. Guns are designed to kill, and they have no other practical use.

I prefer to look at them as instruments of _ **life** _. As in, they help me _protect_ my life.

Furthermore, your assumption is incorrect. When it comes to personal _protection_, the purpose of a gun is not to _kill_. The purpose of a gun is to _ **stop** _. Any death is incidental.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Debaser](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/d/3da27b/32.png) [@Debaser](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Debaser)\
**Post date:** [June 14, 2004, 2:10pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/72 "2004-06-14T14:10:31Z")

</div>

> [@Blalron](#):
>
> And let’s face it, that’s what guns are. They are instruments of death. Guns are designed to kill, and they have no other practical use.

I see this kind of thinking from anti-gun types on nearly every gun control thread. I always wonder how is it possible for some people to actually believe such a foolish notion.

If the only use for guns is to kill, would you support locking up every gun owner in the country in jail? After all, they are all clearly guilty of plotting to kill. Why else would they own a gun? Lets arrest them all for attempted murder.

While we are at it, lets lock up all the baseball players. Let’s face it, that what baseball bats are. They are instruments of death. Baseball bats are designed to bash peoples heads in, and they have no other practical use.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Captain\_Amazing](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/c/6de8d8/32.png) [@Captain\_Amazing](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Captain_Amazing)\
**Post date:** [June 14, 2004, 3:18pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/73 "2004-06-14T15:18:56Z")

</div>

> [@Blalron](#):
>
> And let’s face it, that’s what guns are. They are instruments of death. Guns are designed to kill, and they have no other practical use.

Can we take a middle ground here, and say that guns are designed to accelerate a metal projectile, allowing said projectile to penetrate objects that a thrown projectile could not? That’s what a gun is designed to do, and whether the bullet goes through a paper target, a deer, or a person, is irrelevant to the gun.

Of course, if the bullet does go through a living thing, it’ll cause injury or death, and since that’s the general reason you want to accelerate projectiles like that, guns, like their predecessors bows and slings, are characterized as weapons. Now, whether or not it’s good to cause injury or death to another living thing is a moral question, but the general consensus is that it can sometimes be immoral (shooting an innocent person), morally neutral (shooting a deer), or morally acceptable (shooting a person who’s attacking you).

And of course, none of this has any bearing on whether a person has a moral right to own a gun, a legal right to do so, or even whether one should do so. I’m sorry to intervene here, because I don’t really have much to say about the Second Amendment or gun ownership generally. I’m just bringing it up because it annoys me that in every gun control argument, proponents try to make guns look like these evil machines, while opponents portray guns as noble and wonderful.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![erislover](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/e/71e660/32.png) [@erislover](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/erislover)\
**Post date:** [June 14, 2004, 3:31pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/74 "2004-06-14T15:31:18Z")

</div>

> [@blowero](#):
>
> You guys are missing a major point. If we assume that the 2nd Amendment protects the right to form militias, that doesn’t mean that you CAN’T own firearms individually, it merely means that the decision is left to THE STATES.

I don’t think this is a totally obvious conclusion. “The right to bear arms shall not be infringed” has a pretty unambiguous reading. If the context is in a militia, then that term needs to be clarified, but it is pretty hard, in my opinion, to twist the first part around in such a way as to invalidate the second part.

> [@](#):
>
> Under the collective interpretation of the Second Amendment, states _can_ pass laws regulating individual ownership of guns, but it doesn’t mean they _have_ to.

I think under any but the uber-looney interpretation regulations may be passed.

> [@](#):
>
> States don’t have to be explicitly given permission in the U.S. Constitution for every law they pass.

But obviously they have to be in line with the US consitution when they do pass laws. If there is no discrimination as a federal law, a state doesn’t reserve the right to discriminate.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![bump](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/b/7c8e57/32.png) [@bump](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/bump)\
**Post date:** [June 14, 2004, 3:35pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/75 "2004-06-14T15:35:15Z")

</div>

> [@BrainGlutton](#):
>
> But, **bump,** the federal armed forces have **nukes.**
> 
> And they also have legitimacy. In the eyes of the public, how much legitimacy do you think the National Guard of any state, or grouping of states, would have against the federal armed forces?

Only the Air Force and Navy have nukes anymore, and the vast majority of those are strategic level weapons- pretty much unsuitable for tactical use.

I think the legitimacy of the NG vs the regular Army would depend on the situation. In a rebel state scenario much like the Civil War, then yeah, they might not have much legitimacy, but in other scenarios where the Feds were doing something tyrannical, then they might definitely be considered legitimate. And if the Fed. Govt. ever used nuclear weapons on their own citizens, then the National Guard would likely have ALL the legitimacy it would need to fight the regular armed forces.

