[QUOTE=Pjen]
A lot of people seem quick to blame here. Most modern cars are ‘fly by wire’ - basic functions are electronically controlled by the central computer. If this goes haywire, many systems can screw up at once.
What inputs was the computer willing to accept- would it accept turning off the ignition. If the clutch was disengaged or neutral was selected, did the engine then sound like it was going to blow.
Maybe it would be a good idea to wait for an engineer’s report before engaging in baseless blaming.
[/QUOTE]
Geez watch 2001 or Colossus recently?
OK first off I would say some not most. But that is picking nits. I teach on fly by wire cars and have since they were introduced. The BMW in question is a 1998. IANABMWE (not a BMW expert) but the 318 is BMW’s bottom of the line entry level car. I very seriously doubt that a 98 3 series would have fly by wire. A 5 or 7 series sure, but a 318? Not till several years later.
But what if it did? The base functions are not controlled by the computer, but rather the higher functions such as fuel control for emissions and power, cruise control, ABS. The base functions such as supplying power to the system, shifting, and applying the brakes are still strictly a manual operation. In particular the ignition key is a mechanical switch that supply electrical power to the various systems in the car. The “computer” does not control the ignition switch, but the ignition switch controls the computer. So it is not up to the computer to accept the ignition key being turned off, the computer does not have any choice in the matter. Saying that the car’s computer would not accept a key command is like saying my desktop computer started sending spam, I could not pull out the power cord from the wall because it would not let me. Riiiiiggggghhhhttttt. Also see the last paragraph of this post for what the real experts said.
Casdave Using the links your provided we can get a pretty good picture of what happened
I think we can all agree that this guy panicked. I think we can all agree that panic is not the best way to deal with an emergency.
I think if we read his quotes we can get an idea of why he didn’t do the actions that have been suggested here. ( I mean other than the fact he was crying like a little girl, which is probably the main reason he did not do what he should have)
Kill the key OK we are left with two versions of why he didn’t kill the key
OK not everyone is an automotive expert and he might not have realized that you can turn the engine off without locking the steering, but then the story changes
Anybody else notice a change between these two quotes? Sounds like somebody is trying to cover their ass here.
Use the brakes stupid Now if you read carefully you can find out the root cause of this guy being unable to stop
I think I see the problem. He did not apply the brakes hard enough. Look if you are trying to overcome the inertia of your car + 138 Horsepower you car going to have push for all that you are worth on that brake pedal. It will not be easy, but it can be done. The brakes (Particularly BMW brakes) are plenty powerful enough The telling phrase is keep my speed down to. If he had jammed the brakes all the way he would have continued to slow down, not just maintained speed. For you American dopers, did you see the comments in the news reports about MOT? In England cars have to have a complete inspection every year, so it is not like the states where you can drive a beater for years and years with nobody looking at it. I think the default assumption should be that the brakes were in serviceable condition.
Shift to neutral This is where this guy shows up as an true moron
'Scuse me, but WTF? Gears jammed on an automatic? Unable to shift? Somebody must have slipped up to this idiot and whispered into his ear that what he was saying was impossible, because the story then becomes
All right :wally pick one story and stick to the damn thing. Don’t keep changing stories at the same rate I change my socks and expect me to believe you.
On and in case you missed it, from the experts at BMW
IMNSHO there was a throttle return spring failure and the throttle went to the floor. He stepped on the brakes, but not hard enough to stop the car. the brakes started to overheat and he panicked. Once he got into panic mode, he was pretty much worthless. Then he crashed.