# Good on the ACLU for helping a man gets his guns back

**URL:** <https://boards.straightdope.com/t/good-on-the-aclu-for-helping-a-man-gets-his-guns-back/547498>\
**Category:** Great Debates\
**Created:** [July 21, 2010, 6:33pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/good-on-the-aclu-for-helping-a-man-gets-his-guns-back/547498 "2010-07-21T18:33:55Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 20\
**Page:** 5

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![villa](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/v/bc79bd/32.png) [@villa](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/villa)\
**Post date:** [July 26, 2010, 6:05pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/good-on-the-aclu-for-helping-a-man-gets-his-guns-back/547498/81 "2010-07-26T18:05:11Z")

</div>

> [@Bricker](#):
>
> The Court in Heller and MacDonald could hardly be more precise.

Seriously? You don’t think the Court left huge realms of argument open on what permissible regulation is? They got it essentially right in both cases, but they are far from being precise - otherwise I wouldn’t have had to remember to unload my gun from my car before driving into DC this morning.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Zeriel](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/z/58956e/32.png) [@Zeriel](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Zeriel)\
**Post date:** [July 26, 2010, 6:07pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/good-on-the-aclu-for-helping-a-man-gets-his-guns-back/547498/82 "2010-07-26T18:07:13Z")

</div>

Incidentally, Steven’s analysis reminds me why I would never want to be a lawyer. Having read every word, I kept getting the urge to slap him silly every time he went on what was, to my way of thinking, a pointless digression over minutae and historical lunacy–who the hell cares what people wrote as proposals that WEREN’T passed, we’re talking about what was!

I get the exact same feeling when reading the majority decision from Scalia, too. =P

–Zeriel, who increasingly feels like he’s the only gun-toting law and order Democrat that he knows.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Whack-a-Mole](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/whack-a-mole/32/141_2.png) [@Whack-a-Mole](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Whack-a-Mole)\
**Post date:** [July 26, 2010, 6:17pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/good-on-the-aclu-for-helping-a-man-gets-his-guns-back/547498/83 "2010-07-26T18:17:17Z")

</div>

> [@Zeriel](#):
>
> I’m basically going to ignore the histrionics in the first bit of your response as not germane, since the “strawman” I was shredding was the myth that all doper gun rights advocates are screaming NRA ninnies, when in fact very few of us are–which you didn’t address, apparently thinking I was somehow referring to your incomplete reading of the 2nd amendment.

You are ascribing to me a position I did not express. So the strawman is indeed one of your own making.

> [@](#):
>
> So how are we to deal with Stevens’ handwaving away “the people” to mean “not really the people, just some of the people” here? This is where Stevens fails to make a convincing argument…

It’s called the English language. Words mean something. Words in a certain order mean something. The sentence needs to be taken as a whole and the parts garner meaning in the context of the sentence. The preamble informs of what the FFs are on about in the rest of the sentence. You choose to take the sentence in pieces and ignore the sentence as whole.

> [@](#):
>
> …as well as here, where he seriously argues that “keep and bear arms” doesn’t mean that one can USE arms, because of course that makes perfect sense. :rolleyes:

You can use arms in the context of a militia.

> [@](#):
>
> Let me repeat what I said before: I believe that the first clause (“A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State,”) means that the militia (currently, as cited before, defined as “all males in the US between 17 and 45” at a minimum by statute since 1903!, and if you ask me that needs an update to simply “all able-bodied citizens capable of participating in the national defense at times of need” in keeping with our more egalitarian culture) uses of weapons are paramount (“being necessary” and all). “Well-regulated” means that those weapons, their usage, procurement, and storage can of course be regulated under the law to militia-appropriate standards, IMHO, but “shall not be infringed” and “the people” mean something too.

Well, if you are a gun rights advocate who argues for meaningful restrictions in training and registration then you are a rare breed. I have never seen the NRA advocate for it but have seen them fight tooth and nail against such things.

