[QUOTE=Shagnasty]
Actually the DJ that did my wedding was probably the best I have ever seen for that purpose. We picked the music and there was no chicken dance or any of that. What made him good was that he did some mixing also at appropriate points that sounded great, cool, and sometimes funny.
He also served as a great MC which I think is another skill good DJs need to have. A bad DJ will just mumble to everyone to get out on the dance floor every once in a while. A good one can control the crowd just through music and showmanship.
[/QUOTE]
Well, for a wedding DJ mic-work replaces beatmatching in terms of the most difficult part of the job (for a lot of people, anyway).
I’ve also DJ’d for years, and I figured I’d chime in with some of my experience.
Hip-Hop is much more difficultto beatmatch than techno, IMHO. Most hip-hop records/CDs don’t have any extra beats, which leaves very little room for error when you’re trying to mix two songs together. In addition it always seemed to me that it was a lot more noticeable when I was slightly off on my timing because of the broken up beats they use (as compared to techno’s dum-dum-dum-dum style).
A bad DJ at a club is noticeable to everyone; the difference between a mediocre and a great DJ is really hard to notice unless you are yourself a DJ or know what they’re supposed to be doing*. A great DJ will create an atmosphere with his music choices (called a “set”) and will keep a vibe going that will effectively make him the pied piper of the dancefloor, whereas a mediocre DJ is just up there playing music and is forced to rely on the inherent quality of the music for dancers to be having a good time.
As a DJ, everyone assumes I always had tons of wild, crazy sex in the booth; this was never the case. To be honest, having girls in the booth was extremely distracting and as much as I hated to do it I usually asked them to come back at the end of the night, or leave me with their number. When I was DJing I’d have to focus on reading the vibe on the floor in order to make a decision as to what song I should play next, and having a girl grabbing my crotch was waaaay too distracting.
While beatmatching is a big part of DJing, having technical skill does not make a good DJ. DJing is about 75% playing the right song at the right time (i.e. reading the crowd), and 25% technical skill.
Lastly, after having DJ’d hip-hop, various kinds of techno, and retro-dance nights, I found that the retro nights were by far and away the most fun and resulted in the best crowd response. Maybe I just have a knack for retro, though… TMMV 