# Guns, Freedom and Power

**URL:** <https://boards.straightdope.com/t/guns-freedom-and-power/243095>\
**Category:** Great Debates\
**Created:** [May 2, 2004, 3:28am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/guns-freedom-and-power/243095 "2004-05-02T03:28:56Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 20\
**Page:** 2

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![minty\_green](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/m/f6c823/32.png) [@minty\_green](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/minty_green)\
**Post date:** [May 4, 2004, 12:57am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/guns-freedom-and-power/243095/21 "2004-05-04T00:57:48Z")

</div>

The Supreme Court resolves only the questions that are presented to it for review. In the case of _Miller_, the prosecution asked the Court to review the lower court’s decision in favor of Mr. Miller, specifically asking whether the judge had erred by (a) ruling that Miller had an individual right to bear arms under the Second Amendment, and (b) ruling that the particular gun in question was the type of arm protected by the Second Amendment. The Supreme Court disposed of the case by answering the second issue, which made the first question superfluous.

[Note: I’m working from memory on the details of what the prosecutors said in their brief. I may be mistaken in some details.]

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![SnakeSpirit](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/snakespirit/32/7271_2.png) [@SnakeSpirit](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/SnakeSpirit)\
**Post date:** [May 4, 2004, 4:00am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/guns-freedom-and-power/243095/22 "2004-05-04T04:00:13Z")

</div>

> [@minty green](#):
>
> When come back, read cases.
> 
> On Preview: Jeez, man, if you’re going to argue about the law, at least take the time to read the law. The individual/collective issue is practically the only thing they discuss in the whole darn _Silveira_ case. But if you can’t take the time to read it, I’ll just quote a single sentence for you that makes it absolutely clear: That’s on page 23 of the opinion, by the way.

Thanks for the reference. Those of us who aren’t lawyers or lawyers in training (you haven’t stated here or in your profile which you claim to be) can’t sort through all this stuff and make sense. I read the whole thing, and the whole 84 pages of your other cite.

I’m not going to argue law with you; I didn’t intend to in the first place. Still, all I can find in your second cite [minty greens second cite](http://www.ca5.uscourts.gov/opinions/pub/99/99-10331-cr0.htm) is stuff like this:

> [@](#):
>
> \*\*We conclude that Miller does not support the government’s collective rights or sophisticated collective rights approach to the Second Amendment. Indeed, to the extent that Miller sheds light on the matter it cuts against the government’s position. \*\* Nor does the government cite any other authority binding on this panel which mandates acceptance of its position in this respect.(21) However, we do not proceed on the assumption that Miller actually accepted an individual rights, as opposed to a collective or sophisticated collective rights, interpretation of the Second Amendment.
> 
> We turn now to the Second Amendment’s preamble: “A well-regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State.” And, we ask ourselves whether this preamble suffices to mandate what would be an otherwise implausible collective rights or sophisticated collective rights interpretation of the amendment. **We conclude that it does not.**
> 
> \*\*We agree with the district court that the Second Amendment protects the right of individuals to privately keep and bear their own firearms \*\* that are suitable as individual, personal weapons and are not of the general kind or type excluded by Miller, regardless of whether the particular individual is then actually a member of a militia.(66) However, for the reasons stated, we also conclude that the predicate order in question here is sufficient, albeit likely minimally so, to support the deprivation, while it remains in effect, of the defendant’s Second Amendment rights. Accordingly, we reverse the district court’s dismissal of the indictment on Second Amendment grounds.

Hey, it was _ **your** _ cite!

Anyway: Peace. I can’t and won’t argue law with you. I’m not trained to understand and interpret that stuff. I’ll take your opinion as valid, but frankly I don’t think the individual vs. collective right issue is resolved. Looks to me like it’s still opinion.

I’ll wait for a final ruling. Save your cites. I’m not saying you are wrong. Maybe you are right. I still challenge the use of “almost universal,” however, even more so now I’m aware of your Esquire bent. I’ve seen two lawyers argue!

