Classic, era-defining HIT songs that weren't such big hits

Hey, ***I ***remember “New World Man.” “Subdivisions” also got some AOR play in my neck of the woods.

In the US, the Who’s “My Generation” peaked at #74. They didn’t manage to put a record in the US Top 40 until “Happy Jack”, which entered the charts in May 1967 and peaked at #24. Their only Top 10 hit was “I Can See For Miles” (#9).

All those Devo songs were in rotation in the early days of MTV, too.

Emerson Lake and Palmer were a giant influence on Progressive Rock. “From the Beginning” is a classic rock mainstay, but only got to #39.

“I’ve Seen All Good People” by Yes only got to #40.

Paul Stookey’s “The Wedding Song (There is Love)” only reached #24, but became a mainstay at weddings.

KROQ-FM’s format was Modern Rock so it’s not surprising the song was popular on the station. However, Modern Rock made up just one part of a pop music audience that was getting increasingly Balkanized. When “I Melt With You” first came out, it got a lot of airplay on KROQ and other Modern Rock stations but very little on Top 40, (most) AOR stations, and none at all on any Country or R&B/Urban stations. Likewise, the influential Grandmaster Flash rap song “The Message” (which got to #62 on the Hot 100 chart) probably wasn’t heard that much on Modern Rock stations like KROQ.