Best Song About Death and Dying

Tom Paxton’s “Jimmy Newman” about a Vietnam Solider

Get up Jimmy Newman, the morning has come
The engines are rumbling, the coffee’s all brewed
Get up Jimmy Newman, there’s work to be done
And why do you lie there still sleeping?

<snip>

It’s stateside for us, Jim, the folks may not know.
We’ll let it be such a surprise
They’ll loading us next, Jim, we’re ready to go
And why do you lie there still sleeping?

<snip>

A joke is a joke, but there’s nothing to gain
Jim, I’d slap you but I’m too weak to rise.
Get up, dammit Jimmy, you’re missing the plane
And you’d only to open your eyes.

Asleep by The Smiths:


Dont feel bad for me
I want you to know
Deep in the cell of my heart
I really want to go


What?!!? No mention of Don’t Fear the Reaper ? Heresy!

With the Grateful Dead mentions, you guys missed Black Peter, which never fails to choke me up. Especially this part:
*
Just want to have
a little peace to die
and a friend or two
I love at hand *

Stan Rogers The Watch

So here’s to useless superannuation
And us old relics of the days of steam.
In the morning, Lord, I would prefer
When men with torches come for her,
Let angels come for me.

Because no one has mentioned it- and someone has to - groan- no pitting please- Seasons in The Sun- Terry Jacks.

Psst…see post #11.

A pox on you for mentioning it again

Another fitting song about death and dying is Seasons in the Sun by Terry Jacks.

See post # 11

You know which one always got to me? **Seasons in the Sun ** by Terry Jacks. That poor little boy.
Oh, and to give this post some validity, **Streets of Heaven ** by Sherrie Austin.
And **Bang the Drum Slowly ** by Emmylou Harris.
The McGarrigle Hour album features Dig My Grave.

Go and dig my grave
Both long and narrow
Make my coffin
Neat and strong

It’s two two to my head
And it’s two two to my feet
It’s two two to carry me lord
Whenever I die

And the pre-finale of Les Miserables, with Jean Valjean, Fontine and Epinine:

Forgive me all my trespasses and take me to your glory/
To love another person is to see the face of God

Asie from some song with “Seasons” in the title by a guy (Jackson?) whose name I can’t remember, I love Leonard Cohen’s “Joan of Arc”

“And who are you?” she sterly spoke
To the one beneath the smoke.
“Why, I’m Fire” he replied
“And I love your solitude, I love your pride.”
“Then Fire, make your body cold.
I’m gonna give you mine to hold.”
Saying ths, she climbed inside
To be his one, to be his only bride.

From the death-haunted world of country music:

The Stanley Brothers, “Angel Band”:

Oh come, angel band
Come and around me stand
Oh bear me away on your snow-white wings
To my immortal home

… and about a hundred other Stanley Brothers songs. And a thousand other bluegrass songs.

“One Dyin’ and A Buryin’,” Roger Miller:

One dyin’ and a buryin’,
Some cryin’, six carryin’ me. I want to be free.

&
“Sing Me Back Home,” Merle Haggard
“He Stopped Loving Her Today,” George Jones
“I’ll Never Get Out of This World Alive,” Hank Williams

Trivia: the lyrics to all these songs were written by notable bearded poet Rod McKuen!

I agree with the sound, that of a pop-punk-meets-70s-semiprog, but I sort of disagree with the hollowness. Sure, each individual song on the album seems hollow, but each of them seems to be written from the perspective of a different person who died. So not each of them will fully explore the concept of death and dying, but overall, the album does.

Speaking of which: Country Death Song by the Violent Femmes.

It’s very over-the-top until the solo, but the solo and the last two verses are actually sort of powerful and sad.

Natalie Merchant’s version of “When They Ring The Golden Bells”.

I remembered another one, which was a war protest song by a really unlikely group: Requiem for the Masses by the Association.

Speaking of death and the Stanley Brothers, Ralph Stanley’s a cappella version of “O Death” on the O Brother Where Art Thou soundtrack is really haunting.

O, Death
O, Death
Won’t you spare me over til another year
Well what is this that I can’t see
With ice cold hands takin’ hold of me

Bruce Springsteen, Cadillac Ranch.

James Dean in that Mercury ‘49
Junior Johnson (?) through the woods of Carolin’
Even Burt Reynolds in that black Trans-Am
All gonna meet up at the Cadillac Ranch.

I think Paul Simon’s Quiet is absolutely lovely:

I’d also nominate The Weaskerthans’ Past Due, which is the third and final piece of a series that build to this contemplation of death. Great stuff. I’ve put in line breaks to mimic how it’s sung:

Mercy Seat - Nick Cave

He’s Walking Spanish down the hall - Tom Waits

Cemetary Polka - Tom Waits

Hey Joe - Jimi Hendrix

The I’m fixing to die Rag
“The worms crawl in
the worms crawl out
the worms play pinnchole on your snout”