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![minty\_green](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/m/f6c823/32.png) [@minty\_green](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/minty_green)\
**Post date:** [May 4, 2004, 12:01pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/guns-freedom-and-power/243095/23 "2004-05-04T12:01:15Z")

</div>

Dude, I have told you twice already that _Emerson_, the case you just quoted, is the sole U.S. Court of Appeals case adopting the individual rights interpretation. It is the case that makes the collective rights model the “nearly universal” judicial interpretation, not wholly “universal.”

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![UncleBeer](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/u/977dab/32.png) [@UncleBeer](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/UncleBeer)\
**Post date:** [May 4, 2004, 12:29pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/guns-freedom-and-power/243095/24 "2004-05-04T12:29:46Z")

</div>

What’s with this appeals court stuff? Let’s look at the court superior to those - the U.S. Supreme Court. There are thirty-five Supreme Court cases in which all, or a portion, of the 2nd amendment is cited. I see some of them have been raised here already, so please forgive the duplications in the list that follows (I typed up last night at a place where I had no internet access), except to note that the authors of [this book](http://www.gunlaws.com/SCGC-News.html), Alan Korwin, David Kopel & Stephen P. Halbrook (an attorney who has actually argued and won gun cases before the Supreme Court) disagree with minty’s analysis. I typed up last night at a place where I had no internet access.

Again, these are all Supreme Court cases—not mere Circuit Courts of Appeals. According the analysis in the book linked above by the authors, I have bolded the opinions which support the individual rights view, italicized those which support a collective view, while equivocal opinions are plain text. Many of these are, of course, dissenting opinions, but they’re still valid in that most of these cases weren’t centered on the 2nd amendent.  
[ul]  
[li] **Spencer vs. Kemna (1998) – Dissenting opinion from denial of Cert. by Stevens**[/li][li] **Muscarello vs. U.S. (1998) – Dissenting opinion by Ginsburg**[/li][li] Printz vs. U.S. (1998) – Concurring opinion by Thomas[/li][li] **Albright vs. Oliver (1994) – Dissenting opinion by Stevens**[/li][li] **Planned Parenthood vs. Casey (1992) – Majority opinion by O’Connor**[/li][li] **U.S. vs. Verdugo-Urquidez (1992) – Majority opinion by Rehnquist**[/li][li] Lewis vs. U.S. (1968) – Majority opinion by Blackmun[/li][li] **Moore vs. East Cleveland (1976) – Plurality opinion by Powell**[/li][li] **Moore vs. East Cleveland (1976) – Dissenting opinion by White**[/li][li] _Adams vs. Williams (1972) – Dissenting opinion by Douglas_[/li][li] **Roe vs. Wade (1972) – Concurring opinion by Stewart**[/li][li] Laird vs. Tatum (1972) – Dissenting opinion by Douglas[/li][li] Burton vs. Sills (1969) – per curiam summary affirmation[/li][li] **Duncan vs. Louisiana (1968) – Concurring opinion by Black**[/li][li] **Malloy vs. Hogan (1965) – Majority opinion by Brennan**[/li][li] **Konigsberg vs. State Bar (1961) – Majority opinion by Harlan**[/li][li] **Poe vs. Ullman (1961) – Dissenting opinion by Harlan**[/li][li] **Poe vs. Ullman (1961) – Dissenting opinion by Douglas**[/li][li] **Knapp vs. Schweitzer (1958) – Majority opinion by Frankfurter**[/li][li] **Johnson vs. Eisentrager (1950) – Majority opinion by Jackson**[/li][li] **Adamson vs. Calfornia (1947) – Dissenting opinion by Black**[/li][li] _Hamilton vs. Regents (1935) – Majority opinion by Butler_[/li][li] U.S. vs. Schwimmer (1929) – Majority opinion by Butler[/li][li] Stearns vs. Wood (1915) – Majority opinion by McReynolds[/li][li] **Twining vs. New Jersey (1908) – Majority opinion by Moody**[/li][li] **Trono vs. U.S. (1905) – Majority opinion by Peckham**[/li][li] **Kepner vs. U.S. (1904) – Majority opinion by Day**[/li][li] **Maxwell vs. Dow (1899) – Majority opinion by Peckham**[/li][li] **Robertson vs. Baldwin (1897) – Majority opinion by Brown**[/li][li] **Brown vs. Walker (1896) – Dissenting opinion by Field**[/li][li] **Miller vs. Texas (1894) – Majority opinion by Brown**[/li][li] **Logan vs. U.S. (1892) – Majority opinion by Gray**[/li][li] **Presser vs. Illinois (1886) – Majority opinion by Woods**[/li][li] **Scott vs. Sandford (1857) – Majority opinion by Taney**[/li][li] **Houston vs. Moore (1820) – Dissenting opinion by Story**[/li][/ul]  
Lotta **bolded** cases there, eh? Hell, there’s so many, the bold text is “nearly universal.”

