# "A well regulated militia"

**URL:** <https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950>\
**Category:** Great Debates\
**Created:** [June 12, 2004, 6:40am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950 "2004-06-12T06:40:51Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 15\
**Page:** 8

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![BobLibDem](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/boblibdem/32/3149_2.png) [@BobLibDem](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/BobLibDem)\
**Post date:** [June 18, 2004, 5:41pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/141 "2004-06-18T17:41:53Z")

</div>

UncleBeer, If I understand correctly your position is that both U.S. v. Miller and United States v. Cruikshank should be overturned. With the number of times these have served as precedents and the near unanimity of the courts in upholding these rulings (Emerson being the sole notable exception), this seems quite unlikely.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![ExTank](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/e/35a633/32.png) [@ExTank](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/ExTank)\
**Post date:** [June 18, 2004, 6:28pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/142 "2004-06-18T18:28:16Z")

</div>

**ElvisL1ves:**

> [@](#):
>
> A debate involves honestly considering what differing views are presented to you, not simply denouncing them, and those who present them. If one is so sure one is right that that does not need to be done, then it’s a waste of time to talk about it instead of acting on it.

Well said!

Unfortunately, if this isn’t the biggest crock of intellectual hypocrisy, then I’d be hard-pressed to find a greater example.

**Elvis,** listen to your own nuggets of wisdom and heed them well, for I’ve never, _ever, **not once,** _ seen you concede a single, solitary point in a Gun Control Debate.

I’ll admit to some occassionally specious reasoning from the pro-gun crowd here in GD; almost invariably, it is a relative newbie sprouting the superficial propaganda of the NRA without having done their research and homework.

This is not the reasoning you will get (and have received!) from the more established and more firmly grounded crowd you have been mostly dealing with these last three pages; reasoning, backed up with historical precedence and firmly documented, to which we receive so much “piffle” for response.

**Dewey:**  **Uncle** isn’t saying that those 92 instances were actions of the court; they were 92 instances where the Second Amendment had been mentioned in a Supreme Court case. Period. To illustrate the point that the courts have not been silent on the issue.

The judgements and cites themselves were **NOT** mentioned by **Uncle;** he was attributing no value to them one way or another, only that they existed, as refutation to the assertion that the higher courts were silent on the issue of the Second Amendment.

They _have_ indeed been silent on the issue of a definitive ruling one way or another. I have seen some that mention the Second Amendment and certainly seem to imply by inference an individual right; and just as often I have seen the opposite.

The term “schizo” has been applied to the higher courts on the whole individual/collective rights issue, and, sadly, that seems to be the one and only truism.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![ElvisL1ves](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/e/5daacb/32.png) [@ElvisL1ves](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/ElvisL1ves)\
**Post date:** [June 18, 2004, 6:41pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/143 "2004-06-18T18:41:03Z")

</div>

> [@ExTank](#):
>
> **Elvis,** listen to your own nuggets of wisdom and heed them well, for I’ve never, _ever, **not once,** _ seen you concede a single, solitary point in a Gun Control Debate.

You have “never” etc. pointed out where I’ve been wrong, either in facts or in reasoning. We’re not taking any votes here, not trying to agree on any compromise we can all live with, we’re establishing points of fact and reasoning.

> [@](#):
>
> This is not the reasoning you will get (and have received!) from the more established and more firmly grounded crowd you have been mostly dealing with these last three pages; reasoning, backed up with historical precedence and firmly documented, to which we receive so much “piffle” for response.

An intellectual argument contrary to the Supreme Court’s findings is possible, sure - but remains _academic_. You might as well try to explain how the reasoning in _Brown v. Board of Ed_. is wrong, and therefore that the ruling was “undefinitive”.

The law is _settled_. The reality is what it is. The strenuous insistence to the contrary that is common to those of your persuasion, can certainly be dismissed out of hand. What are \*you \* doing to get that amendment under way, fella?

> [@](#):
>
> **Uncle** isn’t saying that those 92 instances were actions of the court; they were 92 instances where the Second Amendment had been mentioned in a Supreme Court case. Period. To illustrate the point that the courts have not been silent on the issue.

