Can Democrats actually stop the nomination of Brett Kavanaugh?

NM…just saw Thing Fish’s reply. I guess my own high school experiences are so far out, or I was in such an out crowd that I might as well have been going to HS on a different planet.

I would have thought it was less surprising for a conservative. Aren’t conservatives all adherents to the Just World fallacy: She thought if she did the right thing (don’t drink the “punch”) she could avoid the fate of those other girls, who clearly deserved what they were getting?

Why can’t conservatives be consistent in their opinions? If you believe in the just world fallacy in one case, believe in it in all cases. Have some character.

So: do you think that the standard of evidence required to reach a finding of fault in a civil trial should be the same standard used to judge someone’s fitness for a lifetime appointment to a position of extraordinary public trust?

You think formal invites went out, like to a wedding? Maybe you’re overthinking things.

For someone who insists on facts, you sure seem to be making claims not in the victim’s statement.

Yeah, I attended a lot of college parties when I was in high school, though as far as I know nobody ever got raped there. These aren’t the kind of parties you get “invited” to, you just show up and pay your five bucks. If you know where the party is, you must be cool enough.

In my own experience high school kids weren’t usually invited or given an option to attend drunken college parties. Nor did college women, in my own experience, notice high school boys enough to recognize them, let alone recall them standing in a rape line 37 years later. But, as I said, this is obviously beyond my own high school experience.

Which didn’t include things like formal invites, btw. Not sure where you went to high school, but mine certainly didn’t so stuff like that either. :stuck_out_tongue:

3 years ahead of him, so when she was a College junior, he would have been a senior. Not exactly two cohorts who socialize a lot. And a High School boy is attending college parties (ok fine reasonable) where he is taking the lead in organizing gang rape “trains”. Multiple times. And no one, including college students who were much older than him and under whom he had no power never reported this ever, to the police or even did a man these High Schoolers are rather rapey, lets not invite them?

I mean its possible…

Provide the cite where the victim claims he “led” or “organized” the rapes (or stop claiming it).

Ford released her polygraph

Christine Blasey Ford Polygraph Regarding Kavanaugh Assault Allegation Released | HuffPost Latest News

That is not exactly my point. I would think that a woman would not want to go to parties where gang rape was on the entertainment whether the other guests were three years older or three years younger.

According to her affidavit, it was at least ten parties over two years.

A dark place, where drunken lechers display the darkest sides of their bestial natures and demean and attack women. And it took her two years to decide that it was a place where she shouldn’t be.

Hmmm.

Regards,
Shodan

It’s possible Kavanaugh and Judge did something to stand out. Like get belligerently drunk and start groping and grinding on women. Do that enough times and people will start to recognize you.

Probably why I wasn’t noticed a lot by college girls when I was in high school. Plus the whole not speaking very good english thingy. I was doomed.

On the bright side, I could get through the USSC process without any accusations or rape, so there is that.

Rape culture is powerful and insidious and can even alter the decisions for the worse of intelligent boys and girls. If you had to go to these parties to be cool, then the kids who really want to be cool are going to go to these parties, even if they might be dangerous.

Aren’t polygraph tests basically psudoscience at this point?

You and me both. I was in high school at the same time and would be shocked to find out my classmates were attending parties like this one with gang bangs happening. Doesn’t mean it didn’t happen but jeez, I would expect word of something like this would get around pretty fast.

So far the only thing I’ve seen corroborating anything like this happening is the statement from Judge’s ex-girlfriend. If these parties were going on finding others who knew about them shouldn’t be too difficult. Getting them to admit publicly they were in attendance on the other hand is likely to be tricky.

So because she used bad judgement as a teenager rape lines were okay?

Hmmm.

It adds details to the story I did not know about (forget whether they are truthful or not):

Party was attended by “four boys and a couple of girls”.

Ford met Kavanaugh before at parties and briefly dated a friend of Kavanaugh prior to this incident.

Re: polygraphs in general. They determine whether Ford believes the statements are true or not. This polygraph indicates she does.

That statement from Judge’s ex-girlfriend (basically that he stood in line to have sex with a drunk girl) is so on-the-nose that it’s actually a little worrying. I hope Swetnick can provide evidence that she told people about this prior to the statement coming out, or that other witnesses come forward.

On the other hand, if the ex-girlfriend’s statement and Swetnick’s statement are independent, then that’s a hugely damning piece of evidence.

This may be why they’re so desperate to ram through this confirmation as quickly as possible:
Orrin Hatch, the Supreme Court, and Trump's Pardons - The Atlantic

Of the dual-sovereignty doctrine is endes states couldn’t retry the same crime at the state level so states couldn’t retry persons pardined at the federal level.