Really? I didn’t know Anna Torv wasn’t American until I listened to her on a talk show.
I don’t think Canadians should even count. I know a lot of Americans that have worse accents than most Canadians.
If you want to talk about bad accents, then you should mention Mel Gibson and Jean-Claude Van Damme in their early movies. For Arnold Schwarzenegger the accent is his trademark, so he probably isn’t even trying to fix it.
I tend to not count anyone whose first language isn’t English, like Schwarzenegger or Van Damme. It must be difficult acting in a language that’s not your first one, so getting the accent exactly right is probably not foremost on their mind. But I did recently see part of the first Lethal Weapon for the first time in a while, and you’re right, it’s surprising how Australian Mel Gibson sounds. (And before you say anything, yes, I know he was born in the U.S., but he moved to Australia as a kid.)
Jack Thompson is an Australian actor who has had a lot of small to medium roles in movies playing Americans. He’s also done some of the harder ‘southern’ accents, notably in Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil. I’d be interested to know what Americans thought of his accent(s).
The best American accent I’ve heard recently was from Zoe Boyle in Inspector Lewis: The Point of Vanishing. At first I swore I could hear that something was subtly off, but on listening to her carefully I couldn’t identify anything specific. And she looked like a typical rich American girl with her long, straight blond hair (her character was the daughter of the US SecDef or SecState, I forget which).
I was never totally convinced of Hugh Laurie’s accent in House. It seems to me that a grating vocalization like his is sometimes used to convey an American accent and to cover deviations from it.
I watched an episode of Miss Marple the other day where one of the American accents (the film producer) was so awful it sounded like the typical BBC radio play American accent (which are very poor). According to IMDB the actor is actually American, and a dialect coach. But it sounded so over the top!
I was born and grew up in Houston and sorry but the stereotypical Texas accent was almost non-existent aside from a handful. People usually don’t have a clue where I am from, they pick a random english speaking country like Canada or Australia.
I thought King Of The Hill did a very good job capturing what typical Texans sound like.
My mother is a Texan and has a pretty strong East Texas accent, but when my family was living in the Midwest she’d also often have people guess she was Australian. There was a local public figure who was Australian, and people would even specifically say my mother sounded like her.
Marsha Thomason, currently on White Collar (was on Lost and a number of other shows, but I have no idea if she played an American on those or not) is originally from Manchester, England. On White Collar she’s pretty good, but I can hear her slip up now and then. She had one episode where she went undercover as someone from England, so she spent a lot of time going back and forth between accents, even in the same scenes. Always wondered how difficult that was.
Matt Passmore from The Glades is Australian. I wish they’d just let him use his regular accent. On the show is American accent is always a bit off. There are just certain words that don’t sound right for a character supposedly from Chicago.
Dolph Lundgren’s American accent sounds technically pretty good to me, but he has a strange flat quality to his voice sometimes that isn’t quite natural.
I think Charmstr thinks they were “ludicrous” because they were badly done.
I read an interview with her in which she said she has been doing American accents for so long that she no longer can do her native accent. So you won’t be hearing it any more except in her old movies.