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Roland\_Orzabal](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/r/c2a13f/32.png) [@Roland\_Orzabal](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Roland_Orzabal)\
**Post date:** [May 4, 2004, 1:10pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/guns-freedom-and-power/243095/25 "2004-05-04T13:10:42Z")

</div>

This seems to quickly be turning into one of those GD threads I discussed in that [this much-ignored thread](http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?t=253603) in which the questionable legality of an issue is reduced to a discussion of precedent and this-case-versus-that, rather than striking at the moral heart of the issue (which appears to have been **Snakespirit** ’s original intention.

I’m not saying there’s anything wrong with citing legal precedent, and obviously it’s a necessary component of a debate along these lines. I’ve just always felt that a certain law or case ought to be referenced in terms of what it had to say about the matter, or what new insights it provided, rather than simply taking the outcome as “proof” of the correctness of a given position. For example, the Silveira case asks the question of whether the Second Amendment applies to individual rights under the Equal Protection clause. Rather than take the decision on this case to be the true answer to this question (as the Supreme Court is not the ultimate arbiter of morality, and has been known to change its collective mind from time to time), shouldn’t we instead reference the viewpoints taken by the opposing sides and consider the logic and practicality of each? Again, **Snakespirit** seems to understand what I’m talking about, as he is occassionally quoting his referenced cases in an analytical manner (and a couple of others here have done the same).

It may sound like I’m spouting too much Debate Team rhetoric here, but I honestly feel that a focus on the moral and practical standpoints on the issue, rather than a discussion of current legality, yields much more interesting and informative results. Of course, it ain’t my discussion, it ain’t my board, and I ain’t a mod, so by all means feel free to ignore the above if you see fit. It’s nothing more than my own $0.02 on that particular issue.

In regards to the OP, I personally feel that gun control is a good thing overall, but should definitely be applied with a lighter hand rather than a firm one when considering oft-disputed areas of the subject. I equal respect (read: virtually nil) for the positions of “Ban All Guns” and “End Gun Control”, but frankly, the former scenario would disturb me more. As **ElectricZ** pointed out, one original purpose of the Second Amendment was to guarantee the right of the people to protect themselves against their own government. I do not believe that the American government, at present, seeks to exert the quite that extreme an extent of control over its citizens (and clearly, a bill that called to ban all firearms would be hard-pressed to get out of committee, let alone pass). But as long as we’re dabbling in the hypothetical, let’s have a look at the opposite extremes: I am much more afraid of the possibility of living under a totalitarain regime than having each of my fellow citizens armed with assault weaponry. Everyday nutjobs having easy and legal access to Uzis is certainly a frightening thought, but compare that to the possibility of living under something akin to the former Soviet Union, where dissent against the government is considered just cause for death at the hands of a trained force of soliders (who, conveniently enough, also happen to have all the guns). Now ask yourself which of these scenarios you’re more willing to approach. This should give you some idea of where on the spectrum you stand. As for me, I’ll be standing over by the former side, trying to convince the guy down the street to drop his AK-47, but also damned glad for the right to hold my little Colt .22.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![minty\_green](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/m/f6c823/32.png) [@minty\_green](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/minty_green)\
**Post date:** [May 4, 2004, 2:11pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/guns-freedom-and-power/243095/26 "2004-05-04T14:11:12Z")

</div>

None of those Supreme Court cases adopt the individual rights interpretation, UncleBeer. It is legally meaningless to claim that they “support” the individual rights view unless they _hold_ that it is an individual right. They do not so hold. I mean, really, you’re citing _Planned Parenthood v. Casey_? It’s an ABORTION case, not the Second Amendment!