What point is that? That the courts have \*complied \* with the Miller interpretation ever since it was handed down? That they’ve ruled in other gun-rights cases according to it? Sure the Second Amendment has been mentioned in passing in those cases. What’s the argument there?

> [@](#):
>
> They _have_ indeed been silent on the issue of a definitive ruling one way or another.

A definitive ruling having \*been \* made, there is no \*need \* for further comment.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![ElvisL1ves](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/e/5daacb/32.png) [@ElvisL1ves](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/ElvisL1ves)\
**Post date:** [June 18, 2004, 6:54pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/144 "2004-06-18T18:54:17Z")

</div>

> [@UncleBeer](#):
>
> Yep. Which means there’s ambiguity. And room for everyone to argue their viewpoint.

Not in court, there isn’t.

> [@](#):
>
> No matter what ElvisL1ves may believe, I’m not trying to force my opinion on the rest of you.

I don’t think you’re trying that, because you know you cannot “force” anyone to agree with you. Your attempts at what you think to be “persuasion” continue to be strident rants, unfortunately.

> [@](#):
>
> The quite clear matter of fact is, that the people, in the late 1700’s, had the right to possess private arms for whatever reason.

A lot of things have changed over two and a half centuries, a lot of rights bestowed and removed. The FF’s knew the world would keep changing and that the Constitution would need amending. Nowhere can you point to anything definitive that shows they thought they were making rules that would last for eternity, or that later generations should be bound by the morality of the day. We are not a religious community like the Amish or Hasidim, bound by the customs and social rules that applied at the time and place of its founder; we’re a democratic republic.

> [@](#):
>
> And the evidence presented—in this thread and indeed anywhere else that I’ve seen—that the Second Amendent didn’t/doesn’t recognize that reality, and in fact sought to overturn it, just isn’t, _to me_, persuasive.

Once again, for us, in the Twenty First Century, _that just doesn’t matter._ We live today under today’s laws and today’s standing interpretations of the Constitution as provided by the courts, and if we don’t like some or all of it today we have ways to change that today. Arguments derived from the extinct realities of the distant past “just aren’t (to us) _persuasive_.”

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![ExTank](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/e/35a633/32.png) [@ExTank](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/ExTank)\
**Post date:** [June 18, 2004, 9:20pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/145 "2004-06-18T21:20:40Z")

</div>

**Elvis:**

> [@](#):
>
> The law is _settled._

[_No, it isn’t._](http://www.guncite.com/journals/dencite.html)

> [@](#):
>
> What would have happened, for example, if Miller and Layton had retained an attorney to represent them at oral argument and put on evidence about the militia and weapons that militia members generally possessed? Or what if they had argued that the introductory phrase of the Second Amendment merely expressed a widespread sentiment against standing armies and was not meant to qualify or to limit the “right of the people to keep and bear arms?” Given the incomplete record before the Miller court, as well as the very narrow holding of the case, questions regarding the meaning of the Second Amendment and its outer limits should be regarded as far from settled.

**Brannon P. Dennigan**  
_Can The Simple Cite Be Trusted?_

A position that I have argued for several years before having heard of this guy. I wonder: now that an actual _lawyer_ has said these words whether or not **minty** will acknowledge the simple truth contained therein: _Miller_ didn’t hold a collective right view; is far from definitive; and that subsequent cases have misquoted _Miller,_ and badly, in a tragedy of unjustness.

> [@](#):
>
> What are you doing to get that amendment under way, fella?

Well, I’m _not_ supporting the greedy bastards in the National Rifle Association any more, that’s for starters. Nor The Second Amendment Foundation, either.

I’ll get back to you with the name, address and telephone number of an organization worthy of supporting as soon as I have located one.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![ExTank](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/e/35a633/32.png) [@ExTank](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/ExTank)\
**Post date:** [June 18, 2004, 9:22pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/146 "2004-06-18T21:22:29Z")

</div>

P.S.: Don’t hold your breath.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![minty\_green](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/m/f6c823/32.png) [@minty\_green](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/minty_green)\
**Post date:** [June 18, 2004, 10:57pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/147 "2004-06-18T22:57:47Z")

</div>

> [@ExTank](#):
>
> I wonder: now that an actual _lawyer_ has said these words whether or not **minty** will acknowledge the simple truth contained therein: _Miller_ didn’t hold a collective right view; is far from definitive; and that subsequent cases have misquoted _Miller,_ and badly, in a tragedy of unjustness.

