…in the Afghanistan threads after America pulled out, there was an idea that prevailed that essentially it was the right thing to do, because things were always going to go back to the way things were, because that’s just who they are.
I disagreed with that premise back then. And I still disagree with it now.
But I can’t help but look at the United States of America and when I look at the question “Can SDMB create a better form of government?” the answer is obviously “yes”, but would that ever be something that America would even consider, or be doable?
And the answer, short of a revolution, is no.
Because, and I hate to say it, this is just who you are.
The problems here are foundational. America is built on the premise of white supremacy. And it permeates every level of society. The justice system. Housing. Prisons. Policing. Financial institutions. The government.
And one of the other things about America, one that hardly ever gets talked about because people prefer to believe the fiction over the reality, is how fundamentally corrupt American society is.
I remember when I used to play Sid Meier’s Civilisation, which was a fantastic game, but this was how it described democracy:
And I think back to how I just kinda accepted that premise, as I think that we all did, and that’s why “American Democracy is good” and “socialism [nee communism] is bad”.
America is probably one of the most corrupt nations on the planet. It exist on every level, from the government to the police forces to the industrial prison complex to the stock market to the gig economy.
I bring this up all the time here but it boggles my mind that America incarcerates more people per capita than anywhere else in the world, and if we were to release half of everyone locked up in America right now it would still have over twice as many people (per capita) that are currently locked up in Australia.
Twice as many.
And nobody really cares. You so much as mention something like “bail reform” and you get called a “dirty socialist” and they drum you out of office. America will never make a dent in the prison populations. Not in my lifetime. Not for generations. Not short of a revolution.
Because America, fundamentally, is racist and corrupt. And too many people with power are making money out of the prison industrial complex and the people have been conditioned to think that this is entirely normal.
So can America ever create a government that works well?
Short of a revolution, no.
America is too fragmented: by State, by County, heck, even by School Zone. There are 17,985 police agencies in the United States. In contrast, the UK only have 43, ultimately answerable to the Home Office. But in the United States? They are effectively a law unto themselves. The LAPD literally has their own gangs. The NYPD is out of control. And this year you’ve given billions more dollars than you ever have given them before. Billions. America is a country of mini-empires, from the highest tiers of government to the local home-owners association.
You actually have a government that “works well” in this environment. That’s what you have. It works well enough to keep the lights on (most of the time), that keeps the trains moving (by forbidding the workers from going on strike).
The government is perfectly suited to maintaining the status quo.
So what is a “better government?”
I think a core principal needs to be the independence of the people and organizations that control and run the elections. That would need to be the starting point.
But I can’t, short of a revolution, see how this could conceivably happen. There is no pathway to this. You wouldn’t even get beyond the debate on whether this should be lead by the Federal government or lead by the States.