[QUOTE=robby]
A destroyer that “drops a depth charge” on a submarine tracking it is quite likely to find himself on the bottom in short order.
First off, a single depth charge is unlikely to hurt a submarine, unless you get a lucky hit. Even in WWII, it took many, many salvos of depth charges to take out a submarine.
[/quote]
From the Wikipedia article on depth charges:
Although the explosions of the standard 600-pound depth charge used in World War II were nerve-wracking to the target, an undamaged U-boat’s pressure hull would not rupture unless the charge detonated closer than about five meters. Placing the weapon within this range was entirely a matter of chance and quite unlikely as the target maneuvered evasively during the attack. Most U-boats sunk by depth charges were destroyed by damage accumulated from a long barrage rather than by a single carefully-aimed attack. Many survived hundreds of depth charge detonations over a period of many hours; U-427 survived 678 depth charge blasts aimed at her in April, 1945, though many (if not all!) of these may have actually detonated nowhere near the target.
[QUOTE=robby]
Any modern submarine knows exactly where all surface ships in its vicinity are, and has firing point solutions on every contact it is tracking. You do this to keep your crew well-trained, and as a matter of practice.
The instant a sub found itself under attack, it would respond instantly, and with deadly force. And frankly, in a one-on-one contest between a surface ship that thinks it knows where a sub is, and sub that knows exactly where a surface ship is, the advantage is with the sub. Not to mention that depth charges are much less effective than modern homing torpedoes.
[/QUOTE]
Although modern ASW frigates (and most other non-capital combat craft) use Nixie decoys to act as countermeasures against a torpedo attack, robby is correct that the advantage goes to the sub. The submarine can change depth (shifting below a thermocline or saline layer that makes surface sonar essentially useless) or can hide in littoral shallows (although such a move is risky if detected), whereas the surface vessel is just stuck out in the big wide open. In other words, the sub has 3D mobility and the capability of hiding in the shadows, while the can is standing out there in the middle of the street like John Wayne.
And I don’t believe that US Navy ships, nor any other modern navy, carries conventional depth charges, or at least not for offensive use. USN ASW-equipped vessels will have either ASROC batteries or SVTTs (surface vessel torpedo tubes), plus often one or more Sea King helicopters equipped with dipping sonar and armed with a Mark 46 torpedo. In any case, dropping charges or firing torpedos casually is going to cause a major international incident, not to mention show up on the ship’s activity report with a big question mark. “So, Captain Queeg; why did you launch fifty million dollars of torpedos without provocation or orders at a nonaggressive target?”
In the case that the commander of a surface ship group was unhappy about a trailing sub, his best bet is to pound it with active sonar. After a few hours of steady pinging on the hull of the sub, even the most ardent pursuit is going to be somewhat dimmed.
Stranger