[quote=“1920s Style “Death Ray”, post:32, topic:464357”]
I’m not quite sure what you’re getting at with this. When I say I can download sounds, I mean the raw notes and data required to play my 88 key digital piano (a physical instrument) with whatever sounds I desire. I play it just like a piano, it feels like a piano under my hands and sounds like a piano if I want it to, but it can also sound like various different settings on a hammond organ or anything else people have developed sounds for. The Roland organ module connects to the keyboard and allows you to have control over the organ sounds using draw bars etc. There is really no difference between doing this and using a dedicated electric organ other than that the dedicated organ will have more versatility in organ sounds.
[/QUOTE]
I didn’t quite understand this from what you were saying. My electric piano is 7 years old, and though it is a Roland “real electric piano” - not just a keyboard - with about 8 different piano sounds, and a small assortment of others (harpsichord, bass, chimes, etc.), it was the basic model of a full 88-key electric piano, including a reasonable facsimile of key response to speed and pressure of the fingers (“attack”). It’s not a toy, but if it has the capacity to receive added sounds, I don’t know it. It does have a small readable/rewritable memory, (to record, say a single song or score) but that’s it.
Because you’re an organist, or playing organ music?
For someone who is, or has been, an organist, and who actively uses a pedal clavier when available, there is absolutely no substitute for having three (or more) sets of keys, one of which is underfoot. (Yes, you can split my keyboard between two sounds, and thereby emulate two manuals, sort of, but that’s limited in the combinations you can choose, and amounts to the equivalent of being able to use your right hand and your foot - IOW, treble and bass lines.)
I don’t feel like I’m producing organ sounds - and certainly not playing as those who know my playing know it, if I’m not using three “manuals” (one with my foot - or feet). And being unable to play with both hands within - or very close to - the same register (i.e., as if both in the treble clef or bass clef) when that’s what I want, is a frustration, to say the least.
I think we’ve had this discussion before.
At least there’s somebody that spoke up in a discussion about pianos - acoustic vs. electric - to assert that an electric isn’t, and can’t be, a real substitute for a “real” piano with soundboard. It was at least a year ago, likely two (or more), when (IIRC) a poster asked for advice about buying a keyboard for someone who’d expressed the desire to learn to play the piano. Even with the best possible speakers, etc., there ain’t no substitute for how the harp and soundboard pick up vibrations from all the other strings (and probably there are other factors, but that’s the part I’m sure about). So yes, of course I have a musician’s ear.
But I guess I’m just more organist than pianist. :sigh: