I know excatly what you mean! I do the same thing and my husband used to give me weird looks. He’s used to that quirk now. I also “chew” smoothies and shakes.
I smoosh and swirl it around my mouth with my tongue.
I have to add that your user name qualifies this as a highly rated user name to thread title combo.
*Did you chew your cell phone before you swallowed it?
Sort of. It feels like I’m miming chewing or pretend eating. I feel like this dog who’s “air swimming”.
Mostly it’s like going through the motion while I mash the food around my mouth. My jaw goes up and down, but I’m mostly just pushing the pudding or applesauce around until my brain is satisfied that it is actually mooshy after all.