When have I ever claimed that _Miller_ holds that the Second Amendment guarantee is a collective right?

What I will tell you is that _Miller_ is certainly consistent with the collective rights view than the individual rights view. After all, _Miller_ indisputably establishes that the introductory “militia” clause places a substantive limitation on the guarantee of the second clause, i.e., guns that aren’t suitable for the militia are not covered by the guarantee.

Personally, I hold to an individual rights reading of the amendment. Like the 5th Circuit in _Emerson_, I see no other way to read “the people.” But I also read the introductory clause as a limitation on the scope of the guarantee in the second clause, and construe the two together.

But regardless of whether I agree or disagree with the courts, I just have to chuckle at your claim of “a tragedy of unjustness.” Hey, lighten up already. 🙂

Now, on to your cite:

> [@](#):
>
> What would have happened, for example, if Miller and Layton had retained an attorney to represent them at oral argument and put on evidence about the militia and weapons that militia members generally possessed?

They would have been laughed out of the courtroom by the justices. You don’t “put on evidence” at the Supreme Court. Evidence is admitted in a trial court, not in an appellate court. On appeal, you just argue about what the law is and whether the existing evidence is good enough to support whatever your legal position is.

I would this Denning guy with a big ol’ grain of salt if he thinks you can put on evidence at the Supreme Court. Besides, the whole “what if” argument is inherently silly. The fact is that the defendants didn’t show up in the Supreme Court, and the Court issued the opinion that it did, thereby making it the law of the land.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![ExTank](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/e/35a633/32.png) [@ExTank](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/ExTank)\
**Post date:** [June 19, 2004, 12:58am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/148 "2004-06-19T00:58:53Z")

</div>

**Minty:** C’mon, now. How can you make an argument without citing fact and precedent? The very fact and precedent that would have shown (been evidence that) the government’s case was a load of unmitigated hogwash?

The argument of existing facts as to the nature of the militia (it’s makeup and armaments) would have most likely blown the government’s case clean out of the water, a _fact_ acknowledged in the 1st Circuit’s decision in _U.S. v. Case,_ IIRC, when they acknowledged the _Miller_ decision (quite correctly) in that the militia, being made up of the body or mass of citizenry, would most likely be armed to a great variety of weaponry, like the “commando units” they cite.

The greatest misapprehension in the “collective rights” view is that the militia for the greatest time in our history was made up of ordinary people armed with ordinary equipment: rifles, pistols, shotguns and blades of every type, length, caliber, etc.

It is only after the organization of the National Guard, codified and acknowledged in Federal Law as “the organized militia,” that any such notion as a “collective view” can even begin to be entertained; and it is still, even in light of “organized” and “unorganized” militias (10 USC Ch. 13, p.113), as deceitful and ingenuous as ever it was conceived.

While _Perpich v. Department of Defense_ held (correctly, IMHO) that the State Guard and National Guard are essentially one and the same (to wit: a Federal agency), it in no way invalidates the concept or _legal fact_ of the _unorganized militia;_ what a previous poster has referred to as “gun-totin’ yahoos.”

Being one of those yahoos, I will acknowledge this: the forming, organizing and equippping of a “National Guard” was not in and of itself a bad thing; given the advancing technical nature of organized warfare, Congress and the Executive branch were well within their duty, their _obligation,_ to form such a body.

But this formation, IMO, did _not_ obviate the unorganized militia in _fact;_ merely practice. And any such attempt to do so _in fact_ should be addressed seriously as a Constitutional matter, head-on and forthright, than this steady erosion and often willfull misinterpretation of _Miller,_ of a right guaranteed, in plain english to those who have a care to read the precedents with honesty and without preconception, of our right as citizens to keep and bear arms.

