** Blake **, you make some very good points for some alternative fuels. When one adds in vast solar, wind, geothermal infrustructures and reasonable doses of conservation in a world that is exponentially increasing its usage, it seems possible for great reductions in a couple of decades. It mystifies me a bit why you seem so cavalier regarding our using up most of the remaining oil.
I believe we are seeing a strong philosophical difference in place here. One world view believes in taking care of only their own, and if there is anything left over for some charity, fine. A pragmatic and efficient view, but one that I find short sighted and at the heart of the issue. Another worldview believes that civilization is only possible though sharing resources to the point of some self-sacrifice, and that many can provide much more together than a few can provide for themselves. And, as my OP stated, my concern has less to do with when peak oil will pass, or has passed, than with a current certainty of using up all reasonably and economically accessible deposits. I’m less concerned here with using up all the oil and more so with leaving sufficient amounts readily accessible for future use, especially in times of global crisis.
[QUOTE=Blake]
As I said, this is just the precautionary principle gone mad. We can imagine almost any possible scenario occurring on time scales of hundreds of thousands or even millions of years. Very few species actually manage to last that long so extinction is far more reasonable than something wiping out civilisation.
[/QuotE]
Dinosaurs in one form or another existed for 360 million years. Our scant 2 million or so has been a short passing of time, and since we can control our fate more so than any other species I don’t think that expecting homo-something-or-other existing for a few million more years is unreasonable. Complete extinction of humans is probably most likely by our own hand than by any natural forces as at this time we inhabit nearly all landmasses on the globe.
[QUOTE=Blake]
And this is the trouble with the precautionary principle. You can use it to justify or condemn anything at all. Trying to imagine the worst case scenario millions of years in advance is a futile exercise and not a way to decide how to invest our resources. It is as silly as trying to predict condition in 50 years time so you can invest in your unborn grandchildren’s college funds. You can’t accomplish anything that way. Instead you invest according to the likely short term future and move your resources as and when conditions change.
[/qUOTE]
A precautionary principle gone mad seems to me like it would likely stifle any activity. According to your scenario why invest anything on the unborn at all? How do you know they’ll be successfully birthed, or live past the age of one? Why plan for the future at all? What you suggest seems along the lines of eat, drink, and be merry for we may be gone tomorrow.
I don’t buy into this principle; I don’t think it is one that we see often, not for extended periods of time at least. Could you name a couple examples of it otherwise?
No, we don’t know what will happen 50 years from now. Does that prevent us from anticipating likely outcomes? People do make successful investments in their grandchildren’s education funds. Usually the primary course of doing so is very conservative, and low yield until later to be more diversely reinvested on better terms when the grandchild is ten years away from attending collage. And allowing for later changes, some kids do attend school at least in part on their grandparent’s assistance. Why should we not make investments in the lives of future generations?
[QUOTE=Blake]
Yes but it is even more reasonable to assume that a disease or meteor strike or something else will totally eliminate humanity on Erath within that time. By that argument we are remiss if we don’t; do everything in our power to advance technological and economic progress and get off this rock. And that includes maximally exploiting fossil fuels.
[/QUOTE]
Actually, I believe that other than some kerosene based fuels, I don’t believe that petroleum products are a needed major component of rocket fuel. I am all in favor of space exploration and moving beyond Earth. But even looking at the American and Russian space programs, there is no guarantee that it will happen soon or at all, or on a scale that is efficient. Hopefully, we may well be able to partake in many resources floating out in our solar system in the next couple centuries rather than relying on earth to provide them. But space flight will be very expensive in the near future; there are also political and technical difficulties in taking it to an industrial level at this time. The time frames of at least 50 years before doing so and going past the peak oil limit may be in conflict.
I don’t have a problem with maximizing some use of fossil fuels to technically solidify our position in the 21st century to where we are on solid footing to tackle the larger problem in the long run. However, we are not simply maximizing our position. We are wasting oil with often grossly inefficient engines that should be phased out. We are using too much oil in ways that you have demonstrated we need not for transportation, comfort, and industrial use. We leave engines running that could be turned off for periods of time. We could soon add another 10% to 20 % or so to non-fossilized energy usage, not even counting nuclear, with a widespread infrastructure alone.
Yes, conversions are expensive, time consuming, politically difficult, and inconvenient. But we are at this time the only generation or two that will ever be able to make this choice. Uncountable hundreds of billions of lives will be affected by our decisions over the next few years. Sure, total disaster may befall humankind someday, but do we want it to be on our watch? On the other hand, we may be able to make wise decisions that no other generation has had the privilege to make.
[QUOTE=Blake]
The only real question is why anyone else could possibly have any more right to it. This is a found resource. It will vanish eventually no matter who uses it or if no one ever uses it. It won’t last forever. The only choice is who uses it and to what end.
Really, it’s like asking why you think you have a right to a warm spot out of the wind. You have the right simply because no one else has any more right to it, but rest assured the wind will shift and the warm spot will vanish whether you use it r nobody does. Makes no real sense not to be warm in the meantime.
[/QUOTE]
Well that sunlight is a renewable source. I could find another warm spor if you are going to hog the one I want. Or the winds will change and it will return. Fossil fuels are finite. How do we determine in the short run that our ways of using it are the best? Regarding best use, the way we’ve seen modern technology improve by leaps and bounds, it’s not unlikely that far more efficient uses of these fuels may be only decades away. But if it’s unfeasible to get them out of the ground it will be a moot point.
I understand that even my own point regarding the possibility of humankind existing over the course of a million years suggests that at some someone may well use up all the fossil fuels. However, does that negate our own responsibility in trying to greatly reduce our usage? Does that negate our trying to finding ways to teach our immediate descendents to bolster this plan and to improve on our initial attempts?
Civilization has, despite our faltering steps, grown into a globally interconnected world that is in general better educated. Despite ignorance and crushing poverty in some places, standards of living have improved over those of our ancestors a few hundred years before. We slowly advance to greater sophistication, leaving some of the past’s misery behind. A multi generational attempt to minimize fossil fuel use might provide us one fulcrum that could help lift our civilization into it’s most forward thinking, mature level yet. It’s a global concern we could all share, and one that requires our first attempts as sentient beings at trying to install millennia-long attitudes and practices.