Yeah, tell me about it!
It seems to me that many landlords–here, I’m thinking of the mom-and-pop variety–really don’t understand that they’re running a business, and that there are laws that need to be followed with regard thereto. And then they end up doing all kinds of stupid shit that’s in contravention of the law.
OR, they DO know the law, but they expect the tenants to be as ignorant as newborn baby seals. Hence, more stupid, illegal shit. And then they get offended when they discover that, oops, tenant knows the law.
Mind you, there are a great, great many tenants who (a) actually don’t know basic landlord-tenant law; (b) are too lazy/just don’t give a damn/whatever to find out what their rights and responsibilities (yes, responsibilities, too) are, and (c) don’t have the resources to hire the necessary advocates, or don’t know/get worn down enough to find out how to get advocates for those who don’t have the resources to hire their own. I think that many landlords are aware of this, and seeing an opportunity to make a quick, relatively fuss-free buck, take advantage wherever they can, even when they **do ** have good tenants. As you can imagine, this leads to many a landlord-tenant horror story, e.g., the OP.
It also occurs to me that “X” quantity of landlords hold low opinions of renters and are therefore less inclined to treat them as they, themselves, would like to be treated. Just my guess, though.
And yes, I’ve experienced my share of landlord-tenant mishegoss as a renter (yep, I’m one of the really good ones). Why do you ask?
This is me, grateful that (a) I work for a big, NYC law firm (full of attorneys who can refer me to other attorneys), and (b) have been, for many years, personally acquainted with attorneys who can either help me themsevles or refer me to others who can help me if I ever need it.