::Rambly thesis-length MPSIMS post warning::
I’ve mentioned before that my daily driver is a 2020 Civic Sport trim sedan. Before I purchased this car I’ve always driven old used cars in varying degrees of ugliness and unreliability. Since I have a 70 mile round-trip commute through the mountains I finally decided I needed something that 1) was supremely reliable, 2) got excellent gas mileage, and 3) could handle a serpentine mountain road with no issue. For (3) I wanted a manual transmission, which limited my options severely. The Civic, a Sport trim, was really the only car I could get locally that met all the requirements. I signed the papers on it 2 days before Christmas 2019. I’ve done every bit of scheduled and recommended maintenance on it and kept all the records – even keeping all fuel receipts (for which I have recieved much ribbing for, but this is the first new car I’ve bought and I’m OCD to begin with, so whatever. I like to have a paper trail
)
The Civic has its downsides. It doesn’t have lumbar support, the stereo is weak, and it doesn’t have variable intermittent windshield wipers – a disadvantage here in the rainforest of the PNW – and the trunk is small.
It’s also very low to the ground.
My first choice when I was car shopping was a Kia Soul but there were a couple of problems. First, they were butt-ugly. It looked like the bastard child of a Pontiac Aztec and a VW Thing. Whoever designed the front end was clearly not part of the same team that designed the rear end. I’m not one to pay much attention to the appearance of a vehicle – as I said I’ve driven plenty of ugly cars (1986 Chrysler LeBaron, 1989 Toyota van), but those Souls were so fugly that I couldn’t help but cringe. Second, the manual transmission option was only available on the base trim, on which such niceties as cruise control and arm rests were absent. So I went with the Civic and have been driving it problem-free ever since.
Fast forward to this weekend. My wife and I were running errands and she made some comment about how I better not need to drive to work in the snow this winter. I have a ~35 mile one-way commute and 90% of that drive is through the mountains. We don’t get snow regularly but it isn’t exactly unknown. Anyway, I asked my wife why snow would be an issue. She drives a GMC Terrain that has full-time AWD and if I needed to commute in snow we’d simply swap cars. She knows how to drive a manual.
Well… no. She told me that sometimes her knees hurt her to the point that its difficult to get in and out of the Civic. I know she has chronic knee pain but never knew that it gave her that much trouble getting in and out of the car. It was a shocker for sure. She never said anything before about it. Knowing her as well as I do it’s been a problem for a while she just hasn’t said anything.
So now I’m debating trading the Civic for… well, I still like Souls. A manual transmission is no longer an option at all, so maybe I can get one with the lumbar support and variable intermittent windshield wipers that I’ve been jonesing for at the cost of accepting a CVT. Having a remote start, heated seats, and a sunroof would be nice too (although I worry about the sunroof leaking in this climate). Clearly it would significantly more comfortable for my wife.The worst part of this decision is I do not want to go back to having a car payment. I paid the Civic off this past summer, dropping $16K early to get the title. According to NADA and KBB the Civic, with 40K miles on it, has a trade-in value of about $23K (which is significantly more than I paid for it). That number will only go down. The Soul has an MSRP of, depending on trim, $23-25K but I’m sure the out-the-door shopping bag price would be much higher due to the continuing shortage of new cars.
We also have a 1990 Mercedes 300E that’s perfectly capable and willing to be a daily driver but tends to live in the garage because while its a beautiful car that’s been meticulously maintained and kept in good repair it isn’t a comfortable car by any stretch of the imagination. It lacks some features like cup holders, adjustable dashboard lights, and a tilt steering wheel – things that are so ubiquitous today that not having them feels like I’m being cheated (it has an electric telescoping steering column though. Go figure) Plus, it, like the Civic, is pretty low to the ground. It has the 4Matic AWD transmission so I could drive it to work on potentially snowy days, but an hour in it is more uncomfortable than the Civic – but it does have heated seats!
I asked my wife point-blank if I should seriously look into getting something else, something that she would comfortable driving, and she downplayed her knee problems and told me not to worry about it. This, of course, was a day after telling me she doesn’t want to be in a situation where she has to drive the Civic or the 300E. She’s half British so I suspect this is just her stiff-upper-lip DNA showing itself.
Yeah, first-world problems. But still. Sigh, what to do…