As things currently stand this is how easy it is to get a CCW permit today:

> [@](#):
>
> **Applications for concealed-gun permits from Utah hit record levels**  
> By Reuters  
> Tuesday, July 6, 2010
> 
> Never shot a gun? Never been to Utah? You could still qualify for a concealed-gun permit from the state.
> 
> \<snip\>
> 
> Utah makes it easy to get a concealed-weapons permit, which is valid in 32 other states and lasts five years.
> 
> Today, more out-of-state residents than state residents have Utah permits, and out-of-state instructors outnumber those from Utah.
> 
> Applicants must clear a background check, be 21, take a course and pay a $65.25 fee. Last year, 74,000 people applied for the permit.
> 
> \<snip\>
> 
> New Mexico and Nevada have revoked recognition of Utah’s licenses in recent months because that state does not require applicants to train with a handgun or even fire one.
> 
> SOURCE: [http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/07/05/AR2010070502753.html](http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/07/05/AR2010070502753.html)

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Really\_Not\_All\_That\_Bright](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/r/e8c25b/32.png) [@Really\_Not\_All\_That\_Bright](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Really_Not_All_That_Bright)\
**Post date:** [July 26, 2010, 6:30pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/good-on-the-aclu-for-helping-a-man-gets-his-guns-back/547498/84 "2010-07-26T18:30:29Z")

</div>

> [@Zeriel](#):
>
> > [@Really\_Not\_All\_That\_Bright](#):
> >
> > I would happily let you or **Una** drive around in a fully armed Sherman tank, if you so wanted.
> 
> I appreciate the vote of confidence and will do my best not to run over your car. 😃

This sort of civility should be _de rigeur_ for GD threads. 😉

> [@Zeriel](#):
>
> Incidentally, Steven’s analysis reminds me why I would never want to be a lawyer. Having read every word, I kept getting the urge to slap him silly every time he went on what was, to my way of thinking, a pointless digression over minutae and historical lunacy–who the hell cares what people wrote as proposals that WEREN’T passed, we’re talking about what was!

Stevens, like every other Justice ( **Bricker’s** Scalia-worship notwithstanding), is not above picking and choosing when to apply legislators’ original intent (the correct time to do so, of course, is never).

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Zeriel](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/z/58956e/32.png) [@Zeriel](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Zeriel)\
**Post date:** [July 26, 2010, 7:07pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/good-on-the-aclu-for-helping-a-man-gets-his-guns-back/547498/85 "2010-07-26T19:07:51Z")

</div>

> [@Whack-a-Mole](#):
>
> It’s called the English language. Words mean something. Words in a certain order mean something. The sentence needs to be taken as a whole and the parts garner meaning in the context of the sentence. The preamble informs of what the FFs are on about in the rest of the sentence. You choose to take the sentence in pieces and ignore the sentence as whole.

Yes, the preamble informs. It informs ME that it’s a dependent clause describing the rationale (which is absolutely viable both in grammar and in projected intent) to the second (main) clause.

> [@](#):
>
> Well, if you are a gun rights advocate who argues for meaningful restrictions in training and registration then you are a rare breed. I have never seen the NRA advocate for it but have seen them fight tooth and nail against such things.
> 
> As things currently stand this is how easy it is to get a CCW permit today:

Arguably this should make you happy–it’s tough to get statistics, but a cursory reading of available stats indicates that CCW holders are somewhere between “no more likely than any general public member” and “significantly less likely than the average” to commit violent/gun crimes.

A lot of states, especially “red states” but some surprising exceptions, are offering essentially shall-issue CCW licenses–my own state is one. At least some of this is backlash against total gun regulation of the type that tends to only find a home in many larger cities.

Look, there’s no dearth of people on both sides of the debate arguing equally untenable positions (namely, “no regulation whatsoever” and “no guns in civilian hands whatsoever”) and neither side has given the other much reason to trust their legislative intent. The pro-regulation side argues that gun violence is a problem (which it is). The pro-gun-ownership side points to the vanishingly small percentage of gun owners who commit gun crimes (especially the pro-some-regulations folks like me, who point out that CCW holders regardless of degree of testing/rigor of permit acquisition seem to be less prone to gun crime.)