Plus, there’s one thing we’re not considering. Our armed forces swear an oath to the Constitution, not the President, etc… This would tend to put a certain damper on using the Army for unconstitutional purposes- the officers and men in the Service take that oath pretty seriously, and would probably have some difficulty obeying unlawful orders, such as those that would be unconstitutional.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Alessan](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/alessan/32/465_2.png) [@Alessan](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Alessan)\
**Post date:** [June 14, 2004, 3:46pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/76 "2004-06-14T15:46:27Z")

</div>

> [@Captain Amazing](#):
>
> Can we take a middle ground here, and say that guns are designed to accelerate a metal projectile, allowing said projectile to penetrate objects that a thrown projectile could not? That’s what a gun is designed to do, and whether the bullet goes through a paper target, a deer, or a person, is irrelevant to the gun.

But by that logic, the purpose of, say, a car, is to rotate four wheels at a certain speed and a certain angle. Nothing about driving on roads, nothing about carrying passengers, no reason to call it a “vehicle”. It’s _reductum ad absurdum_.

Myself, I have no problems with guns being defined as devices for killing. In fact, if when I sign up for my annual bout of Reserve duty, someone hands me a thing he calls “a device meant to propell a piece of metal at great speed”, I’d give it back and ask for a damn weapon. I _want_ something designed for killing human beings.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Captain\_Amazing](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/c/6de8d8/32.png) [@Captain\_Amazing](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Captain_Amazing)\
**Post date:** [June 14, 2004, 4:06pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/77 "2004-06-14T16:06:32Z")

</div>

> [@Alessan](#):
>
> It’s _reductum ad absurdum_.

Eh, yeah, it probably is. I just get tired of statements like, (as seen in this thread)

“Guns are tools of death!”  
“Guns are tools of life!”

because they’re really nothing more than just appeals to emotion. They don’t have anything to do with whether or not owning a gun is legal, moral, or wise.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![blowero](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/b/41988e/32.png) [@blowero](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/blowero)\
**Post date:** [June 14, 2004, 6:44pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/78 "2004-06-14T18:44:37Z")

</div>

> [@erislover](#):
>
> Quote:  
> Originally Posted by blowero  
> You guys are missing a major point. If we assume that the 2nd Amendment protects the right to form militias, that doesn’t mean that you CAN’T own firearms individually, it merely means that the decision is left to THE STATES.
> 
> I don’t think this is a totally obvious conclusion.

I didn’t say it was. Perhaps you missed the magic word “if” that was right at the beginning of my sentence.

> [@](#):
>
> “The right to bear arms shall not be infringed” has a pretty unambiguous reading. If the context is in a militia, then that term needs to be clarified, but it is pretty hard, in my opinion, to twist the first part around in such a way as to invalidate the second part.

I wasn’t getting into that argument at all. I happen to disagree with you that “The right to bear arms shall not be infringed” ought to be interpreted on its own without the context of the rest of the sentence, but let’s leave that argument alone, because frankly, I’m sick of arguing that.

What I _was_ saying was that " **If we assume that the 2nd Amendment protects the right to form militias** , that doesn’t mean that you CAN’T own firearms individually, it merely means that the decision is left to THE STATES.

My point was in response to **furt’s** statement: “if you want to make the case that gun owners must be a part of an organized private militia, go ahead.” But if (notice the word if, please) one makes the argument that the Second Amendment applies only to militias, that is NOT the same as saying “you can only own a gun if you are in a militia”. Understand yet? Saying that something is not _protected_ does not mean it is _forbidden_.

> [@](#):
>
> ## Blowero: Under the collective interpretation of the Second Amendment, states can pass laws regulating individual ownership of guns, but it doesn’t mean they have to.
> 
> I think under any but the uber-looney interpretation regulations may be passed.

Then we are in agreement. You believe that under the Constitution, states _can_ regulate guns. Therefore, you do not have an absolute right to own a gun.

> [@](#):
>
> ## Blowero: States don’t have to be explicitly given permission in the U.S. Constitution for every law they pass.
> 
> But obviously they have to be in line with the US consitution when they do pass laws. If there is no discrimination as a federal law, a state doesn’t reserve the right to discriminate.

Exactly. That’s a great example. In the absence of a Federal law, the states could and did discriminate, and only stopped when civil rights laws were passed and aggressively enforced. That’s the whole point - if a particular type of state legislation is prohibited by law, then the states can’t pass such legislation. But they aren’t _automatically_ prohibited just because something _isn’t_ explicitly mentioned.

So again:

Saying: “The 2nd Amendment only applies to militias” is NOT equivalent to saying: “Individuals cannot own guns.”

