If You Like Harry Potter... (Favorite Kids' Fantasy)

Oh how wonderful. So many old favourites, and two newies to go look for - I’ve not read Diane Duane or Edgar Eager. Thank you all.

Fenris, for completeness, what about “A Barnstormer in Oz” by Phil Jose Farmer? (I have a spare copy if you don’t have one). I’ve got the canon plus the Thompson’s, but it’s not a favourite series. I find Baum too stilted - he was trying to deliberately create an American fairytaleworld and I think the deliberation comes through.

Delphica, Joan Aitken also wrote one for much younger children called ‘The Kitchen Warriors’, with no dark edge.

Ones unmentioned as yet:

[ital]Marianne Dreams[/ital] by Catherine Storr is, as far as I know, a one off - never seen anything else by the same author. It is about a child who finds a magic pencil and whatever she draws (or erases) happens. Excellent fantasy with ethical overtones aimed at a young child - what is her responsibility to the creatures/people she has created?

The [ital]Mary Poppins[/ital] series by PL Travers is excellent. I think there are 5 books in it. British eccentricity for children.

From memory Alan Garner stuff is also good, particularly [ital]The Wierdstone of Brisingamen[/ital], but it’s been a long time since I re-read it.

For younger kids, what about Enid Blyton’s [ital]Faraway Tree[/ital] and [ital]Wishing Chair[/ital] series? I always loved the Faraway Tree - a new land each week would be such a wonderful experience.

Tove Jansson’s [ital]Moomintroll[/ital] series is an all-time favourite, very otherworldly, like you’re suspended in the calm before a storm breaks and the Moomintroll family life happens around you - very comforting.

Don’t know if they are available in the US, but the [ital]Plum Rain Scroll[/ital] trilogy by Ruth Manley is just simply compulsive reading if you appreciate children’s fantasy. She retells old Japanese fairy tales in a magic-heroic style accessible to Westerners. Worth scouring the internet for copies. The third in the series is the least, as it was completed after her death, and misses her light humour.

But no-one has mentioned Nicholas Stuart Gray. Fantasy with humour, some books for younger kids like the ones about [ital]Grimbold[/ital], others like [ital]The Seventh Swan[/ital] and [ital]The Stone Cage[/ital], probably for older kids. [ital]The Stone Cage[/ital] is the retelling of the story of Rapunzel from the point of view of the witch’s familiars. Very nicely crafted.

TH White’s [ital]The Once and Future King[/ital] is a brilliant version of the Merlin legend, with one of the books in the series, [ital]The Sword in the Stone[/ital] familar to many children via Disney. And the Disney cartoon isn’t half-bad either!

Ummm, sorry about that - I seem to have gotten carried away…

Just to be pedantic, (sorry!) the Cannon includes the Thompson books. It’s the first 40 Oz books (Baum+Thompson+Neill+Snow+a few others) that were published by Reilly-Lee.

Anyway, thanks for the offer, it’s really appreciated, but I do have a copy of A Barnstormer in Oz*. I read it when it was new, and hated it. I no longer remember why I hated it though, so I want to go back and re-read it.

Have you tried Wicked* by Gregory Maguire? It’s the Wicked Witch of the West’s story in a darkly skewed Oz. It’s creepy to watch her fight the usurper Wizard who’s deposed the Pastoria family and hidden the Ozma. The Wizard working ruthelessly to stamp out the Lurlineist heresy (paraphrasing: ‘Oz was created by the fairy queen Lurline-Superstitious nonsense!’)

The Wizard is also trying to set up a single Oz, instead of the four independant countries (echoes of “One People, One Land, One OZ!”) and the Witch is a freedom-fighter trying to protect the talking Animals.

The first two-thirds are dark, creepy,and brilliantly done (the author, obviously loves the Oz books and knows his trivia), but the ending is weak and kind of dribbles off.

Fenris

You are awesome! Thanks!

I adore LeGuin, especially her earlier works. I discovered her when I was 16 or 17, so I did not immediately consider her works for younger people. Earthsea is absolutely brilliant. I would also suggest City of Illusions for any young person thinking about issues of identity. I reread it myself when I need a kick in the rear.

Too bad you were disappointed with Susan Cooper. I most enjoyed her evocative prose and mythicial allusions, so I suppose I overlooked deficiencies in other areas.

MR

Lois Lowry is a fine contemporary author of YA fantasy…she’s won two Newbury awards to date.

My ten-year-old daughter loves her stuff, and I read the award-winning THE GIVER and the just-published GATHERING BLUE over our vacation a couple months ago. I can recommend the former without reservation; the new one is good, but not as good as THE GIVER…

Gaudere…you ever read Snyder’s BLACK AND BLUE MAGIC? I loved that one when I was a kid…it’s about a boy in San Francisco who sprouts wings.

I don’t know how much this really counts as part of the genre, but I read a fabulous book called The Giver, by, I believe, Lois Lowry.

It’s a sort of a futuristic story about a community that has figured out a way to channel everyone’s emotions into one person, who then feels everything, so nobody else has to feel anything. The whole point is so nobody has to feel bad but they forget that means nobody gets to feel good either. I thought it was excellent, thought-provoking and a great book to teach.

D’Oh!

Excellent taste there, Sunny!

{SPOILER ALERT! SCROLL DOWN!}

So, what was YOUR take on the last scene of THE GIVER? My daughter and my mother-in-law read it as Jonas (and the baby he was trying to save) finally making it to a better, warmer place, dragging themselves through the driving snow and down to salvation among people who live the Good Life.

Me, I thought Jonas was hallucinating, and that he and the baby died horribly and miserably in the storm.

Just call me “Mister Sunshine.”

No, I don’t think so…I read every Snyder book in the school library, but I don’t recall that one. Maybe I’ll check it out. I do remember a half-way decent book called Mail-order Wings, where a girl orders wings from the back of a comic book, but then she starts turning into a bird.

Here here! Those books are a delight!

Several people have mentioned Tam Lin, which I do not really care for. I read it after having it recommended to me by several friends and was disappointed. Oddly enough, the exact same thing happened to my roommate and younger sister. We’ve joked about forming a club for people who didn’t like Tam Lin even though their friends did. :slight_smile: I didn’t think the blend of fantasy and reality was handled very well, and I got bored with the endless mundane details about Janet’s class schedule, etc., that had no bearing on the plot. And I agree with tomndebb that it’s not really a book for kids, it’s more for teenagers and up.

Or “Mister Bierce.” Whom I don’t recommend for children, btw.

Although I don’t think it’s marketed as YA, the Myth series by Robert Aspirin is appealing - dumb puns, fun characters and interesting plots (may be inappropriate becausse of a little sex, but I don’t recall of the top of my head).

Ben Bova has written some great YA SF stories. I can’t recall any titles, but I really enjoyed the stories when I was 8-12.