The problem is that there’s a history in the legislation of this country for some gun ownership rules to be turned into onerous or difficult rules, so the pro-gun community is (understandably and frustratingly) suspicious of the motives of people who advocate for some sensible rules. The biggest argument I hear against my proposal is twofold–“testing implies it can be refused, and we’ve had testing requirements (such as literacy tests for voting) be used in nefarious ways before” and “what’s to stop a new, less-gun-friendly and oppressive leadership from using the well-founded sane registration lists as a handy ‘here’s the people who I need to suppress and disarm’ list”?  
Both are valid caveats in a world where one can’t trust the good natures and decency of their political opponents, unfortunately.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Lumpy](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/lumpy/32/446_2.png) [@Lumpy](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Lumpy)\
**Post date:** [July 26, 2010, 8:27pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/good-on-the-aclu-for-helping-a-man-gets-his-guns-back/547498/86 "2010-07-26T20:27:15Z")

</div>

I have a question I’ve raised before but which I’ve never heard a straightforward answer to. First, two quotes from the Constitution:[ul][li]Article 1, Section 10, Clause 3 (Compact Clause): No State shall, without the Consent of Congress, lay any duty of Tonnage, keep Troops, or Ships of War in time of Peace, enter into any Agreement or Compact with another State, or with a foreign Power, or engage in War, unless actually invaded, or in such imminent Danger as will not admit of delay.Second Amendment to the Constitution: A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.[/ul][/li]  
Ok. If your posistion is that by “militia”, the Second Amendment means a regimented body of armed persons organized and controlled by the state, then just what exactly is the difference between a “Militia” and “Troops”?

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Really\_Not\_All\_That\_Bright](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/r/e8c25b/32.png) [@Really\_Not\_All\_That\_Bright](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Really_Not_All_That_Bright)\
**Post date:** [July 26, 2010, 8:29pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/good-on-the-aclu-for-helping-a-man-gets-his-guns-back/547498/87 "2010-07-26T20:29:34Z")

</div>

Troops aren’t organized and controlled by the state(s), but by the federal government.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Lumpy](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/lumpy/32/446_2.png) [@Lumpy](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Lumpy)\
**Post date:** [July 26, 2010, 8:58pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/good-on-the-aclu-for-helping-a-man-gets-his-guns-back/547498/88 "2010-07-26T20:58:25Z")

</div>

> [@Really\_Not\_All\_That\_Bright](#):
>
> Troops aren’t organized and controlled by the state(s), but by the federal government.

If a state can have a state army, and by your definition they’re just not **called** troops, then what’s the point of A1S10C3? If states can’t have troops then what is the Second Amendment promising they CAN have?

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![villa](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/v/bc79bd/32.png) [@villa](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/villa)\
**Post date:** [July 26, 2010, 9:03pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/good-on-the-aclu-for-helping-a-man-gets-his-guns-back/547498/89 "2010-07-26T21:03:05Z")

</div>

> [@Lumpy](#):
>
> > [@Really\_Not\_All\_That\_Bright](#):
> >
> > Troops aren’t organized and controlled by the state(s), but by the federal government.
> 
> If a state can have a state army, and by your definition they’re just not **called** troops, then what’s the point of A1S10C3? If states can’t have troops then what is the Second Amendment promising they CAN have?

Aren’t “troops” members of regular, professional armed forces and the “militia” is instead made up of the citizenry, to be called out when needed?

So A1S10C3 is stating that a state may not have a standing army, but, under the Second, individuals cannot be prevented from owning weapons because they might be needed to be called up to serve in the militia.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Zeriel](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/z/58956e/32.png) [@Zeriel](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Zeriel)\
**Post date:** [July 26, 2010, 10:09pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/good-on-the-aclu-for-helping-a-man-gets-his-guns-back/547498/90 "2010-07-26T22:09:39Z")

</div>

> [@Lumpy](#):
>
> I have a question I’ve raised before but which I’ve never heard a straightforward answer to. First, two quotes from the Constitution:[ul][li]Article 1, Section 10, Clause 3 (Compact Clause): No State shall, without the Consent of Congress, lay any duty of Tonnage, keep Troops, or Ships of War in time of Peace, enter into any Agreement or Compact with another State, or with a foreign Power, or engage in War, unless actually invaded, or in such imminent Danger as will not admit of delay.[\*]Second Amendment to the Constitution: A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.[/ul][/li]  
> Ok. If your posistion is that by “militia”, the Second Amendment means a regimented body of armed persons organized and controlled by the state, then just what exactly is the difference between a “Militia” and “Troops”?

A Militia is organized but not standing and not professional (in the sense of it’s not their full-time job).