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![BobLibDem](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/boblibdem/32/3149_2.png) [@BobLibDem](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/BobLibDem)\
**Post date:** [June 14, 2004, 6:49pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/79 "2004-06-14T18:49:19Z")

</div>

> [@RandomLetters](#):
>
> This sounds more like a GD topic, but [here is the Great Master Cecil’s take on the Second Amendment.](http://www.straightdope.com/classics/a5_123.html) I generally agree with him of course.

Cecil is of course generally a pretty intelligent guy. But I happen to disagree with him on this issue- the quotes are from Cecil’s columns referenced above unless noted otherwise.

> [@](#):
>
> Historically there have been two interpretations of the Second Amendment: the states-rights argument and the individual-rights argument. The states-rights view is that the Second Amendment merely guarantees the states the right to organize militias and citizens the right to join. (Militia here means any armed force raised for the common defense, not just the national guard.) The individual-rights view is that the Second Amendment means what it says: citizens have the right to keep and bear arms. The states-rights view currently prevails in federal case law, but the individual-rights view is probably closer to the framers’ intent…
> 
> This is a crock. The legal precedents are far from clear. They are also pathetically sparse, suggesting a reluctance on the part of the courts and the legal community generally to deal with the issue

I beg to differ with the “pathetically sparse” comment, see [this list of court rulings on the Second Amendment](http://www.gunlawsuits.org/downloads/militiav.pdf) not the most non-partisan cite but the list of rulings is easily verified. If the individual rights view is closer to the framers’ intent, then one would think the courts would also take that position.

> [@](#):
>
> The framers likely would have objected to a blanket proscription of handguns, which they would have seen as legitimate weapons of self-defense, and arguably they would have opposed a ban on assault rifles, the AK-47 being to today’s oppressed what the long rifle was to those of 1776

Huh? I agree with the first part, but the AK-47 being to today’s oppressed what the long rifle was to those of 1776??? I’m just not following this logic. Unless the oppressed are the drug dealers.

> [@](#):
>
> Let’s put it this way: it was not meant to be beyond regulation. The question is whether the power to regulate encompasses the power to banSo far as guns are concerned, the courts have held that it does. You may say outlawing guns altogether was not what you had in mind. But it’s certainly what some people have in mind, at least with respect to broad categories of firearms such as handguns, and a few would happily prohibit guns, period. Federal case law currently offers virtually no protection against such draconian measures.

OK, SOME people (and a very distinct MINORITY) would like to ban all guns, and federal case law offers no protection against such a measure. True enough. But not a sound reason for misinterpreting the Second Amendment.

> [@](#):
>
> However odd it strikes us today, the framers regarded private gun ownership as one of the pillars of their liberty. They had recently defeated one of the most powerful nations in the world using an army that in the early going had consisted of amateur soldiers using their own weapons. They considered these citizen militias vastly preferable to standing armies, which in their experience had been instruments of oppression. They also had no professional police force upon which to depend for defense of their lives and property. It seemed natural to them that ordinary folk should have the right to own guns.

True, the American militia defeated a superior army, but there was a rather conspicuous accomplice- the French. But in modern times, we’ve seen tyrannical governments (USSR, E Germany, Poland, etc) fall without armed uprising of the citizenry. We’ve also seen a tyrannical government in Iraq fall from outside forces and a stable government have difficulty in forming BECAUSE of mad packs of armed citizens. We’ve seen numerous Latin Ameican nations suffer many revolutions because of these armed militias. We’ve seen Lenin, Hitler, and Castro use armed revolution to create tyrannical governments. The American Revolution is the exception to the rule, not a noble pattern that has been widely followed. A better way to overcome tyranny is exemplified by Gandhi, Mandela, and Martin Luther King. Guns in and of themselves are not the path to liberty, and liberty is not always the result of gunfire and bloodshed.

> [@](#):
>
> Put yourself in a gun owner’s shoes. While the first half of the Second Amendment is no miracle of clarity, the second half is about as plain as it can be. “The right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed.” But gun-control advocates deny this sentence means what it seems perfectly evident it says, and the courts have backed them up. Gun owners’ recognition that one of their most cherished rights has been interpreted out of existence accounts for the apocalyptic tone in which their arguments are often framed

Actually, the two halves are in ONE SENTENCE! True, the first half is no miracle of clarity, but it is still there. The first half qualifies the second half. Just because “Gun owners’ recognition that one of their most cherished rights has been interpreted out of existence” doesn’t give them license to ignore half of an Amendment.

> [@](#):
>
> Likewise we should concede that the Second Amendment means what it seems to mean and that if we want to control guns to the point of prohibition, amending the amendment is the honest thing to do.

Well, it would be honest if we were controlling guns to the point of prohibition. But very few advocate that. Sensible regulations are consistent with the existing Second Amendment. The ones who need a change in the constitutional status quo are the gun rights advocates, not the gun control advocates.

