If the Confederacy Had Taken Back Chattanooga in 1863 (a McCain/Obama free thread)

Well, to hell with Chattanooga, let’s talk mounted infantry.

While a horse is a hansom and noble beast imbued with all the aura of knight errantry it is a terribly inefficient and troublesome military instrument, what with its constant need for large quantities of forage (hay) and grain, which must be carried along, stockpiled or rustled up en route, and their need for large amounts of fresh, clean water, the need to keep them shod, their annoying habit of going lame, developing colic, sore backs and saddle sores, and just falling over dead for no apparent reason. Soldiers, like farmers, were happy to dump the horse in favor of the much more reliable internal combustion engine. Diesel fumes may not be as romantic as horse farts, but life with a jeep is a lot easier than life with a 1000 lb hay-burner that needs to be fed twice a day, watered three times, brushed and curried every night and morning and will step on your feet as often as it possibly can.

How old am I? Old enough to know to stay out of open-ended political arguments. Old enough to remember when everybody hated Harry Truman. Old enough to wear a Taft for President button to school. Old enough to remember the Army-McCarthy hearings and a televised nuclear detonation. Old enough to qualify as an expert with the M-1 rifle. Old enough to have actually carried on real conversations with a woman who smelled the smoke from the Great Chicago Fire. As old as dirt, but a bit younger than Senator McClain.

The Union did perhaps, but Chattanooga was in a desperate shape. They were starving, eating horses and mules and their horse’s food, and the only supply line was over a ridge that was easily shelled and disrupted by cavalry raids. The Union soldiers penned in Chattanooga were in worse shape than the Confederates, who were also hungry but more free to hunt and forage/steal and for a few get care packages from home occasionally. (Sam Watkins tells a couple of stories about his own foraging and the guilt he felt over it.)

Looking at your scenario, I’m a little confused, btw. In our hypothetical scenario, do Rosecrans and the Army of the Cumberland make it back to Chatanooga, or does the now Bragg-less Army of Tennessee manage to cut them off and force their surrender before they get back there?

Because in real history, once Rosecrans gets back to Chatanooga, I don’t really see how the Confederates could have taken the city by force. It would have meant attacking a fortified city with close to a numerical equality (USA had about 40,000 active troops, CSA, about 50,000) A siege really was the CSA’s best option there.

Here are the Orders of Battle for the Chatanooga campaign, btw (this is after Forrest’s feud with Wheeler, btw):

CSA

and

USA