Please also note that all those concurring and dissenting opinions you cite are the positions that _lost_ at the Supreme Court. As such, they don’t support much of anything, except the individual positions of the justices who signed onto them.

Another relevant quote from _Emerson_: “Only in _United States v. Miller_ has the Supreme Court rendered any holding respecting the Second Amendment as applied to the federal government.” That point ought to make it pretty clear why I refer folks to the Courts of Appeals–there just isn’t much out of the Supreme Court on the subject of the Second Amendment. When there is, I happily acknowledge it.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![minty\_green](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/m/f6c823/32.png) [@minty\_green](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/minty_green)\
**Post date:** [May 4, 2004, 2:15pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/guns-freedom-and-power/243095/27 "2004-05-04T14:15:58Z")

</div>

> [@Roland Orzabal](#):
>
> I’m not saying there’s anything wrong with citing legal precedent, and obviously it’s a necessary component of a debate along these lines. I’ve just always felt that a certain law or case ought to be referenced in terms of what it had to say about the matter, or what new insights it provided, rather than simply taking the outcome as “proof” of the correctness of a given position.

I do not cite those cases as “proof of the correctness” of the collective rights interpretation. I cite them as proof of what the law _is_, not what it _should be_. The distinction is important.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![BrainGlutton](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/b/82dd89/32.png) [@BrainGlutton](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/BrainGlutton)\
**Post date:** [May 4, 2004, 6:39pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/guns-freedom-and-power/243095/28 "2004-05-04T18:39:43Z")

</div>

> [@ElectricZ](#):
>
> I originally posted this on another thread (that I think someone else mentioned that had been reduced to a shouting match) but I think it applies here, so pardon me if this is a rerun!
> 
> The ultimate reason behind the 2nd Amendment
> 
> * * *
> 
> This is a post that has nothing to do with “more people are killed in the US by guns than the world combined” or "they can have my gun when they pry it from my cold dead fingers. There are no statistics, and no cites. Just my thoughts about the Constitution and the rights it protects.
> 
> [soapbox] The 2nd Amendment is a written guarantee by the Federal Government of the United States that it will not take away the citizens’ right to protect themselves. Simple as that. The founding fathers knew nothing of assault weapons or homicide rates that would come 200 years later, and it doesn’t matter one little bit. Nor is the lack of Indians, wild bears, or any other 18th century threat a factor.
> 
> Why? Because the gun crime that IS the issue here is a violent act between individual citizens, and not between the the body of citizens called “the people” and the body known as the Federal Government.
> 
> The Bill of Rights is about protecting “the people” against the government, not from each other. The government can not to tell you what to say, what to believe, imprison you without due process, or any other personal freedom. It’s a contract, a written guarantee, that those things can’t happen, at least not legally. (Even though it does happen, it gives the citizens and the courts a basis from which to argue against it when it does.)
> 
> This is not paranoid delusion – protection from the government is exactly what the founding fathers had in mind, because they WERE the government. They knew exactly how corrupt and oppressive people could be when given power over other people. They knew that unarmed people were at the mercy of people who had weapons, and that throughout history it was always the government who had force on their side. So they put it in black and white that the Federal Government was going to give the power to the citizens instead of the other way around. The idea that guns in the hand of private citizens won’t be able to stand up to the forces of the federal government wasn’t an issue. The 2nd Amendment, in fact, ALL of the amendments in the Bill of Rights are a guarantee that scenario will never come to pass.
> 
> I realize that this entire post does nothing to solve the problems of gun crimes and the ridiculously high numbers of shooting deaths and injuries in the United States. It’s just to point out that repealing the 2nd Amendment is not the answer. You should NOT alter the Bill of Rights because the citizens can’t behave toward each other.
> 
> Otherwise, you should avoid the middleman and demand a Constitutional amendment against murder.
> 
> Please don’t mess with the Constitution. It’s not the solution.  
> [/soapbox]
> 
> Thanks for reading my high-minded, long-winded theory on Constitutional law!
> 
> EZ

