Late to the discussion here. I have owned a 78 Rabbit, 81 Rabbit, 84 Jetta and 96 Jetta, all purchased new. As God is my witness, I will never buy another Volkswagen again! At least unless I could be assured that it was built in Germany.
Every car was plagued by electrical problems of one sort or another.
78 Rabbit (built in Germany). Water leaked in along the antenna cable and shorted out the electrical system, but was covered in a recall so no harm done. Totalled in an accident at about 40K, so no extended data.
81 Rabbit (built in Westmoreland PA?) I would drive and parts would fall out behind the dash onto the carpet. Parts inside the sunroof good loose and would rattle annoyingly. Intermittent electrical problems. Traded in at about 60K.
84 Jetta (built in Germany). Intermittent electrical problems (expensive to fix each time). Actually not that bad a car, and I kept it for 12 years and 200K.
96 Jetta (built in Mexico?). I wanted to get rid of this car a year after I bought it. My first automatic transmission, and it would get stuck in a lower gear. I’d have to pull off to the side of the road, turn off the engine and back on. The axle failed just over warranty but before aftermarket parts were available so I paid full price to have it fixed. Something about a defective boot design, so it was bound to happen again. I had to have the entire electrical system replaced.
I was thinking about trading it in (at 100K), and debated over another VW, but decided on Japanese instead. Then a couple I know bought a 2001 VW Jetta and couldn’t praise it enough. I agonized anew, but finally decided to go with a Toyota or Nissan.
I traded in toward a 2002 Nissan Altima, the first year that they were produced. Common wisdom says that that is not the wisest thing to do. Almost 100K, and right now the worst that has happened is that a blown headlight bulb also shorted out a fuse.
It turned out to be a good move. That couple had to deal with the faulty ignition coil FUBAR, and had the car in the shop four times as each ignition coil failed.
The VWs were a blast to drive, there is no question. The Nissan steering seems to be aimed at what they think the American public wants. But, I’ll still trade that for reliability anyday.