“Troops” are a standing, ready army.

The biggest difference is that one has to call up a Militia, but Troops are ready now.

You’ll note the end of Article 1, Section 10, Clause 3 says “unless actually invaded, or in such imminent Danger as will not admit of delay”, which implies that a State may have forces ready for activation under those circumstances, even if they may not have “Troops” ready at all times.

This dovetails with the “security of a Free State” part of the 2nd Amendment.

One could argue, given this context, that the 2nd Amendment only prohibits the Federal Government from infringing on the right of the people to bear arms. It would come down, essentially, to whether the “state” in the 2nd amendment is the “sub-unit of the Federal Government” or “sovereign state”, combined with what one thought of the relevance of the first clause’s power (whether it is a modifier/descriptor or an active clause in its own right), combined with (in some cases) what one thought about whether firearms ownership is a right reserved to the people as opposed to the states.

Whatever the case, the Supreme Court appears to believe that the rights to firearms ownership is reserved to the people, as they appear to have incorporated it as of McDonald vs. Chicago.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Whack-a-Mole](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/whack-a-mole/32/141_2.png) [@Whack-a-Mole](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Whack-a-Mole)\
**Post date:** [July 27, 2010, 1:32am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/good-on-the-aclu-for-helping-a-man-gets-his-guns-back/547498/91 "2010-07-27T01:32:29Z")

</div>

> [@Zeriel](#):
>
> Yes, the preamble informs. It informs ME that it’s a dependent clause describing the rationale (which is absolutely viable both in grammar and in projected intent) to the second (main) clause.

It is only if you disagree with this:

_“it cannot be presumed that any clause in the constitution is intended to be without effect.” Marbury v. Madison, 1 Cranch 137, 174 (1803)._

If you think it is ok to just declare some part of the constitution rhetorical fluffery with no effect then that is worrisome.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Zeriel](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/z/58956e/32.png) [@Zeriel](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Zeriel)\
**Post date:** [July 27, 2010, 2:44am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/good-on-the-aclu-for-helping-a-man-gets-his-guns-back/547498/92 "2010-07-27T02:44:34Z")

</div>

> [@Whack-a-Mole](#):
>
> > [@Zeriel](#):
> >
> > Yes, the preamble informs. It informs ME that it’s a dependent clause describing the rationale (which is absolutely viable both in grammar and in projected intent) to the second (main) clause.
> 
> It is only if you disagree with this:
> 
> _“it cannot be presumed that any clause in the constitution is intended to be without effect.” Marbury v. Madison, 1 Cranch 137, 174 (1803)._
> 
> If you think it is ok to just declare some part of the constitution rhetorical fluffery with no effect then that is worrisome.

So in other words, because I’ve said that that clause absolutely guarantees the government can regulate firearms ownership provided that it doesn’t break the stated plain meaning of the second clause (shall not be infringed), including requirements of training and licensing (which fulfill the military meaning of “regulated”, especially if there is a mandatory selection of calibers/platforms for at least ones first rifle and pistol), I am dismissing it as fluffery? Especially as I’ve also pointed out that the statutory definition of “militia” is far more people than merely those under uniform in the national and state guards, so as not to ignore that clause either? Right, then.

I’ll agree that I think “A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State,” is rhetorical frippery if you agree that you and Mr. Stevens apparently think that “the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.” is rhetorical frippery.

Clearly neither of htose are the case, and you’re arguing in bad faith.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Lumpy](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/lumpy/32/446_2.png) [@Lumpy](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Lumpy)\
**Post date:** [July 27, 2010, 2:51am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/good-on-the-aclu-for-helping-a-man-gets-his-guns-back/547498/93 "2010-07-27T02:51:27Z")

</div>

As to what the Second Amendment is talking about when it mentions a “well regulated” Militia, I suggest everyone who hasn’t already done so read [The Federalist #29](http://www.constitution.org/fed/federa29.htm), where Alexander Hamilton answers various objections that were raised to the proposed Constitution giving the federal government authority over the Militia. The Federalist #29 answers in part [this published article](http://www.wepin.com/articles/afp/afp29.html), which argued that if the Federal government was given authority over the militia, that it could use that power to regiment the populace under permanent military discipline. Hamilton’s rebuttal states (bolding mine):

