Have you forgiven someone for a major transgression against you?

Forgive the novel. This is a topic I’m working through.

My father carried resentments forever and would always trout out his laundry list of grievances against any and all. I remember once when I was 16 or 17, and he was telling me something terrible my mother had done, from before they were married. I was the forth child, so it had been a long time.

I learned that lesson well. I used to spend forever reciting terrible things which had happened to me. Coming from an abusive household, you can collect a large number of them.

After wrecking our family, my father passed away years ago. Three out of the five of us have really serious psychological issues as a consequence. At least four of us have had suicidal idealizations, if not outright attempts. One brother is a bipolar who doesn’t take medication. He’s homeless and can’t work. A sister is on disability for her condition.

Finally, after decades and decades of anger against all of the people who’ve done me wrong, I’m starting to be able to let go. It’s been 30 years since my father died, and now I’m finally able to look back without the anger. I don’t know what I would do if he were still alive, but at least I’m now able to think about it without the rush of overwhelming emotions. He was a really sick man, and I’m glad I don’t have to make the decision about letting my kids have a relationship with him or not.

My mother was unable to protect us from my father. She was a battered wife and remains a victim. It had been difficult to let go of both the feelings of needing to be her savior and also resentment for her role. I am able to feel more objective now.

My older brother sexually molested me when we were young. That really, really bothered me for years. I confronted him once, and he was unable to provide a straightforward apology. He babbled on and on about how much the guilt had hurt him over the years. When I brought up that his speech didn’t include any apology for me, he said that he was sorry “terrible things had happened to you” without taking responsibility for it himself. He had cut us out of his life for years and was trying to come back. I returned the favor and grew increasingly resentful.

Finally, I’ve been able to see how much that was poisoning me. I can look back now at that with a detached view, without wishing harm on him. Again, as I’m on this side of the world, I don’t need to worry about him, so I don’t know how much I’ve “forgiven” him. I’ve made peace in that he was also a child of our household, and wasn’t able to do any better.

My younger brother, the homeless one, said some really hurtful things, including that I had killed my son through my actions. I had to cut him out of my life, and any thoughts of him would stir up a ton of anger. I’ve finally let that go as well. He was simply sick and wasn’t really responsible for his thoughts. I can forgive him of it.

However, like many other people have said, I can’t really forget in that I’m unable to put myself into a vulnerable position with him. He’s not in treatment and could lash out again. I don’t have the capacity to deal with him.

I forgive. Sometimes it’s not easy and I have to actively try hard, to do so. It’s still worth it to me.

I was traumatically victimized by events when I was younger. I was left somewhat shattered, filled with righteous rage and not yet an adult even! I found I could not manage an entire lifetime, stretched out before me, filled with rage- no matter how righteous it might be.

I intuitively felt my mental health somewhat hinged on me moving past these events. I found it impossible to put these events truly behind me, without full forgiveness.

My life is definitely better for choosing forgiveness. There is a lot of awesome that would never have come into my life had I clung tightly to my righteous angry, bitter, hurt.

It is foolish, however, to forget, or so I humbly submit. I won’t hold grudges, but I won’t set myself up to be hurt again either.

My parents had me immediately after an extreme trauma, and when young I had what was probably autism(I did not speak regularly until age 6) and my father made his extreme anger and disappointment in having such a weird son clear.

They abandoned me in a mental hospital as a young kid, they made it clear that was why. They also lied and tricked me and abandoned me, and then picked me up a week later only because their insurance refused to pay and they could not afford it out of pocket.

My mom told me all the time my entire life she should have had an abortion like her doctor advised her to due to her age, after all look how I turned out. My father also emotionally abused me, it continued until I cut ties. My dad planned to commit suicide when I was 8 after blowing his retirement fund on casino gambling, when asked by someone else what he expected his son to do he said “what do I care, I’ll be dead lol”. My mom blew much more money on hoarding but couldn’t spend any on me, I first went to the dentist as an adult paying for it myself.

I don’t know if I can forgive them, my father was so NASTY to me with his only excuse being life didn’t treat him 100% like he felt he deserved. My mom I realize now was no where near mentally competent, but she still made no effort to be a loving parent.