😕 :rolleyes: :eek: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad:

What you are talking about, **ElectricZ,** is what has been called the “insurrectionary theory” of the Second Amendment. In essence, you are not saying (as gun-rights advocates often do), "I need a gun, so I can defend myself, my family and my property, because I do not trust the police to do that job for me adequately. What you are saying is, “I need a gun, so I can shoot the police (and/or the FBI, National Guard, U.S. Army) if it should become necessary in my judgment.” Now will you just **think seriously for five minutes** about the implications and results of armed citizens using, or even threatening to use, their weapons on agents of the government? No, sir, the “insurrectionary theory” of the Second Amendment is **completely indefensible** on any grounds – practical, ethical, theoretical, or historical. We’ve already had a GD thread on this: “Is the Second Amendment meant to facilitate armed rebellion?” – [http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?t=201061](http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?t=201061)

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![SnakeSpirit](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/snakespirit/32/7271_2.png) [@SnakeSpirit](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/SnakeSpirit)\
**Post date:** [May 4, 2004, 7:26pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/guns-freedom-and-power/243095/29 "2004-05-04T19:26:52Z")

</div>

> [@minty green](#):
>
> Dude, I have told you twice already that _Emerson_, the case you just quoted, is the sole U.S. Court of Appeals case adopting the individual rights interpretation. It is the case that makes the collective rights model the “nearly universal” judicial interpretation, not wholly “universal.”

Yes, I noticed.  
So, you’re the final authority? Or is this just your position and someone else, a lawyer (or another lawyer, if you are a lawyer - I don’t want to offend), may find differently?

I’ve already told you three times that “universal” is an absolute and to modify it with ‘almost’ or even ‘nearly’ is meaningless.

But I don’t want to squabble. I’d rather stick to reasonable debate. I’ll only correct your English when it effects the tone or meaning of your post.

How about if I agree that the “majority” of decisions hold the 2nd amendment to be a collective right and you agree that modifying absolute terms is meaningless? 🙂

You’re a legal person, I’m an English person. Lawyers may not always speak common English, and English professors don’t do law.

I want your substantive debate here; I welcome it.

And yes, Peace.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![SnakeSpirit](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/snakespirit/32/7271_2.png) [@SnakeSpirit](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/SnakeSpirit)\
**Post date:** [May 4, 2004, 7:32pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/guns-freedom-and-power/243095/30 "2004-05-04T19:32:30Z")

</div>

> [@UncleBeer](#):
>
> Hell, there’s so many, the bold text is _ **“nearly universal.”** _

:eek: Arrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrgggggggggggggggggggghhhhhhhhhhhhh!

Seriously, thanks for all the data. It sure looks like a LOT of work, and is appreciated.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![akennett](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/a/ee59a6/32.png) [@akennett](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/akennett)\
**Post date:** [May 4, 2004, 7:42pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/guns-freedom-and-power/243095/31 "2004-05-04T19:42:01Z")

</div>

> [@BrainGlutton](#):
>
> No, sir, the “insurrectionary theory” of the Second Amendment is **completely indefensible** on any grounds – practical, ethical, theoretical, or historical.

I’ll leave the first three alone(though I have no problm debating them) and focus solely on the historical.

What do you think was happening at Lexington and Concord back in the good ol’ days? Seems to me it was a bunch of normal folk, taking arms against the forces of a government that they felt had become oppressive. That sounds quite like the “insurrectionary theory” to me.

Would the words of Thomas Jefferson, Supreme Court Justice Joseph Story, and Abraham Lincoln, among others, be enough to convince you that this very surely was one of the reasons to allow for firearms ownership?

> [@](#):
>
> We’ve already had a GD thread on this

Oh, well I guess that completely settles the question then. :rolleyes:

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![SnakeSpirit](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/snakespirit/32/7271_2.png) [@SnakeSpirit](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/SnakeSpirit)\
**Post date:** [May 4, 2004, 7:49pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/guns-freedom-and-power/243095/32 "2004-05-04T19:49:07Z")

</div>

> [@Roland Orzabal](#):
>
> This seems to quickly be turning into one of those GD threads I discussed in that [this much-ignored thread](http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?t=253603) in which the questionable legality of an issue is reduced to a discussion of precedent and this-case-versus-that, rather than striking at the moral heart of the issue (which appears to have been **Snakespirit** ’s original intention.