In fact, an _honest_ interpretation of _Miller_ (as opposed to this half-assed mess we currently have) would lay the National Firearms Act, much of the Gun Control Act _and_ The Crime Omnibus to nines, for they curtail the “keeping and bearing” of such arms that would be of value, to quote _Miller,_"…of rendering effective the Militia."

Would such an expansive view be harmfull to society? Given the evidence at hand (the “roaring twenties,” the violent crime associated with organized crime), I would say that it is altogether probable. Thus, I have nothing against The National Firearms Act _in principle._

But in execution, that act, along with subsequent amendments and Acts, have rendered such a state of affairs that decent citizens have been tarred with the same brush and uneasy apprehension as that of criminals. For criminals are dangerous enough with semi-auto “assault weapons;” what would they be like re-armed with “Tommy Guns,” or even M-16’s and M-60s?

Thus, a rational set of policies, applied evenly across the nation, would be (and to some extent have been) necessary; would additional policies be of even greater efficacy? Possibly, so long as they do not throw out the good in order to weed out the bad. And thus the crux of the matter is finally arrived:

ON the one hand, we have citizens who live in fear of criminals and random criminal acts, or of oppressive governemnt, and who seek to arm themsleves rather than be victims; they are labeled by the pro-control crowd a “paranoid nut-jobs.” Given the nature of society and history of governements, I cannot see how this derogatory mind-set is honestly arrived at.

AND on the other, we have citizens who do not wish to be the victims of gun owners, _legal or otherwise,_ by accident or design, and who wish some mechanism of law to be firmly in place to stop the good from crossing the line into being the bad (here the term “paranoid” may also be equally applied by their adversaries, IMO).

This is not an unlaudable goal; however, given the diverse nature of humanity, particulalry in our polyglot United States, it may well be unattainable to any practical extent _without the other, armed half of society forfeiting their rights entirely._

Now: as to the wording of the amendment in and of itself, I can only apologize for being unable to currently locate the cite I am searching for. It is essentially a linguistic analysis of the Second Amendment by an English professor, specializing in colonial language, in which he asserts that the preamble (A well-regulated militia…) is the subjective clause, and that the true operative clause is “…the right of the people to keep and bear arms…”.

I will recall that this professor is not a paid consultant of either side of the debate, owns no firearms, and had no particualr leaning on the issue of gun control, one way or the other. I will continue to look for this article, but will be leaving town for the next week on Sunday, and my time may be limited.

As to the quoting of Hamilton and Federalist 29, I can only say this: Hamilton _was_ a Federalist, the true antecedent to “Manifest Destiny” and our current NeoCons. I believe Hamilton didn’t give a good goddamned one way or another about the militia, and simply wrote #29 to sop the Anti-Federalists. His true aim is made readily clear in subsequent paragraphs when he says:

> [@](#):
>
> “The project of disciplining all the militia of the United States is as futile as it would be injurious, if it were capable of being carried into execution. A tolerable expertness in military movements is a business that requires time and practice. It is not a day, or even a week, that will suffice for the attainment of it. To oblige the great body of the yeomanry, and of the other classes of the citizens, to be under arms for the purpose of going through military exercises and evolutions, as often as might be necessary to acquire the degree of perfection which would entitle them to the character of a well-regulated militia, would be a real grievance to the people, and a serious public inconvenience and loss. **It would form an annual deduction from the productive labor of the country, to an amount which, calculating upon the present numbers of the people, would not fall far short of the whole expense of the civil establishments of all the States. To attempt a thing which would abridge the mass of labor and industry to so considerable an extent, would be unwise: and the experiment, if made, could not succeed, because it would not long be endured.** Little more can reasonably be aimed at, with respect to the people at large, than to have them properly armed and equipped; and in order to see that this be not neglected, it will be necessary to assemble them once or twice in the course of a year.”

Money talks, militia walks. And that’s what I think of Alexander Hamilton and Federalist #29. Small wonder he wound up on one of our currencies.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![ExTank](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/e/35a633/32.png) [@ExTank](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/ExTank)\
**Post date:** [June 19, 2004, 1:06am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/149 "2004-06-19T01:06:36Z")

</div>

I found it!