> [@](#):
>
> "The project of disciplining all the militia of the United States is as futile as it would be injurious, if it were capable of being carried into execution. A tolerable expertness in military movements is a business that requires time and practice. It is not a day, or even a week, that will suffice for the attainment of it. To oblige the great body of the yeomanry, and of the other classes of the citizens, to be under arms for the purpose of going through military exercises and evolutions, as often as might be necessary to acquire the degree of perfection which would entitle them to the character of a **well-regulated militia** , would be a real grievance to the people, and a serious public inconvenience and loss. It would form an annual deduction from the productive labor of the country, to an amount which, calculating upon the present numbers of the people, would not fall far short of the whole expense of the civil establishments of all the States. To attempt a thing which would abridge the mass of labor and industry to so considerable an extent, would be unwise: and the experiment, if made, could not succeed, because it would not long be endured. Little more can reasonably be aimed at, with respect to the people at large, than to have them properly armed and equipped; and in order to see that this be not neglected, it will be necessary to assemble them once or twice in the course of a year.

In other words, Hamilton uses the phrase to mean practiced, functional, competent. The sense that many people today take the phrase to mean- only that part of the population that regularly drills with arms under state supervision, and are the first ones called when needed- is referred to by Hamilton elsewhere in #29 as the “select corp” of the Militia (The Militia Act of 1903 a.k.a The Dick Act, uses the phrase “organized militia” to mean virtually the same thing.) He also explicity uses the word militia as synonymous with the mass of the populace, and denies that it is either necessary or desirable for the entire militia to be “well regulated”.

I would hold the first clause of the Second Amendment to mean that in order to have a populace actually familar with arms and ready to serve if needed, the Federal government was not to order that guns be kept locked away in state armories and only allowed in peoples’ hands during an emergency. In order to BE “well regulated”, it was held necessary that the people should “keep and bear arms”.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Zeriel](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/z/58956e/32.png) [@Zeriel](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Zeriel)\
**Post date:** [July 27, 2010, 2:59am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/good-on-the-aclu-for-helping-a-man-gets-his-guns-back/547498/94 "2010-07-27T02:59:12Z")

</div>

Thank you, Lumpy. That’s really the crux of the original intent.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Whack-a-Mole](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/whack-a-mole/32/141_2.png) [@Whack-a-Mole](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Whack-a-Mole)\
**Post date:** [July 27, 2010, 10:35am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/good-on-the-aclu-for-helping-a-man-gets-his-guns-back/547498/95 "2010-07-27T10:35:47Z")

</div>

> [@Zeriel](#):
>
> Thank you, Lumpy. That’s really the crux of the original intent.

Well that’s interesting. “Original intent” seems to have been a compromise between two opposing viewpoints on a right to bear arms. Perhaps it is no wonder we are left in this quandary today.

Make no mistake I am a big fan of the Federalist Papers and think Hamilton and Madison (and John Jay for a few) did a fantastic job and I hold them in high regard. I have referenced them frequently myself in the past. That said while they are an excellent guide to original intent they are not the definitive work of it. If we were to pen a new constitution today it would be a practice in compromise…things were no different back then.

It seems there was a distinct two-sided difference in what the right to bear arms meant so Madison punted to appease both sides.

> [@](#):
>
> In resolving the arms versus militia issue, language that combined a militia statement with a recognition of an individual right fitted Madison’s objectives perfectly. A militia statement standing alone likely would have been unacceptable to liberal [p.39] groups such as the Pennsylvania minority, Samual Adams and his supporters, the New Hampshire majority, and possibly Jefferson himself–all of whom had advocated an individual right to arms and none of whose efforts had so much as mentioned the militia. Conversely, an individual right to arms clause, standing alone, might well have irritated supporters of the traditional militia such as George Mason and possibly Richard Henry Lee, both of whom were powerful Virginians. In addition, both were figures with whom Madison still had to deal because they would vote on his proposal–Mason as a Virginia legislator and Lee as a member of the federal Senate. By joining the two issues, Madison would be assured of broad-based support for his proposal. He naturally chose language that already had proved acceptable to both groups. “[T]he right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed; a well armed and well regulated militia being the best security of a free country.” [144]
> 
> Much of Madison’s handiwork underwent substantial editing in both the House and the Senate, but his militia and arms proposal survived relatively unscathed. In the version finally passed by the House, the order of the provisions was reversed: “A well regulated militia, composed of the body of the people, being the best security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed.” [145] Although the first casualties of the House’s editorial process were his preambles and explanations, the militia statement and the right to arms guarantee both were retained. The House apparently did not think that either portion of what would become the Second Amendment was redundant; nor did the Senate, which emphasized the differing natures of each provision. On the one hand, it refused to add “for the common defense” to the right to arms guarantee, which would have suggested that the guarantee’s purpose was linked solely to the militia; on the other, it replaced the House’s statement that the militia was “the best security” of a free state with a stronger statement that it was “necessary” to the security. [146]
> 
> SOURCE: [http://www.saf.org/LawReviews/FieldsAndHardy.html](http://www.saf.org/LawReviews/FieldsAndHardy.html)