The last conversation I had with my mom before her death, she told me I had never done ANYTHING to be proud of.

So yea I can’t bring myself to forgive two dead people, but I feel there is good in it because I would never repeat their perhaps maliciousness perhaps mistakes.

EDIT:I doubt now my mom mentioned abortion to be hurtful, she just honestly had no idea what human emotions were or what empathy was. When I asked her if she missed my dead father she said oh I have so much free time now that I don’t have to do things for him.

Although it seems insignificant in comparison to some of the other stories here, when they were both unemployed I bought a voucher for my sister and mother to enjoy a day out together eating cheese and drinking wine at a venue by the beach. I thought it would lift their spirits.

They never used the voucher and flat out lied to me and said they did. I never received a decent explanation and still don’t really know why they did it. It still hurts my feelings when I think about it.

I have forgiven a lot of major transgressions by those I love. I’m not a grudge holder at all, but these were such huge things that it surprised me that I could forgive. I’m not good at forgiving those who transgress against the ones I love.

grude, reading this, my heart hurt for you. The fact that you will not repeat their maliciousness and mistakes is something you should be extremely proud of.

When we say “forgiveness” we don’t really mean “Start thinking that everything they did was all right.”

It’s more like “My parents were not kind people, on the contrary, they were downright evil. Whether it was circumstances or just plain old maliciousness that made them like that, I can’t say. But I am not responsible for their cruelty and I will not hold it to my chest and make myself bitter.”

I’m not saying it works 100% either. I still feel bitter over my mother sometimes. I just remind myself she’s dead and she can’t hurt me anymore, and in the end it was just ignorance and sadness that made her what she was (she was not a happy woman). I consider myself lucky I am happier than her and I try to move on.

I am sorry to hear about your parents, but you do have reason to be proud of yourself.

(I know this is a hijack, but…This whole post, btw, is why I LAUGH loudly whenever people say gay people are not fit parents. Um, they can’t fuck up their kids anymore than plenty of straight people have, can they?)

I’m sorry, I wasn’t very clear. When I say that I forget, it’s more of the “don’t dwell on it” variety. For example, there’s no longer any reason (and hasn’t been in forever) to think about what my step-brother did. I acknowledge what happened and I don’t have anything to do with him, but he takes up absolutely zilch space in any of my life. I hope that explains my stance better.

I haven’t forgiven.

My fiancée was killed by a drunk driver. He had several prior DUI’s. He was out on a bender celebrating his release from jail for a prior offence. It was clear that alcohol was correlated with a series of violations of the law and bad choices throughout his life.

My fiancee’s family and I asked that he enter an alcohol treatment program while incarcerated. That suggestion seemed to fall on deaf ears.

With no repentance and not even an attempt to face his demons, I cannot forgive. I can, and did, move on.

Iggy, drunk driver guy sounds like a suitable candidate for an unfortunate accident. Such an evil asshole would be impossible to forgive.

Maybe I overstated my case. I expect I would have the restraint to not get medieval on a perp’s ass right after the transgression. But I would aggressively pursue the maximum penalty/remuneration allowable by law (e.g. jail time + a civil judgment).

If a texting/drunk driver killed a member of my family, I don’t imagine I would ever write a friendly letter to him saying I hope he’s doing well.

This is a hard one for me to answer. I’ve been considering how to respond since it was posted.

I like to think I’m pretty great at empathy. The closer someone is to me the easier they are to understand. I get why people do the things they do, whether I’m a fan of their actions or not. So in a sense I guess I am able to forgive just about anything since I can see it from the transgressor’s point of view.

Initially I was going to say “I can, and have, put up with a lot, but I have a limit.” but the more I think about it the more I think that’s not really the case. What I have is a break point. It’s like I try so hard to see the good in everyone, and I keep it up and keep it up, until finally they do or say the special magic thing that erases the benefit of doubt, where I figure out that they are just not going to get it when it comes to not being hurtful. Then, that’s pretty much it. The switch gets flipped and I completely stop giving a shit. Forgiveness doesn’t play into it, because at that point they’re not part of my life anymore.