But first, my retraction (my memory ain’t what it used to be): the article is written by J. Neil Schulman, in which he cites Professor of Journalism Roy Copperud (retired), formerly of U.S.C.

[Enjoy!](http://www.constitution.org/2ll/schol/2amd_grammar.htm)

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![minty\_green](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/m/f6c823/32.png) [@minty\_green](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/minty_green)\
**Post date:** [June 19, 2004, 2:18am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/150 "2004-06-19T02:18:08Z")

</div>

> [@ExTank](#):
>
> **Minty:** C’mon, now. How can you make an argument without citing fact and precedent? The very fact and precedent that would have shown (been evidence that) the government’s case was a load of unmitigated hogwash?
> 
> The argument of existing facts as to the nature of the militia (it’s makeup and armaments) would have most likely blown the government’s case clean out of the water, a _fact_ acknowledged in the 1st Circuit’s decision in _U.S. v. Case,_ IIRC, when they acknowledged the _Miller_ decision (quite correctly) in that the militia, being made up of the body or mass of citizenry, would most likely be armed to a great variety of weaponry, like the “commando units” they cite.

You misunderstand what constitutes a “fact” for purposes of the legal system. Facts are proven by evidence that is admitted in the trial court, either at hearing or at trial. (Depending on the situation, courts also deal with facts as they are alleged by the parties, without having to resort to evidence in support of those facts–mostly when determining whether the parties are even entitled to try to prove their set of facts. We’ll ignore that for present purposes.) Whether a sawed-off shotgun is suitable for militia use is a matter of fact that would have to be proven by formal evidence–perhaps testimony by a commander in the National Guard, perhaps through the admission of similar firearms that are actually used in the military. No evidence of suitability means the point is not established.

So guess what happens if you don’t offer any evidence of a point in the trial court? That’s it. It’s over. You don’t get to supplement the record on appeal, you don’t get to tell the Supreme Court that the Iowa National Guard equips all of its troops with sawed-off shotguns, you don’t get the justices to determine for themselves that sawed-off shotguns are wonderfully apt for militia use. You just lose.

> [@](#):
>
> In fact, an _honest_ interpretation of _Miller_ (as opposed to this half-assed mess we currently have) would lay the National Firearms Act, much of the Gun Control Act _and_ The Crime Omnibus to nines, for they curtail the “keeping and bearing” of such arms that would be of value, to quote _Miller,_"…of rendering effective the Militia."

Could we kindly drop this sort of rhetoric about “honest” interpretations of ambiguous texts? Because the unmistakable implication of that statement is that any interpretation other than your own is _dis_honest, and that’s not terribly conducive to reasonable discussion of the issue.

And on a similar note:

> [@](#):
>
> . . . what a previous poster has referred to as “gun-totin’ yahoos” . . .
> 
> . . . Being one of those yahoos . . .
> 
> . . . they are labeled by the pro-control crowd a “paranoid nut-jobs” . . .
> 
> . . . here the term “paranoid” may also be equally applied by their adversaries, IMO. . .

Persecuted much? I do not recall any previous poster to this thread throwing around such terms. So why would you choose to wallow in them?

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![ExTank](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/e/35a633/32.png) [@ExTank](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/ExTank)\
**Post date:** [June 19, 2004, 3:34am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/151 "2004-06-19T03:34:15Z")

</div>

**scotandrsn:**

> [@](#):
>
> To me, it looks like a win-win situation. The lefties get real regulation of firearms, and the righties get a state-tax-supported gun club on steroids, plus the public’s opinion of them as Defenders of the State Sovereignty rather than a bunch of gun-totin’ yahoos.

In all honesty, **scot** didn’t actually call “the militia” a bunch of gun-totin’ yahoos himself; and I actually liked his proposal

And I failed to mention this, from **Blalron:**

> [@](#):
>
> Not a bunch of unorganized rednecks running around with guns.

