Best Stephen King TV / Movie Adaptation? (Poll)

Yeah, but none of these were great. As a matter of fact, I often use Cujo as an example of a movie that was better than the book. Not because the movie was great, but because the book sucked.

I appreciated Running Man (1987) for what it was; I like Running Man (2025) for being more faithful.

Yeah, to each their own, but one could say similar about Curry’s iconic depiction of Dr. Frank N. Furter in TRHPS - just some guy hamming it up in drag. And yet, in a way, Curry’s depiction of Pennywise was almost a sequel or homage to Dr.F-- humor, irony, cosplay, and yes, downright menace, all wrapped up in a great performance.

Maybe I’m being overly sentimental since he just died, but I did do a rewatch of the ‘It’ miniseries not too long ago, and remember at the time thinking in general it held up well, and specifically liking Curry’s Pennywise performance.

Not to mention the book. Other than the Dark Tower series (like I said upthread, fantasy just ain’t my bag), I’ve read just about everything King has ever written, of which there’s been better and worse, but I think Dreamcatcher is the only one that made me outright think “this reeeally sucks”. It was like a much inferior writer trying to copycat King while adding a shit-ton (heh) of needless scatalogical details.

To be fair, I believe it was the first thing he wrote after getting hit by a van, and I think I read that King even said he was in a very bad place when he wrote it-- incapacitated, angry, bitter, mentally foggy and drugged-up with pain meds.

You remember incorrectly :smiley:

I think not, but I’m also very accustomed to liking things that most people don’t.

I liked the first part, it was successful at being creepy. Then the ending came and I was baffled. I guess if you read the book it made more sense.

I also liked Children of the Corn. That was one I watched a million times on cable

Now, will anyone defend Lawnmower Man?

This thread prompted me to have a look at the list of Stephen King adaptations on Wikipedia @gyrate posted and I found 3 recent ones I haven’t seen that I’ve now watchlisted. The Monkey and The Boogeyman are both on Hulu, and In the Tall Grass is available on Netflix. Of the 3 I’ve only read The Monkey. Looking forward to them all.

Even Stephen King himself won’t defend Lawnmower Man. In fact, he sued to have his name taken off the movie and the marketing materials because it bears literally zero resemblance to the story he actually wrote.

I don’t think it’s worth considering as an adaptation. Evidently, King didn’t think so either. Stephen King wins lawsuit

ETA: Ninja’ed

It did inspire a pretty good Rick and Morty episode, at least.

Are you offering these up as write-in candidates, or just casual mentions? I’ve taken to updating the write-in list in the mornings.

Oh, sorry. I already voted for my five, don’t want to skew the results. I was just defending CotC, which was mentioned above.

Doesn’t sound like there is much love for Lawnmower Man so probably not worth it.

OK, thanks for the follow up. It’s sometimes difficult to tell what’s meant as a write-in and what’s just a mention (not the this is the world’s most scientific poll or anything).

Oh, we get 5? OK, well I put in DT and HIA already, so I’ll fill out the other 3 with 11.22.63, Running Man (2025), and The Dead Zone.

Here is the updated write-in list:

  • The Dead Zone (1983 Movie): 7 votes
  • Maximum Overdrive (1986 Movie): 4 votes
  • Needful Things (1993 Movie): 3 votes
  • The Running Man (1987 Movie): 2 votes
  • The Langoliers (1995 Miniseries) 2 votes
  • 1408 (2007 Movie): 2 votes
  • 11.22.63 (2016 Miniseries): 2 votes
  • Doctor Sleep (2019 Movie): 2 votes
  • The Life of Chuck (2024 Movie): 2 votes
  • Salem’s Lot (1979 Miniseries): 1 vote
  • Creepshow (1982 Movie): 1 vote
  • Cujo (1983 Movie): 1 vote
  • Children of the Corn (1984 Movie): 1 vote
  • Firestarter (1984 Movie): 1 vote
  • Pet Sematary (1989 Movie): 1 vote
  • Hearts in Atlantis (2001 Movie): 1 vote
  • The Dark Tower (2017 Movie): 1 vote
  • Mr. Mercedes (2017 TV Series) 1 vote
  • The Outsider (2020 Miniseries): 1 vote
  • The Running Man (2025 Movie): 1 vote

Since it hasn’t been mentioned yet and actually wasn’t that bad, I’ll throw in 1922 released on Netflix in 2017.

No love for The Monkey (2025)?

I just saw it last night. I enjoyed it, but not enough to change any of my votes.

Kinda shocking just how many film adaptations he’s had, really. I like King, at least overall. But man, that’s a lot of films. Dude has got to be richer than God by now.

I know, right? And in maintaining the write-in list, it’s getting harder and harder to tell what’s an actual vote and what’s just a casual mention: “what about this King adaptation? Anyone like it?”.

I said I was trying my best to decide what’s an actual write-in, erring on the side of inclusivity. But looking at the poll tally, there’s only 8 write-in votes, and currently 37 votes in the write-in list I’m maintaining. Technically, that could work, since I said everyone can make 5 choices. If everyone who voted ‘write-in’ in the poll had 5 write-in votes, that’d be 8 x 5 = 45. But realistically, I know I’m letting too many casual mentions in the write-in list.

So from now on, I’m including in the write-in list going forward only those who specifically say “My write-in vote(s) is / are…”.

Maybe we can make it easier on @solost by clarifying our write-ins. Mine are:

  • The Dark Tower
  • Hearts in Atlantis
  • 11.22.63
  • The Dead Zone
  • The Running Man (2025)