Commonwealth vs. State

As to West Virginia, from this recent General Questions thread:

As to states being “readmitted to the Union”: The Union government’s position was that the attempted secession of the Southern states was simply an illegal act of insurrection; according to the post-war Supreme Court decision Texas v. White, secession (legally speaking) never took place. States were not “readmitted to the Union”, rather they were (in the eyes of the federal government) “readmitted to representation in Congress”.