Sure. The reason my online persona is similar to my RL persona is that I don’t have a reason to do otherwise, not that I couldn’t. I would assume that most people with extensive RPG experience could do it easily if there were a sufficient reason.
I hope I do not upset anyone by saying this, but I just feel like things would be better if we all had a level playing field. Is it wrong for me to feel this way? I don’t think it’s necessarily someone’s fault if he or she is using a different online personality than he or she has in his or her real life. And I do not mean to disparage people who may feel differently. I think our government could do more to solve this problem with some thoughtful legislation. Maybe a new Department of the Internet would help. Again, if anyone disagrees with me, then I truly apologize. I can feel a different way if all of you think I should. It does take a village, after all.
ETA:
I did not mean to offend anyone by putting “he” before “she”. It may be taken as condescending if I do ladies first. Oh, it’s all just so confusing!
The results of the study were not that people couldn’t do it, it’s that they didn’t on facebook. Sure, I think it would be fairly trivial. Creating alter-egos online is pretty easy, I’ve done it myself when I’m bored and many people I know have done it (not on the sdmb). It’s much easier when the sock is significantly dumber than you are.
I love you, man.
I think it would be really difficult for me. I could pretend to have different hobbies, political views, etc., but my writing style is fairly idiosyncratic, and I think it would shine through.
I have, in the past, created and sustained online personas who are very different than I am in real life, complete with full backstories, made-up events, and a different voice. In several cases I was able to maintain the fiction for months at a time. I’m pretty sure I could do the same thing here.
I haven’t done it in years, though. In the first place it’s a hell of a lot of work. It’s also kind of a shitty thing to do in the long term because the other people you’re interacting with become attached to your lies. In a couple of cases I found myself having to engineer a graceful fictional exit from the forums in question because I started to worry about how involved other posters had become with my persona. I figured it was kinder to just fade away quietly than to hurt people by revealing my dishonesty.
These days I only post as myself. And, in fact, on most forums other than this one I post under my real name as well.
I’d like to think that I’d be smart enough to do it if I really wanted to, and paid close attention to how I wrote and what subjects I wrote about and what topics I was interested in.
But I can’t imagine wanting to do that for any length of time - too much work and not the way I like posting on message boards.
My posting style is so nondescript that I could sign up and act exactly the same and no one would notice.
As for creating another persona entirely, though, I have always known that when it comes to roleplaying, I blow goats. Phunk making up a backstory and trying to stick with it.
I don’t think the role playing analogy stands up to scrutiny.
RPGs are designed for people to roleplay; many have built in reward and/or penalty systems for good or bad roleplaying. Good roleplaying is usually over-the-top or at least very, very unrealistic.