[QUOTE=SFORCE82]
This scenario can be compared to a jogger running on a treadmill. Imagine, for the instant, that the jogger gets off the treadmill, moves it outside, puts on some rollerskates, and straps on a jetpack. The jogger then gets on the treadmill, starts the treadmill, activates a sensor that determines how much thrust is produced from the jetpack and relays it to the treadmill computer which adjusts the speed of the treadmill to compensate by spinning quickly backwards. Now, since the treadmill can exert a backwards force on the jogger despite the rollerskates, the jogger simply stays in place with respect to a stational observer. Does he feel a strong wind blowing on him from the front? No, because he is not accelerating with respect to the ground. He will probably get blisters on his back and feet from the jetpack and the rollerskates with wheels turning at many, many orders of magnitude higher than intended (the cloth/rubber part of the skates will melt off within the first 20-30 seconds or so), but he will not feel any more wind passing over him than if he got off the treadmill and took off the jetpack and the skates.
At least that’s what I think.
[/QUOTE]
No. No, no, no, no, no.
Draw a damned force diagram, instead of thinking about it in your head. It is so damn easy to understand physics once you have to put it on paper and make computations.
The wheels can turn any damn speed they want; their speed isn’t in any way important to the velocity of the jogger relative to a position outside the treadmill. The treadmill can only impart force upon the WHEELS; they then turn. The fact they are turning isn’t important to the jogger at all, other than the fact that he hopes to God they don’t stop turning (by, for instance, having the bearings explode), so that the belt suddenly DOES impart force to the jogger. The damn belt can co as fast as it wants, and it’s totally irrelevant to the jogger, once the system overcomes the intitial force of static friction (a very minor issue).
I’ll repeat one last time for all readers who fail still to understand the reason the Column got the right answer:
DRAW THE DIAGRAM!!!