Bringing a thread to a shouting match or “I’m right, you’re wrong and I won’t listen” is one way that a poster who doesn’t want a certain debate to take place can destroy a thread. I fully expect that somewhere along the way some anti-2nd-Amendment poster will try to do that to this thread. I don’t think minty green is trying to do this, btw.

> [@Roland Orzabal](#):
>
> It may sound like I’m spouting too much Debate Team rhetoric here, but I honestly feel that a focus on the moral and practical standpoints on the issue, rather than a discussion of current legality, yields much more interesting and informative results. Of course, it ain’t my discussion, it ain’t my board, and I ain’t a mod, so by all means feel free to ignore the above if you see fit. It’s nothing more than my own $0.02 on that particular issue.

I disagree on one point, Roland, it’s your board as much as you want it to be, as it is anyone else’s. I deliberately started this open-ended in order to engender more of an open debate.

Thanks for the input; I feel you brought up some good points.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![minty\_green](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/m/f6c823/32.png) [@minty\_green](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/minty_green)\
**Post date:** [May 4, 2004, 8:50pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/guns-freedom-and-power/243095/33 "2004-05-04T20:50:39Z")

</div>

> [@Snakespirit](#):
>
> So, you’re the final authority?

No, the cases I cited are the “final authority,” at least as to the question of what the state of the law is. They say what they say, and that is as I have represented it to be. If you contend otherwise, you should prove it by providing the case law that says otherwise. Otherwise [Michael Palin] this isn’t even an argument [/Michael Palin].

> [@](#):
>
> How about if I agree that the “majority” of decisions hold the 2nd amendment to be a collective right . . . ?

No. 8 circuits to 1 is not simply a “majority.” Maybe “overwhelming majority,” if you would prefer that description.

> [@](#):
>
> You’re a legal person, I’m an English person. Lawyers may not always speak common English, and English professors don’t do law.

Wrong again. I hold a graduate degree in English and taught writing and literature as an instructor at a state university for several years before becoming a lawyer. There’s nothing magic about either profession that precludes discussion of the relevant issues in this thread.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![ElectricZ](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/e/58f4c7/32.png) [@ElectricZ](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/ElectricZ)\
**Post date:** [May 4, 2004, 9:46pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/guns-freedom-and-power/243095/34 "2004-05-04T21:46:31Z")

</div>

> [@BrainGlutton](#):
>
> 😕 :rolleyes: :eek: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad:  
> What you are saying is, “I need a gun, so I can shoot the police (and/or the FBI, National Guard, U.S. Army) if it should become necessary in my judgment.” Now will you just **think seriously for five minutes** about the implications and results of armed citizens using, or even threatening to use, their weapons on agents of the government?

Actually, I didn’t say that anywhere in my post. It’s just a few posts above this one, if you need a cite. What am I saying? You quoted my whole post – but I don’t think you actually read the whole thing.

So let me quote myself:

> [@ElectricZ](#):
>
> the gun crime that IS the issue here is a violent act between individual citizens, and not between the the body of citizens called “the people” and the body known as the Federal Government.

So here is what I am saying: The laws governing the citizens, those of the criminal justice system, are what need to be changed. The law restricting the government, the 2nd Amendment, does not. The Bill of Rights is about what the government CAN’T do.

As for the “insurrectionary theory” and your request that I “ **think seriously for five minutes** about the implications and results of armed citizens using, or even threatening to use, their weapons on agents of the government?” once again I have to requote myself:

> [@ElectricZ](#):
>
> The idea that guns in the hand of private citizens won’t be able to stand up to the forces of the federal government wasn’t an issue. The 2nd Amendment, in fact, ALL of the amendments in the Bill of Rights are a guarantee that scenario will never come to pass.