:checking the color of my neck:

Nope; standard Caucasian. SPF 45 is my friend; and my knees are such that I don’t do much running. A brisk walk is about all my knees (and ankles, too, for that matter) will abide. Running with a gun is kind of like running with scissors; occasionally necessary, but not wise.

And are you really going to make me wade through a search of previous gun control threads for the term “paranoid nut-jobs”? I’ll do it if I must…

Persecuted? Nah. Just grossly misunderstood. Besides, the _unorganized militia_ can hardly be faulted for being, er, well, _unorganized,_ now, can it?

So, if I take your definition of “fact” (and I indeed do), then how is it, in arguing _Miller_ in the highest court, that the government could even put forth an argument about the suitability of a sawed-off shotgun as an argument of _fact_ in front of the court when it had not previously done so in the trial court? Never mind that no one was there to refute such a claim in the first place.

If they had advanced such an argument in the trial court, and it was found…_wanting_… for lack of the proper legalese, then how could it have been admitted at the higher court?

And does the Supreme Court often, now and then, here such one-sided cases? It would seem to me that that gives a governement, with near unlimited funds and manpower, a decidedly and decisively unfair advantage over the poor (often literally) schmucks who wind up cross-wise to their agendas and policies.

I’ll check this back tomorrow, but I will most likely have little time to reply for the next week or more.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![ExTank](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/e/35a633/32.png) [@ExTank](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/ExTank)\
**Post date:** [June 19, 2004, 3:55am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/152 "2004-06-19T03:55:20Z")

</div>

Ah. I almost forgot this, **minty:**

> [@](#):
>
> Could we kindly drop this sort of rhetoric about “honest” interpretations of ambiguous texts? Because the unmistakable implication of that statement is that any interpretation other than your own is dishonest, and that’s not terribly conducive to reasonable discussion of the issue.

So, if the _Miller_ decision was/is ambiguous (your words; and a point I may grudgingly concede at some future point, but not just yet), can we not then reasonably say that _definitive_ collective-rights rulings citing _Miller_ in subsequent Circuit and Appellate Court rulings are quite possibly proceding from false notions?

I address this question not to you (for you have made your personal opinion distinct from your legal opinion quite clearly), but others here who hold the collective-rights view, personally and otherwise, quite dear and correct.

If anyone holding the collective-rights view can honestly admit, at least as far as _Miller_ and subsequent rulings citing _Miller_ and all its ambiguity is concerned, it may not be entirely as _correct_ as some would wish… _then_ I believe that an honest debate may be had here.

Until then, I yield _:Michael Corleone voice: **nothing.** _

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![blowero](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/b/41988e/32.png) [@blowero](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/blowero)\
**Post date:** [June 19, 2004, 7:04am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/153 "2004-06-19T07:04:26Z")

</div>

> [@UncleBeer](#):
>
> **Blowero:  
> I’m saying that Madison’s original text was changed, and appears to have been changed in order to de-emphasize the individual-rights aspect of the amendment. You assert that such is not the case. On what evidence do you base that assertion?**
> 
> Because “well regulated” didn’t mean to the authors what you think it means. “Well regulated” simply meant “well functioning.” Here’s a contemporary use of the term from the 1789 charter for the University of North Carolina:  
> It is simply not possible for “well regulated,” as used in that charter holds the meaning you are trying to give it.

But that has nothing to do with the point at hand. We were discussing the fact that the order of the clauses was changed, and that a semicolon, which you said yourself serves to make two concepts seperate, was changed to a comma, which connects two concepts. You have completely changed the direction of our discussion.

> [@](#):
>
> Also, Madison’s proposed text **isn’t** the original that was considered. Several states, when holding their conventions to ratify the Constitution, passed along to the Congress about to form, more than 100 proposed amendments.

If that’s the case, then it seem rather disingenous of you to quote Madison’s proposed text alone, as though it ought to be the definitive writing with which to interpret the Second Amendment. That’s pretty much what you did in your previous post.

> [@](#):
>
> **1)** 2/3 of the states, at the time the Constitution was being debated, statutorily protected the \*private[/] right of their citizens to keep and bear arms - for whatever purpose.

Even if that’s not exaggerated, it still means that 1/3 DID NOT.

