Gatorade vs. home made sports drinks

A week or two ago the local news had a story about what is best to drink when replenishing body fluids. Chocolate Milk came in way ahead of Gatorade. I don’t remember who did the study but I found the following doing a Lyco’s search.

Jim

By Leslie Carson RD, Sports Nutritionist and 2001 National Marathon Team Member

Whether you are gearing up for competition, or enjoy ACTIVE living, your body needs the right fuel after exercise to replenish energy stores and speed recovery. You may be surprised to hear that CHOCOLATE MILK is one of the best recovery drinks for active individuals.

Chocolate milk is carbohydrate rich (26 grams/1 cup), moderate in protein (9 grams/1 cup), and low in fat (2 grams/1 cup). Research suggests that carbohydrate beverages that contain amino acids from protein help promote rebuilding of muscle after exercise (J Appl Physiol, 2000). Another research study suggests that liquid calories tend not to “fill us up” as much as food calories (J. Obesity, 2000).

This is good news for athletes who often lose their appetites after exercise, but need 40-60 grams of carbohydrates within 30-45 minutes after exercise to facilitate recovery. Although there are many sports drinks on the market that are carbohydrate rich, and moderate in protein, nothing beats great tasting chocolate milk - both accessible and affordable to most athletes.

Chocolate milk is recommended BEFORE and AFTER exercise, not DURING exercise as beverages containing more than 8grams of carbohydrates/ 100ml may cause gastric distress and interfere with hydration.

Did you know that chocolate milk contains less simple sugar than equal amounts of apple juice . . . Until next time, be bright and drink right . . . for optimal recovery!

I couldn’t have said it better myself regarding your hyperbole about people buying bottled water being evidence of a failed education system. Perhaps we are both guilty of exaggerating to make our points? Of course, it’s fairly obvious that my point is relatively true (soda is not good for you, especially compared to alternatives like water) and yours is blatantly false (as I’ve presented good reasons for buying bottled water with which you’ve agreed).

You don’t bother to back up your claim about bottled water sales being the result of failed education and instead seize on my comment about soda being unhealthy. Whatever the failures of my education, it was just good enough to spot a red herring when I see one.

The ancient Romans drank honeyed vinegar, sometimes with salt, and it worked great for them. This was late improved on by the Perisans, who made stuff called sekanjabins. Basically, you make a simple syrup of sugar and water, then boil in a fruit or spice or herb flavoring, then add vinegar. In the final drinkiong, you don’t taste the vinegar as such. You just get a refreshing sense of coolness as you drink. MInt is a very common flavor, but I’ve made strawberry, vanilla-cardamom, rose, and even blueberry with great success. You can also make sharbats, which are done with an acidic flavor so they don’t require the vinegar. Lime and pomegranate are great sharbats. The syrup will keep indefinitely and requires no refrigeration. To drink it, mix it with plain water to taste, usually about one cup per gallon of water. For sports use, add salt to the final mix.
You end up with a drink that is cheap, tasty, effective, and contains no artificial flavors or colors.
If anyone wants more info on these, feel free to write me directly for a more detailed recipe. They’re super easy to make.
HennaDancer
info at hennadancer dot com

Athletes should use sports drinks.

Try this formula for Oral Rehydration Salts

http://www.rehydrate.org/ors/

The role of protein in the athlete’s diet:

http://www.gssiweb.com/reflib/refs/668/sse_93.cfm?pid=38

http://www.gssiweb.com/reflib/refs/692/sports_science_news_protein.cfm

http://www.gssiweb.com/reflib/refs/665/letter_jeffz.cfm?pid=38