There it is, in plain, unedited text, what I am really saying. The federal government is bloated, inefficient, schizophrenic, self serving, scheming, sometimes even beneficial, and constantly swinging from the left to the right as politicians come and go. But no matter who is at the helm we have a signed contract that tells them what their limits are. (Even if some administrations like to try little end-runs around the Constitution. ::coughPATRIOTACTcough:: )

I don’t own a gun. If I thought I needed one, I’d get one. But it would be to protect myself from my fellow citizens and not the government. Maybe the answer is for everybody in the country to sign a written contract declaring they violate each other’s rights.

So, Brainglutton, would you please tell me where in my post I demand the right to shoot policemen? You put a tinfoil hat on my head. I ask politely that you please remove it.

EZ

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Filli](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/f/77aa72/32.png) [@Filli](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Filli)\
**Post date:** [May 4, 2004, 10:25pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/guns-freedom-and-power/243095/35 "2004-05-04T22:25:56Z")

</div>

Apologies for dropping in this way. A colleague recommended I check this out for my work in civil rights… I don’t think so, but it sure looks like fun! Wish I had more time to play, this is a fascinating website.

Nice “thread” - discussion - whatever, but it sure has a long way to go. I recommend stating an opinion, dropping it and moving on. You are not going to _prove_ anything here. It’s an exercise in… well, personal aggrandizement? State your point, argument, whatever, move on. So what if someone disagrees?

Minty, you are particularly interesting. If you are ever seeking another position, drop me an e-mail. Although you do seem a bit vehement, you sure can argue! I’ll bet you’re even better in issues where you don’t have a personal stake! (Your bias is showing.)

And shame on you for misleading these people! You know case law and even Supreme Court decisions prove nothing, ultimately, except the outcome of the case at hand.

Which is why I’m involved with the new Congressional 2nd Amendment Caucus, so that arguments such as these shall become moot.  
Please visit us at [http://wwwc.house.gov/musgrave/108th%20Web/pr\_040426\_2ndAmendmentCaucus.htm](http://wwwc.house.gov/musgrave/108th%20Web/pr_040426_2ndAmendmentCaucus.htm)

Frankly, Snakespirit, I think you are a hopeless idealist. (Idealist isn’t an absolute, though ideal is.) You remind me of someone who was very dear to me. He didn’t get very far in life, personally, but he did touch, and even change, lots of other people. Unsolicited advice: Give it up. It’s not worth it.

I won’t be back, too busy, but feel free to contact me by email if you wish.

Filli

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![minty\_green](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/m/f6c823/32.png) [@minty\_green](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/minty_green)\
**Post date:** [May 4, 2004, 11:08pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/guns-freedom-and-power/243095/36 "2004-05-04T23:08:08Z")

</div>

> [@Filli](#):
>
> I recommend stating an opinion, dropping it and moving on. You are not going to _prove_ anything here. It’s an exercise in… well, personal aggrandizement? State your point, argument, whatever, move on. So what if someone disagrees?

Umm, you are aware that this forum is called “Great Debates,” right? We do have a forum for stating an opinion and moving on. It’s called “IMHO,” which is short for “In My Humble Opinion.” If you are displeased that people are actually trying to convince each other of the correctness of their opinions, IMHO may just be the place for you.

> [@](#):
>
> Minty, you are particularly interesting.

I prefer “fascinating,” but thank you. 🆒

> [@](#):
>
> Although you do seem a bit vehement, you sure can argue! I’ll bet you’re even better in issues where you don’t have a personal stake! (Your bias is showing.)

What bias would that be? In point of fact, my _personal_ interpretation of the Second Amendment is an individual rights view, not collective rights. I personally am a gun owner. I personally support private ownership of firearms, albeit with certain restrictions. If I have a bias, it is a bias against misstatements of the law, which is not exactly something I would consider a fault.

> [@](#):
>
> And shame on you for misleading these people! You know case law and even Supreme Court decisions prove nothing, ultimately, except the outcome of the case at hand.

Nonsense. Case law is precedent, and when precedent is applicable to a future case, it controls the outcome of that case. If you try to claim that you have an individual right to bear arms under the Second Amendment in (for example) a federal court in Florida, that court will simply apply the binding precedent of _U.S. v. Wright_ and rule that you have no such right.