> [@](#):
>
> **2)** Here’s what _Anti-Federalist_ Richard Henry Lee wrote in his pamphlet _An Additional Number of Letters From the Federal Farmer to the Republican,_ published in May of 1788.
> 
> “. . . to preserve liberty, it is essential that the whole body of the people always possess arms, and be taught alike, especially when young, how to use them . . .”
> 
> \*\*3)\*\*Don B. Kates has stated in the Michigan Law Review (1983)
> 
> Thus you can see that I’m **not** cherry-picking data that would fit a preformed conclusion. The great body of “The People” at that time in history, not only had private arms and quite logically expected to be permitted to retain them, but in many case were also _required_ to own guns.

Actually you _are_ cherry-picking. You just quoted only people who believed in gun ownership for everyone. But not everyone held that opinion. You didn’t provide quotes from any of them. Isn’t that the definition of cherry-picking?

> [@](#):
>
> On what evidence do you base your assertion that the 2nd amendment refers to a collective right? Because a collective right certainly wasn’t the situtation at the time. Neither by tradition, nor by law.

I don’t think you’ve proven that at all. Some colonies allowed gun ownership, and some colonies had restrictions on gun ownership. Some people believed in a right to personally own a gun, and some didn’t. This idea that colonial militias were just any Joe who happened to own a gun is absurd. Militias were organized, had a chain of command, kept records, gave pensions, etc. Any attempt to say otherwise is revisionist history. And there’s a great deal of evidence to suggest that the Second Amendment was crafted to protect states’ rights against a federal standing army, not to say “Gee, everyone gets to have a gun”.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![minty\_green](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/m/f6c823/32.png) [@minty\_green](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/minty_green)\
**Post date:** [June 19, 2004, 2:03pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/154 "2004-06-19T14:03:07Z")

</div>

[QUOTE=ExTankSo, if I take your definition of “fact” (and I indeed do), then how is it, in arguing _Miller_ in the highest court, that the government could even put forth an argument about the suitability of a sawed-off shotgun as an argument of _fact_ in front of the court when it had not previously done so in the trial court? Never mind that no one was there to refute such a claim in the first place.

If they had advanced such an argument in the trial court, and it was found…_wanting_… for lack of the proper legalese, then how could it have been admitted at the higher court?[/QUOTE]  
The problem is that Miller and the other defendant didn’t put on any evidence in the trial court, and on a matter for which they bore the burden of proof. Having failed to do so in the trial court, they cannot put on evidence in the Supreme Court in an belated attempt to establish the fact of militia suitability on appeal.

You can _argue_ the facts and what they mean all you want on appeal, but it has to be supported by evidence or the court will be required to reject your argument.

“Your honors, my client did not commit this murder.”

“What evidence in the record supports that contention.”

“None. We didn’t put on any evidence. But I have here an expert report that says it’s impossible for him to have committed the crime, and here are three witnesses who can conclusively establish his alibi, plus a confession of the real perpetrator.”

“Affirmed.”

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![minty\_green](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/m/f6c823/32.png) [@minty\_green](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/minty_green)\
**Post date:** [June 19, 2004, 2:09pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950/155 "2004-06-19T14:09:55Z")

</div>

> [@ExTank](#):
>
> So, if the _Miller_ decision was/is ambiguous (your words; and a point I may grudgingly concede at some future point, but not just yet), can we not then reasonably say that _definitive_ collective-rights rulings citing _Miller_ in subsequent Circuit and Appellate Court rulings are quite possibly proceding from false notions?

No. One can certainly cite _Miller_ in suppport of either the collective or individual rights model. It is susceptible of being interpreted in support of either position. So long as _Miller_ is not cited as having already determined the issue, there’s nothing wrong with showing that it supports one position or another. And while I think there may be one or two old opinions that mistakenly (isn’t that so much nicer than “dishonestly”?) cite _Miller_ as determining the right is collective, the overwhelming weight of collective-rights opinions acknowledge that _Miller_ is not conclusive on the issue.

[Previous page](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/a-well-regulated-militia/249950.md?page=7)
