[QUOTE=KarlGauss]
Sorry for the delay. Busy times . . .
At the risk of sounding cliched and evasive, I think it’s the case that to a very large extent the mechansims underlying weight maintenance are still pretty much of a mystery.
Some facts seem beyond debate (eg. If calories absorbed > calories used ==> weight gain ensues, and vice versa). But even such a simple, self-evident statement can lead to trouble if/when we don’t understand just how calories are “used” and what controls the rate of that use.
For example, the act of weight loss itself, sets into motion a poorly understood phenomenon whereby it begins to take fewer calories to maintain basal metabolic rate and function than it did before the weight loss. Phrased differently, and what many dieters will tell you, is that the body becomes more “efficient” with weight loss. It gets progressively harder to lose weight.
One can imagine a scenario, possibly on a genetic basis, wherein some people are more “efficient” than others even before they’ve lost weight.
I use the quotation marks around ‘efficient’ for good reason. No one knows exactly what it means for your body to be more or less “efficient”. Or, more specifically, the biochemical and bioenergetic mechansims are not at all well characterized.
Although not really relevant to your question, I’ll use this chance to point out a couple of the changes that occur early on in the course of weight loss:
- you become more sensitive to insulin (hence fat and sugar are more easily stored)
- certain enzymes in your fat tissues (eg. lipoprotein lipase) become more active (again, tending to promote fat storage)
- as mentioned above, the number of calories per kilogram of body weight needed to maintain basal metabolic rate diminishes (i.e. your body does the same stuff with less fuel)
- your taste preference changes (eg. in blinded testing where people can only taste but not see or smell what they’re eating, weight loss leads to a preference for fattier foods. Apparently we’re hard-wired to seek out high calorie food when we’re starving)
On rereading, I’m not too surprised to see that I really didn’t answer your questions. While it most certainly could be a function of my ignorance about such things, I think it’s also the case that we just don’t know very much about weight maintenance, appetite, etc.
[/QUOTE]
Could you please repeat this wonderful post in every discussion about weight loss? I am so tired of the “fatties just eat too much” over-simplified BS. Even more, I hate the fact that when I try (as a non-MD) to explain that it is more complicated, I get “oh, that’s just an excuse.” I have PCOS/insulin resistance (my insulin levels have be up to 51, which impressed even my endocrinologist), and I think of it as the medical problems make it easier for me to gain and harder for me to lose, BUT it is still up to me to do my best to lose weight. It is harder, and I want some respect and even sympathy for that, but that doesn’t absolve me of responsibility.
Sorry for the hijack, but I really wanted to thank you, KarlGauss.