Huge ONE-DAY spike in electric bill

The original electrical meters had a spinning disk that turned other disks and recorded how much current you used. That wasn’t entirely fair though since the voltage can vary a bit, and power is voltage multiplied by current. I doubt that there are very few single coil electrical meters still in use, but who knows. These meters would have been made back in the 1920s or 1930s or so.

To make it more fair, they went to two-coil meters. These meters have a coil that measures the current and another coil that measures the voltage, and both of these combined spin the disk so that the disk turns are proportional to the power and not just the current. If you have a mechanical meter, this is almost certainly what you have.

As noted, all you get with this type of meter is a total.

The newer “smart” meters still have the two coils, but instead of using them to electromagnetically spin a disk, each coil is fed into an A/D converter to digitize them. This allows the smart meter to measure and track a whole bunch of stuff that the mechanical meter can’t measure. For example, they can measure and track your power factor. Power is made up of watts and vars. Most people have heard of watts but not vars, because the power company only charges you for the watts. Vars are energy that is used to charge up devices like inductors and capacitors. Motors are inductive, so residential service tends to be slightly inductive due to things like washing machine motors, vacuum cleaners, refrigerator compressor motors, etc. Tracking the vars allows the power company to more precisely calculate how much capacitance they have to add at the substation to balance out the inductive vars to make the system more efficient (I can explain this a lot better if anyone is interested, but the basic point is that there’s a huge efficiency bonus for the power system if you keep the inductive and capacitive vars balanced). If your capacitive and inductive vars are all perfectly balanced, your power factor is 1. Anything less than 1 means your vars aren’t balanced and the system is running at less than peak efficiency.

As a side note, while residential service usually isn’t charged for vars, business and industrial users are charged out the wazoo for vars. That gives them a huge financial incentive to install their own power factor correction devices.

In addition to monitoring vars for efficiency, they can also measure and track the voltage to make sure that it stays within spec. Any sagging on the voltage can also warn them that the branch is getting close to being overloaded and they may need to add more capacity. Distortion of the voltage sine wave can also indicate problems, and the meters can track certain types of spikes and brownouts as well. This allows the power company to find and fix potential problems before they become bigger problems.

Since all of the data is digital, everything can be tracked like any other type of digital data. Some folks have privacy concerns about this since the power company can probably figure out when you’re awake, when you’re asleep, and when everyone is away at work and the house is probably empty.

The smart meters all talk to each other by sending communication data over the power lines, and basically forward data from one meter to the next all the way down the line until it gets back to the power company. The meters store a certain amount of data within the meter, but the important stuff (or at least what the power company thinks is important) is sent back to the main office where it gets tracked in regular ordinary computers.

BTW, I just looked up the specs for a random power meter and this is what it measures:

Instantaneous watts
Instantaneous vars
Total watts
Total vars
Voltage
Current
Power Factor
Maximum demand of watts
Maximum demand of vars
Magnetic tampering
Meter cover removal
Power disconnection
Energy inverse (customer is providing energy instead of consuming it - normal if you have solar panels or your own generator)
Meter disconnection due to remote command
Meter disconnection due to overload
Meter reprogramming
Meter time and date change
Meter access with correct password
Meter attempted access with incorrect password
Firmware revision
Measurement interval
32 daily measurements of all data
8 daily divisions of all data
Meter Status
Meter Configuration

For most of these (the electrical stuff, not the tampering stuff), it measures both line 1 and line 2 as well as the total. Residential service typically comes from a split phase transformer, so you have two hot lines and one neutral. Your 240 volt appliances are connected from one line to the other. Your 120 volt circuits go from either line to neutral, and are balanced so that half of them are on line 1 and half of them are on line 2.

For comparison, your typical spinning disk meter measures total power of line 1 and line 2 combined, and that’s it.

We’re talking about 42 kilowatts average throughout the day on 8/11. That’s four arc welders running max power, 100% duty cycle, for 24 hours. That’s not a hobby, that’s a passion.

Or 30 microwave ovens, or 420 100-watt light bulbs.

