I’ve been living in Columbus for 12 years now. This town was a pretty good place for me to be for a while, but I’m ready to try living somewhere else.
Columbus doesn’t really feel all that generic if you’re in the Clintonville, German Village, Victorian Village, or campus areas. Outside that region–like, in the suburbs–Hyperelastic is right. It’s pretty sterile and bland. There are cool things hiding out there, but you have to really hunt for them.
There is a relatively low cost of living here, which is nice. If you’re not supporting anyone but yourself on what you earn as a TA or RA, and you’re in decent health, you can cover your basic expenses with your monthly pay.
If you are planning on supporting yourself with a TA, you might want to keep this in mind–OSU’s TAs and RAs aren’t yet unionized. This means you can be worked an awful lot of hours, you have almost no job security, there’s no transparency in hiring, and the pay you’d receive is much less than it is at a lot of places with grad student unions. The health coverage we get is improving, but it’s still not as good as the deal grad students get at, say, Michigan. We’re working on forming a union now, and, hopefully, we’ll have one by June. But no guarantees.
Something else you might want to keep in mind–if you’re a TA or RA at OSU, and you’re starting in Fall Quarter, you won’t get your first paycheck until the end of October. That means that living expenses for October have to come out of whatever savings or other job you might have. I ran some of the TA orientation sessions a couple of years ago, and I was suprised at the number of people who thought they’d be getting a paycheck at the end of September.
The weather is beautiful from about mid-September through October. Spring and early summer aren’t bad, either. Other than that, the climate in central Ohio leaves much to be desired. Summers (from mid-June until mid-September) are hot, muggy, and mosquito-filled. Winters (from November until at least mid-March, sometimes later) are cold and wet, with the kind of damp chill that goes straight to the bone.
Despite the lousy weather, there are some neat things to do. You’re near the Hocking Hills, which are beautiful year-round, and there are bluegrass festivals and the Ohio State Fair in summer. (I live in the northeast campus area. No, it’s not as nice as Clintonville or Victorian Village, but I get a great deal on my rent.) For more info on things you might want to check out, see TellMeI’mNotCrazy’s thread about Columbus.
I agree with other posters who say that you really have to have a car to live here. That’s very true. There is a bus system (called COTA–Central Ohio Transit Authority), but outside of the downtown and OSU areas it’s pretty lousy. Even downtown, you can spend quite a while waiting for a bus. (Here’s a joke I heard recently about COTA: Question: How do you say “COTA bus” in German? Answer: Der Nevercomin.)
Really, how happy or unhappy you are in Columbus will have much more to do with how much you like your department than anything else. As a grad student, your life will be dominated by your schoolwork and teaching. If you can make friends with other people in your department, you’ll find a way to be happy.