[QUOTE=A.R. Cane]
OK, fair enough. Now since most posters can’t see this as purely hypothetical, let me
try to pose a reasonable scenario.
Suppose we use an ultra light airplane w/ an engine capable of about 40 HP. Assume
that, with a fixed pitch prop, the engine is capable of moving the plane across the
ground at about 75 MPH. Further assume that the takeoff speed is around 40 MPH…
[/QUOTE]
A. R. Cane, you seem to be one of the few people on here who really doesn’t get it.
There are two interpretations of the scenario. One is that the belt moves backwards to match the aircraft’s forward speed, this is the interpretation you seem to have taken. The answer to the problem interpreted this way is very simple. The aircraft’s engine applies a force to the air which is not connected to the belt. The belt applies minimal force to the aircraft. Therefore the aircraft moves forwards and takes off as usual.
There are two faults in your scenario. First, it is airspeed that is limiting to an aircraft not groundspeed, moving the belt backwards does not limit the aircraft from moving forwards. Second, although an aircraft would move with a conveyor belt if you moved the belt gently, it doesn’t take much force to get the aircraft moving, and indeed, if you tried moving the conveyor belt suddenly, the aircraft would not move with it.
In your scenario with an ultra-light capable of moving at 75mph. The belt will wind up to its max speed of 75 mph. The ultra light applies enough power to stay stationary. At this time, the aircraft is stationary relative to the ground, stationary relative to the air, and moving at 75 mph relative to the belt. You are saying that 75 mph is as fast as the plane can go so it won’t take-off. However, the plane is limited by airspeed not ground speed. At this time the airspeed is 0, therefore there is plenty of excess power available to move the aircraft forwards up to 40 mph airspeed at which time it takes off. It also happens to be moving at 115 mph relative to the belt but that is not relevant.
The other interpretation basically allows the belt to move as fast as necessary to prevent the aircraft from moving. It would seem that a constantly accelerating conveyor belt does apply a force to the aircraft, and that there is an acceleration value that could keep the aircraft stationary.
Evil Captor, twin engine propellor driven aircraft gain no significant lift from the prop slipstream over their wings. If they did, then they wouldn’t need much runway to take-off, and running the engines up to full power with the brake set would make the aircraft light on the ground. It doesn’t, to any significant degree.