The above source material is long but an interesting read. I encourage people here to read it. In short it shows that this topic is far from a clear one.

Here is another example in how differing states saw the right to bear arms differently prior to the constitution being written:

> [@](#):
>
> Provisions in the various declarations and constitutions of the colonies also reflected the beginnings of a divergence of opinions on the nature and purpose of the militia as an institution. Virginia, which was the first colony to adopt these documents, chose a constitution and bill of rights that was drafted by a committee, and was taken predominantly from the proposals of the conservative George Mason. [90]
> 
> The prevailing version recognized, “A well-regulated militia, composed of the body of the people, trained to arms, is the proper, natural, and safe defence of a free State.” [91] It made no mention, however, of an individual right to arms.
> 
> \<snip\>
> 
> Pennsylvania adopted a bill of rights only a few months after Virginia, but its political situation was nearly the opposite of the one in Mason’s state. The Pennsylvania convention was dominated by a radical coalition whose political base consisted of small farmers in the western part of the state and “mechanics,” or skilled tradesmen, in Philadelphia. Its product was decidedly Jeffersonian in nature, extending the franchise to any taxpayer over the age of twenty-one, and giving a greater scope to individual rights. [98] John Adams later would note that Pennsylvania’s “bill of rights [was] almost verbatim from that [p.29] of Virginia.” [99] Respecting the militia issue, however, the word “almost” is one that bears emphasis because Pennsylvania clearly departed from the Virginia approach by deleting the Virginia reference to well-regulated militias and by adding a new recognition “[t]hat the people have a right to bear arms for the defense of themselves and the State.” [100]
> 
> In states in which a relatively even split between liberal and conservative elements existed, efforts were made to reconcile the diverging views on the nature of the militia. The Massachusetts Constitution, whose chief author was John Adams, contained an elaborate provision for the democratic election of militia officers. Captains and subalterns were to be elected by their companies; higher officers were to be elected by their subordinates; major generals were to be appointed by the legislature. [101] In the bill of rights, Adams chose an unusual mode of trying to compromise the arms verses militia issue. He took the language of the Pennsylvania convention, expanded it by recognizing for the first time a right to “keep” as well as to “bear” arms, but then qualified the right by recognizing it only with regard to “the common defense.” [102]
> 
> SOURCE: [http://www.saf.org/LawReviews/FieldsAndHardy.html](http://www.saf.org/LawReviews/FieldsAndHardy.html)

So, **Lumpy’s** and **Zeriel’s** assurances that original intent is obvious I think we can say it decidedly wasn’t (unless we want to say original intent was to appease two sides and walk down the middle).

As I result I guess we could say today that either view is “correct” (or at least not wrong).

Finally, I am curious about this quote I came across from Scalia…seems at odds with rulings he made subsequent to this (in particular McDonald v. Chicago):

\*“[T]here is no need to deceive ourselves as to what the original Second Amendment said and meant. Of course, properly understood, it is no limitation upon arms control by the states.”

—Antoin Scalia, A Matter of Interpretation: Federal Courts and the Law (1997)  
\*

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Whack-a-Mole](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/whack-a-mole/32/141_2.png) [@Whack-a-Mole](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Whack-a-Mole)\
**Post date:** [July 27, 2010, 10:45am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/good-on-the-aclu-for-helping-a-man-gets-his-guns-back/547498/96 "2010-07-27T10:45:33Z")

</div>

As an aside I find it interesting that when the Constitution was written it seems it was the conservatives trying to keep guns out of the hands of the people and the liberals trying to give them guns.

