Am I Littering When I Release a Helium Balloon?

I understand that it sucks to find them in the wilderness, but I would assume that most of those balloons were accidentally released by children. A local grocery store would give balloons to all the kids who came through the checkout line when I was little, and I would pretty much lose every single one of them unless it was tied to my wrist. I’ve also been in a few stores which have balloons permanently stuck to the ceiling, and I’m pretty sure nobody purposefully released them there.

Well, then teach the kids to be careful with them :slight_smile: If a kid drops a candy bar wrapper while walking, I hope you don’t just smile and go “Oops, oh well!”

If a balloon flies away, next time I’d hope the parent would say “Remember what happened last time? This time we’ll tie it around your wrist so you can keep it for longer and so it doesn’t pollute the environment!”

And it’s not just the wilderness. Imagine that you live in a house with a nice, scenic wooded lot. You wake up one morning to find a large Mylar balloon stuck up high in a tree. You have the choice of hiring someone to get it down or having that piece of crap in your yard for years.

I’ve always mused about this in regards to the National Weather Service because they release 75,000 weather balloons a year. No one in their right mind would charge them with littering, but it seems strange that the government would be to allowed to do something that is illegal on a daily basis. Not that I think the government is a angel, just that their lawyers wouldn’t ok it. I guess since their instruments are contained in a postage paid package that they hope people will return, that gets around most littering laws.

Similar results here. A couple of times a week I walk the beaches on the S end of Lake Michigan. It is an unusual week that I don’t see at least one balloon washed up - and quite often there are more than one.

Now what I want to know is if you committed suicide by hanging yourself from a weather balloon that drifted across various state lines as you slowly strangled, your sphincter loosened, and you began to decompose - which state has to fill out the death certificate?

Yep, October I was on a cattle drive on our S.E. Colorado ranch and miles from civilization out on the sagebrush plains. Moving up the trail I’m surprised to see a purple mylar balloon that’s hung on some sage. There’s still a little helium left as it’s hanging droopily but still upright. I got off my ATV and walked over to get a picture, thinking maybe I’d do a “Where party ballons go to die” thread, and then dispose of it in my saddlebag. Just before I reached it though a wisp of wind caught it and carried it off aways to the hill where the B-52 crashed decades back. So the only manmade piece of litter I saw all day ended up where a number of our servicemen lost their lives years ago. While that hardly constitutes a tragedy in anyone’s book, it is kinda sad nevertheless.

How about “Chinese lanterns?” These are paper ‘globes’ that are filled with hot air from a burning fuel source at it’s base?

These fly pretty high and far once they lift off… especially if there is a bit of wind at altitude.

At least those are biodegradable.

“Litter - any solid or liquid material or product or combination of solid or liquid materials or products, including, but not limited to: any rubbish, refuse, garbage, paper, package, container, bottle, can, manure, or sewage or the whole or a part of an animal carcass or
the whole or part of any article, raw or processed material, Motor Vehicle or other machinery, that is disposed of;”

That’s a pretty lousy definition. I dispose of pounds of rubbish and garbage weekly, none of which is litter. When one flushes the toilet, one is disposing of excrement, pour that last inch in the beer bottle down the drain, that’s been disposed.

Just a guess, litter laws are not used for the release of baloons because they are not yet litter when flying away. In theory, a ballon released in the middle of texas could float to another state. Not surprisingly, most states do not prohibit littering in other states.

I didn’t find any corroborating sources, but apparently one person was (federally) charged with littering and sentenced to prison for leaving water bottles along the US-Mexico border for crossers. Damned if I could find the relevant laws on the books.

Edit: Actually, this story has more detail and cites the relevant court case.

Only recently people have understood how harmful balloons can be for animals that accidentally swallow them. Not just because of the long shards that clog up intestines untill the animal starves, but also because of the attached cord that is very dangerous. Sad picture of sea bird dead because his beak is wound shut with a balloon cord.

If by “recently” you mean “21 years ago”. I’m pretty sure balloons were covered in the 1992 book 50 Simple Things Kids Can Do to Save the Earth, which was distributed to me and every other fourth-grader when it came out.

Thank you, I will investigate the littering angle with an attorney who represents the solid waste industry. Everywhere I look I find examples of this form of sanctioned littering so it must not be against the law or it lands squarely in a gray area. For example both Clemson University and the University of Nebraska release thousands of helium balloons as part of their home football games. Here is an example. http://www.thetigernews.com/news.php?aid=6656&sid=1

A Florida man is charged with a third-degree felony for releasing balloons near wildlife.

[tiny voice]The world-wide helium shortage is no joke! stamps foot Why won’t anyone take me seriously?![/tiny voice]

.

also illegal in places around the world because they start fires.

Saw this in the news today.

http://http://www.sun-sentinel.com/news/local/crime/fl-helium-balloon-environmental-crime-20130222,0,3220328.story

They charged this guy with a felony. He could get as much as five years for releasing a group of mylar balloons.

When you release balloons that would harm the birds on a wildlife swamp, you’d feel bad about it at first, but then you’d have no more egrets.

But he didn’t know they were in the swamp: really, you had to crane to even see them.

Yes, according in Florida police, as of today. (Hasn’t been tried yet.) Violation of Florida Air and Water Pollution Control Act.

Third degree felony. Maximum five years in the clink.

Be very, very careful in Disneyland.

Also, you might fuck up a NASA launch, somehow. Or poke someone’s eye out.

ETA: Damn. Ninja’ed.