Elvis Costello memoir out

Oh, and minor sidenote from a guitar geek standpoint: Elvis is a gearhead and likes his vintage gear. I have seen him pull out a '52 Tele, a few nice Gibson archtops and other pricey guitars, played through a variety of vintage Fender tweed amps. But he doesn’t mention his gear much - refers to a 1935 Martin 000-28 (a six figure guitar) and a Gibson Century of Progress guitar ('30’s, with a celluloid/bakelite fingerboard - kitchy charming, but the ones I have played I haven’t liked at all).

Why am I sharing this? I dunno; because I am a guitar geek. But for being such a gear head, I would’ve expected him to discuss them a bit more. Especially if he was playing much with T-Bone Burnett, a gear nut if there ever was.

Carry on.

There is a review of the Elvis-read audio version in the NYTimes this week.

Ouch - the opening line:

[QUOTE=NYTimes writer John Williams]
“Life takes much longer then the average pop song.” Elvis Costello writes in his uneven and bloated autobiography, in which life takes much, much longer.
[/QUOTE]

and, in describing how Elvis frames his upbringing with a bit of a Dickensian feel:

Pretty direct for the NYTimes. I did find the book underwhelmed me given the writer at work and the life being described, but this review is harsh.

WordMan, does he at least touch on his work with the Pogues? Given the fact that he married their bass player, I’m assuming that’s at least one of the spans of his life he covers…

I think he mentions Cait maybe 1 - 2 times by name and in a few stories. Seems to walk right past her.

Well, c’mon now - let’s be fair. They were only married for sixteen years. It’s not like he would have had time to really get to know her ;).

I’m quite a big fan of EC, but I think I might take a flyer on this one. A near 700 page autobiography has the threat to be a little ponderous and precious to begin with. But in addition it appears he focuses least upon some of the things I am more interested in.

Wow. As Tamerlane mentions, seems like a bit of a slight given how long they were together, but I get that this is not a standard, in-sequence, “story of my life” type autobiography. I would love a few Shane anecdotes, though.

I’ve enjoyed a couple of rock-and-roll memoirs–Keef, Pete–and I am interested in Patti’s and this one. So, bottom line, now that you’ve reflected on it and read the Times’ review, is it worth a read?

Keef’s is one of the best I have ever read - the stories, the voice, the music insights

Patti’s was incredibly well-written and weaves in her relationships with Mapplethorpe, Shepard and so many others with tenderness. I am not a fan but really enjoyed and respected the book. Haven’t read M Train.

Pete’s was a great, thoughtful read, but unfortunately confirmed that he is a complex, and slightly skeevy guy - that is at the heart of his creative genius. I am not commenting on the online issues he had - I mean his general voice/persona.

Honestly, Elvis’s book is a tier below these. Dylan’s Chronicles is SO MUCH BETTER. I would strongly recommend Andy Summers’ One Train Later, and Al Kooper’s Backstage Passes and Backstabbing Bastards first.

Heck, to be clear: Rod Stewart’s book is about an inch deep, but he is an incredibly charming storyteller with many, many stories to tell. I’d put it in front of Elvis’.

In terms of books I am targeting:

  • Maybe M Train by Patti Smith
  • Chrissie Hynde’s Reckless
  • Carrie Brownstein’s Hunger Makes Me a Modern Girl
  • just bought Sam Phillips: The Man Who Invented Rock and Roll. If you have read any of Peter Guralnick’s other books - his books on Elvis are some of the best ever - then this choice was easy. I still need to read his book on Sam Cooke.

Does that help?

It does. Thanks, WordMan…

It’s pretty popular in both of the libraries I use. The hold dates stretch out into February. (10 copies in one library, 3 in the other.)

Also just heard about Sound Man by legendary there-for-everything producer and engineer Glyn Johns: Amazon.com

Good god, that was a tough slog. Really wouldn’t recommend it to anyone who isn’t HUGELY into parsing Elvis’s lyrics, and dying to hunt down obscure influences and references. With an emphasis on obscure!

Full disclosure - I have/had all of his albums through Goodbye Cruel World, and none after. His work and my tastes parted after that. Which is not to take ANYTHING away from an artist who chooses to expand and explore, rather than repeating the same formula. But I wasn’t particularly interested in his work with Burt Bacharach, the Brodsky Quartet, etc. The book has tons of material regarding his work after I stopped being a big fan. So while I found that interesting, I think the lack of a clear structure made it less interesting than it otherwise would be.

Heck it is tough to really figure out for sure how many times he’s been married, and how many kids he has (3 each, I believe). So you have to be content to just sorta absorb it to give a sense of his life, rather than a specific chronology.

Re: Cait - I think there is a place in the 600s where he refers to her somewhat more regularly over the course of 10 pages. Said she looked good wearing a bass. I think he previously said they were not married, but by this point I was frustrated enough at the obscure style that I skimmed a lot.

Spends a TON of time talking about his dad and his grandparents. Even if I would have been interested in that, the convoluted and obpaque writing put me off. He seems to wish to “namedrop” many MANY writers, musicians, and songs I had never heard of before, as influences on him, or his dad and grandpa. Could be useful if you wished to try to track them all down, but my mind glazed over somewhere around pages 2-300.

Like I said, back in the 70s-early 80s I was a BIG fan of Stiff, Dave Edmunds, Nick Lowe, Brinsley Schwaz, Ducks Deluxe, the Clash, Graham Parker, Jonathon Richman… My roommate and I were in a band playing that sort of music, bought albums the day they came out, and we’d pore over the albums late into the night. Fuck, my crazy roommate even organized our several thousand discs - not by alphabet, but by who produced/played with/and influenced who. Hell, saw Elvis and T-Bone play in a gym during the solo tour he mentions in (I think) a single sentence. But I found even that part of the book frustrating, uninformative, and unenlightening.

Many experiences/relationships are presented as isolated vignettes: all of a sudden there will be 5 pages about eating meeting David Bowie, with nothing before or after to put it into context.

The only mention I saw was to something like “some idiot named Eric” during early Stiff days.

He gives a lot of time/credit to the Attractions. So I learned more about Steve Nieve and the Thomas brothers than I knew before. But I could have found a lot of that out without wading through this.

I was really, really disappointed. If I didn’t consider myself such a fan, no way I would have finished it. Impressed me as very self indulgent.

And here it is, February.

I’m halfway through, and, yes, completely disorganized. Many mentions of people, places, events, and songs that have no context surrounding them at all. I may not finish it.

One thing I would have liked: captions on the photos.

This book needed a strong editor.