Quite a difference from today.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Lumpy](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/lumpy/32/446_2.png) [@Lumpy](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Lumpy)\
**Post date:** [July 27, 2010, 12:47pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/good-on-the-aclu-for-helping-a-man-gets-his-guns-back/547498/97 "2010-07-27T12:47:55Z")

</div>

> [@Whack-a-Mole](#):
>
> Well that’s interesting. “Original intent” seems to have been a compromise between two opposing viewpoints on a right to bear arms. Perhaps it is no wonder we are left in this quandary today.\<snip\>  
> It seems there was a distinct two-sided difference in what the right to bear arms meant so Madison punted to appease both sides.\<snip\>  
> So, **Lumpy’s** and **Zeriel’s** assurances that original intent is obvious I think we can say it decidedly wasn’t (unless we want to say original intent was to appease two sides and walk down the middle).

An honest and enlightening response **Whack-a-Mole** , thank you. Apparently from the beginning there was a conflict between two viewpoints that are still with us today: “you don’t seriously propose to let any yahoo who wants a gun to have one?!” versus “you don’t seriously think the government can be entrusted with a monopoly on arms do you??” Real doubt about an issue where either extreme seems unreasonable is a valid position.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Zeriel](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/z/58956e/32.png) [@Zeriel](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Zeriel)\
**Post date:** [July 27, 2010, 12:55pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/good-on-the-aclu-for-helping-a-man-gets-his-guns-back/547498/98 "2010-07-27T12:55:31Z")

</div>

I should just bow out of this thread if Lumpy is going to post basically what I wanted to say every time.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Really\_Not\_All\_That\_Bright](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/r/e8c25b/32.png) [@Really\_Not\_All\_That\_Bright](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Really_Not_All_That_Bright)\
**Post date:** [July 27, 2010, 1:07pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/good-on-the-aclu-for-helping-a-man-gets-his-guns-back/547498/99 "2010-07-27T13:07:26Z")

</div>

As I have many times before, I will point out that the _intent_ of a law, even one written by the (or some, or a) founding fathers, is immaterial.

If they couldn’t say in the text of the law what they meant to, shame on them. In the absence of evidence to the contrary, it must be assumed that a more (or less) expansive version which _does_ say what they wanted it to would not have received enough votes for passage.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Whack-a-Mole](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/whack-a-mole/32/141_2.png) [@Whack-a-Mole](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Whack-a-Mole)\
**Post date:** [July 27, 2010, 1:34pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/good-on-the-aclu-for-helping-a-man-gets-his-guns-back/547498/100 "2010-07-27T13:34:57Z")

</div>

> [@Really\_Not\_All\_That\_Bright](#):
>
> As I have many times before, I will point out that the _intent_ of a law, even one written by the (or some, or a) founding fathers, is immaterial.
> 
> If they couldn’t say in the text of the law what they meant to, shame on them. In the absence of evidence to the contrary, it must be assumed that a more (or less) expansive version which _does_ say what they wanted it to would not have received enough votes for passage.

Well…where does that leave us?

They were beholden to the political process…a democratic one at that so they had to reach compromises.

Granted it seems they left us with a mess by intentionally appeasing both sides thus leaving the result vague on the 2nd Amendment. The alternative would be for them to fight it out and land on one side or the other or toss the whole thing. Could be an interesting discussion on which way you think that might go but dangerous dice to roll. You might get sevens, you might get snake eyes. I do not think it is at all clear which way it might have gone had they pushed for a firm stance one way or the other.

Keep in mind the whole Bill of Rights was in the balance. If they decided to fight tooth-and-nail over the 2nd Amendment the whole thing might have been brought into jeopardy.

Considering I really like the rest of the Bill of Rights (admittedly not fussed about the 3rd Amendment) I think they did a good job. Amazed such a document came out as well as it did all things considered and perhaps still the best example of its kind in the world today…despite being the oldest.

[Previous page](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/good-on-the-aclu-for-helping-a-man-gets-his-guns-back/547498.md?page=4)

[Next page](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/good-on-the-aclu-for-helping-a-man-gets-his-guns-back/547498.md?page=6)