> [@](#):
>
> I won’t be back, too busy, but feel free to contact me by email if you wish.

Hey, come back here and argue! I demand that you defend your position! 😉

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![BrainGlutton](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/b/82dd89/32.png) [@BrainGlutton](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/BrainGlutton)\
**Post date:** [May 4, 2004, 11:31pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/guns-freedom-and-power/243095/37 "2004-05-04T23:31:17Z")

</div>

> [@akennett](#):
>
> What do you think was happening at Lexington and Concord back in the good ol’ days? Seems to me it was a bunch of normal folk, taking arms against the forces of a government that they felt had become oppressive. That sounds quite like the “insurrectionary theory” to me.

Just because the United States owed its independence to an insurrection does not mean that the United States Constitution should be construed so as to authorize insurrection, in any sense, under any circumstances. See Article I, Section 9: “The Privilege of the Writ of Habeas Corpus shall not be suspended, unless when in Cases of **Rebellion** or Invasion the public Safety may require it.” Bear in mind, when the Continental Congress published the Declaration of Independence in 1776, it was intended as a radical document, a statement of revolutionary principles. But when the Framers attended the Constitutional Convention in 1787, they were drafting a blueprint for a political system that was intended to last indefinitely. “The Constitution is not a suicide pact,” etc.

Furthermore, the “insurrectionary theory” of the Second Amendment depends on the assumption that the “well-regulated militia” is intended to be, not an arm of the state, but a countervailing popular force against the state – or else a force of the state governments against the federal. There is no contemporary historical evidence that the first version is what the drafters of the Bill of Rights had in mind. And any argument based on the second version is very much a dead letter ever since 1865, and rightly so.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![BrainGlutton](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/b/82dd89/32.png) [@BrainGlutton](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/BrainGlutton)\
**Post date:** [May 4, 2004, 11:36pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/guns-freedom-and-power/243095/38 "2004-05-04T23:36:30Z")

</div>

> [@ElectricZ](#):
>
> So, Brainglutton, would you please tell me where in my post I demand the right to shoot policemen? You put a tinfoil hat on my head. I ask politely that you please remove it.
> 
> EZ

No, **ElectricZ.** The tinfoil hat fits you. Wear it. When you say that “The 2nd Amendment is a written guarantee by the Federal Government of the United States that it will not take away the citizens’ right to protect themselves”; and you also say, “The Bill of Rights is about protecting ‘the people’ against the government, not from each other”; and when you say both of these things in the context of discussing the Second Amendment; then there is no other logical conclusion than that you are claiming the right (or at least, a constitutionally protected opportunity) to shoot the police, etc. How **else** can arms be used to protect “the people” from “the government” and “not from each other”?

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![silenus](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/silenus/32/166_2.png) [@silenus](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/silenus)\
**Post date:** [May 4, 2004, 11:46pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/guns-freedom-and-power/243095/39 "2004-05-04T23:46:28Z")

</div>

Just dropped in to see how this thread was developing, as the “other one” collapsed under total pig-headedness. Good arguments developing here. But **Snakespirit** , as a hard-core, “from my cold dead fingers” gun owner… **minty** is cleaning your clock, mainly because he is right. (Don’t you just _hate_ it when that happens.) Case law, as it exists, is almost entirely on the “collective” side. That doesn’t mean it is _right._ Just that it is.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![enipla](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/e/54ee81/32.png) [@enipla](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/enipla)\
**Post date:** [May 5, 2004, 12:29am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/guns-freedom-and-power/243095/40 "2004-05-05T00:29:26Z")

</div>

So -

What would the folks that recommend more gun control suggest for the vast, vast majority of gun owners (the law abiding owners)do?

Most gun owners are law abiding, careful, and own their guns for many different reasons. Be it recreation, hunting self defense or collecting.

I own seven guns. Recreation and self defense are my reasons. Every one was handed down to me from my family. Except one. One was a gift.

Should I just give them up? Give away a few thousand dollars of my familys history?

[Previous page](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/guns-freedom-and-power/243095.md?page=1)

[Next page](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/guns-freedom-and-power/243095.md?page=3)
