[QUOTE=JBHarrisonIX]
This is where I’m getting the problem. I do not understand how the plane gets airflow over the wings.
The plane is being thrusted forward by the engines. The engines themselves don’t push air over the wings of the plane - the engines push the plane forward, which then causes air to move over the wings, which then causes the plane the lift.
Now, add in the treadmill. The plane is thrusting forward and the treadmill is matching the plane’s wheel rotation speed, only in reverse, so the plane looks stationary.
The planes thrust is forward, but it isn’t actually moving forward relative to the air around it, so the air is NOT flowing over the wings, which means the plane doesn’t lift off of the ground.
Someone please correct me, because I’d like to know the answer.
[/QUOTE]
We all agree and seem to understand that no airflow over wings = no flying. If a bystander can’t see the plane moving forward (ignoring wind), it won’t fly, no matter what happens to the wheels. And, making airflow requires the wings to move relative to the air. Tether a jet’s tail to prevent forward motion, it won’t take off no matter how you rev the engines. But, tether the nose and give it enough headwind, and it could potentially lift off without engines. (Like a kite or a glider)
The problem says that the conveyor belt moves at a certain speed determined relative to the speed of the plane’s WHEELS, not to the speed of the plane itself. So, if you are assuming that part of the question as posed requires the plane to be motionless relative to a bystander, wipe that thought from your mind - it’s not anywhere in the question and indeed, it is ONLY that incorrect but natural assumption that makes the question seem difficult.
It does help to think of the ‘conveyor belt’ as being the length of a runway, NOT the length of the plane. Now, you have it all right in your first 5.5 sentences, right up through ‘only in reverse.’ It’s the next step that falters - ‘so the plane looks stationary’ … why? What is holding it back? That conveyor belt isn’t PUSHING the plane back while the engines push it forward, it’s just making the wheels spin.
Maybe this will help - imagine the plane is backed up directly against a brick wall (or a thrust deflector, if it makes pilots happier). Now spin that conveyor belt ‘backward’ (moving nose-to-tail) at the plane’s takeoff speed. What happens? Does the plane bust through the wall, or take off? Now speed the conveyor belt up by a factor of 2 (or 5, or 50). Any change? No - the wheels spin faster and faster, but as long as they spin with anything approaching low friction, but that plane goes nowhere. Do we agree so far? Wall is behind plane, belt is making the wheels spin madly.
Now, with our runway-length conveyor belt still running madly, convert our stationary brick wall into an aircraft carrier’s catapult, or whatever - i.e., have the wall physically PUSH the plane forward at takeoff speed. The conveyor belt can’t overcome the force of a brick wall pushing the plane, no matter how fast they may make the wheels spin. Plane is moving forward at takeoff speed and takes off, because it has airflow over the wings, right? Are we still in agreement? Now, simply mentally replace the pushing wall/catapult with the pushing jet engines, because, relative to the tiny backward force exerted by the spinning wheels, the jet’s engines are functionally the same as the wall - an irresistible force.
So, as the question is stated, Cece is clearly right. If we change the question and require that the plane remains motionless with respect to a bystander, first we have to add why/how this is so (e.g., tethered at tail), and it doesn’t fly. That result might be slightly counterintuitive, but it isn’t the question presented.
Maybe this will help someone …
Clay