Back to the OP- The militia clause is there. It has been interpreted many times by many courts in the collectivist viewpoint. If you want an absolute right of individual ownership of guns, then you’ll need to adopt a new Amendment, not ignore half of an old one.

Some quotes from Warren Burger, a conservative gun-owning Nixon appointee. See[the American Bar Association](http://www.abanet.org/irr/hr/fall99humanrights/blek.html)

> [@](#):
>
> The National Rifle Association’s (NRA) continuous omission of the “well-regulated militia” language in its literature speaks volumes. It even prompted former U.S. Supreme Court Chief Justice Warren Burger to comment:It’s the simplest thing: a well-regulated militia. If the militia—which is what we now call the National Guard—essentially has to be well-regulated, in heaven’s name why shouldn’t we regulate 14-, 15-, and 16-year old kids having handguns or hoodlums having machine guns? I was raised on a farm, and we had guns around the house all the time. So I’m not against guns, but the National Rifle Association has done one of the most amazing jobs of misrepresenting and misleading the public." (USA Today, December 16, 1991)

I think there’s a lot of room for common sense gun regulation and the existing Second Amendment offers this room.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![erislover](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/e/71e660/32.png) [@erislover](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/erislover)\
**Post date:** [June 14, 2004, 7:05pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/80 "2004-06-14T19:05:33Z")

</div>

> [@BobLibDem](#):
>
> Huh? I agree with the first part, but the AK-47 being to today’s oppressed what the long rifle was to those of 1776??? I’m just not following this logic. Unless the oppressed are the drug dealers.

Maybe it is WRT guns people had versus guns the military had? I don’t know either, but usually if I don’t follow an argument I don’t reject it.

> [@](#):
>
> OK, SOME people (and a very distinct MINORITY) would like to ban all guns, and federal case law offers no protection against such a measure. True enough. But not a sound reason for misinterpreting the Second Amendment.

For “misinterpreting” it? Loading your statement much?

> [@](#):
>
> True, the American militia defeated a superior army, but there was a rather conspicuous accomplice- the French.

And, hopefully, there’d be an accomplice again. And?

> [@](#):
>
> But in modern times, we’ve seen tyrannical governments (USSR, E Germany, Poland, etc) fall without armed uprising of the citizenry.

Forgive me for saying so, but I wouldn’t want to wait decades for a shitty, tyrannical, oppressive government to fall just because people were a little twitchy about public firearm possession. That’s frankly not a cost I’m willing to bear.

> [@](#):
>
> We’ve also seen a tyrannical government in Iraq fall from outside forces and a stable government have difficulty in forming BECAUSE of mad packs of armed citizens.

As much as I support the fact “Saddam gone == good”, you’re talking about a conquered nation. Of course there is going to be insurrection, instability, etc.

> [@](#):
>
> We’ve seen numerous Latin Ameican nations suffer many revolutions because of these armed militias.

Or is it because of the governments they’re against?

> [@](#):
>
> The American Revolution is the exception to the rule, not a noble pattern that has been widely followed.

What has been widely followed is that many governments have indeed oppressed in order to consolidate power. America has mechanisms that _protect_ against such a thing, but no mechanism can _guarantee_ it. If the uprising is unpopular and small enough, existing mechanisms will quell it and otherwise address the problems. If the uprising is large enough, we’re talking about a point at which your beloved mechanisms have totally failed for a large portion of the population.

> [@](#):
>
> A better way to overcome tyranny is exemplified by Gandhi, Mandela, and Martin Luther King. Guns in and of themselves are not the path to liberty, and liberty is not always the result of gunfire and bloodshed.

I do not care to glorify martyrs. Better to not need them, thanks.

Actually, the two halves are in ONE SENTENCE! True, the first half is no miracle of clarity, but it is still there. The first half qualifies the second half. Just because “Gun owners’ recognition that one of their most cherished rights has been interpreted out of existence” doesn’t give them license to ignore half of an Amendment.

Well, it would be honest if we were controlling guns to the point of prohibition. But very few advocate that. Sensible regulations are consistent with the existing Second Amendment. The ones who need a change in the constitutional status quo are the gun rights advocates, not the gun control advocates.

Back to the OP- The militia clause is there. It has been interpreted many times by many courts in the collectivist viewpoint. If you want an absolute right of individual ownership of guns, then you’ll need to adopt a new Amendment, not ignore half of an old one.

Some quotes from Warren Burger, a conservative gun-owning Nixon appointee. See[the American Bar Association](http://www.abanet.org/irr/hr/fall99humanrights/blek.html)

I think there’s a lot of room for common sense gun regulation and the existing Second Amendment offers this room.  
[/QUOTE]

[Previous page](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950.md?page=3)

[Next page](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950.md?page=5)