[QUOTE=engineer_comp_geek]

Since all of the data is digital, everything can be tracked like any other type of digital data. Some folks have privacy concerns about this since the power company can probably figure out when you’re awake, when you’re asleep, and when everyone is away at work and the house is probably empty.
[/QUOTE]

No “probably” about it. About two years ago, I was looking into my usage, and the analyst at the poco could tell with eerie accuracy when we wake up, leave for work, get home, how we cook dinner, and go to bed.

Via their website, I can see graph of kWh vs time, and sure enough, usage is coasting along at baseline until a sharp spike at 7:00 when the coffeemaker starts. At the other end of the day, a couple of short usage spikes vs a prolonged high usage reveals using the microwave vs electric oven.

I just registered an online account with my utility company and looked back at my daily usage records.

Since February of this year, there are 2 to 4 days every month where the DAILY USAGE reads almost almost 99,000. Figures like 98,785, and 98,924, etc.

HOW DO THESE PEOPLE NOT KNOW THERE’S A PROBLEM WITH THIS METER? Yes, I’m angry, but I’m also serious. How can they not know it needs to be replaced?

Back in June I got a bill with no amount due, plus about $27 credit for the next month. It seems like they are aware of a problem and gave me a big credit for the overage in their readings. But REALLY?

My home is only 1,280 square feet. Certainly no mansion. And my electrical panel is 200 amp. Each month there are many days where the reading is over 100 usage. I haven’t gone over the usage charts thoroughly yet, but from a cursory glance it mostly seems to be cold/hot days where furnace/aircon is running.

I’m going to look over the daily usage charts more closely, but it seems that I have a VERY legitimate gripe with these folks.

Thanks again for all your help and information. Feel free to comment further!

You might also want to check with some of your neighbors, to see if they’re having similar problems (and if they are, if they’re happening on the same days). It’s probably a problem with the meter itself, but if it’s somewhere else in the system, it might be affecting others, too.

Weird … a neighbor showed me his bill for 8 days usage and it was 1 MW/hr … he’s calling about it … weirder, it was exactly 1 MW/hr … the graph on the bill showed usage a/a 750kW/hr in the depths of winter for a month … maybe this is how the aliens are attacking us …

I once had a place with a mechanical meter. When I moved out, I was hit with a ridiculously large power bill — something like 1000 kWh larger than it should have been. It turned out that the guy who had read the meter had gotten confused and read the largest digit wrong, since the dials on old-style mechanical meters run in opposite directions. In other words, the needle for the ones digit runs clockwise, the tens digit runs counter-clockwise, the hundreds digit runs clockwise, etc. The meter reader had apparently thought that since the needle was a bit more clockwise from “3”, that digit should be a 3; when really, they should have interpreted it as “a bit more counter-clockwise from 2” instead.

This probably doesn’t apply to your case (unless someone is coming out to your house and reading the meter daily), but I figured I’d share the story anyhow in case someone with a similar problem happens upon this thread.

Not sure if it applies to this data set, but if you’re looking to expose potentially made-up numbers, Benford’s Law might be your friend.

If anyone still has an interest in this thread, I thought I’d point out a pattern I’ve found from the utility’s reports of my daily usage:

On any day that has usage of over 1,000 kWh, it is followed by a next-day readout of almost 99,000 kWh. By adding those two days’ usage and eliminating the leading number, I believe the utility is adjusting for the anomalous reading.

Example:
July 12 reading: 1,173
July 13 reading: 98,919

Add the two readings, and you get 100,092

Delete the leading “1”, and you get 92. And since it uses a day to put in the adjustment, perhaps the 92 represents the usage for both days, July 12 AND 13.

I’ll iron this out with the utility company tomorrow, but I thought I’d add this in case anyone was interested.

It just keeps getting more bizarre doesn’t it.

Dennis

I’m visualizing a glitch that starts the count from 100k and goes down, following the day that goes over 1,000. Logic error, programming error, processing error. You are in touch with them about this, right?

I agree with this post, didnt look around to see if it has been answered.

But my grocery store operates 12 doors of cool, 8 doors of frozen, 2 large produce bunkers, 1 8x16 cooler, 1 8x14 freezer.

Plus lights, air conditioning, and some other minor things.

We draw around 800kWH per day.

So unless your running a medium sized grocery store out of your house, 1022 is impossible.

Hey, priority - any update on this?