[QUOTE=Mr2001]
Yawn. Whether he has a connection to the work is, IMO, irrelevant. He has no right to suppress it either way.
[/QUOTE]
Your disregard for other people taints your actions and destroys your argument. You might as well argue that it is moral to cut to the head of lines because, hey, who cares of those other people are disturbed!
[QUOTE=Mr2001]
See, that’s emotive language. What a surprise that it’s in your post and not mine.
[/QUOTE]
Tu Quoque. And look up sarcasm.
[QUOTE=Mr2001]
Instead of “suppress”, is there a friendlier term you’d like to use for when one person wants to prevent someone else from spreading information?
[/QUOTE]
“Protecting his rights”.
[QUOTE=Mr2001]
I don’t doubt that he might be offended. I just don’t find his offense to be any more relevant than the offense of someone who’s disturbed by a newspaper article or video game. Sure, he wrote much of the content, but why should that give him the right to suppress it?
[/QUOTE]
His labor on it earns him that right. When a person moves lumber around for you, he has earned his pay. His labor has value, and you are responsible for paying him back for the value of the labor he did for you. When a person carves and assembles a dining room table out of blocks of wood, the table is his, and should he sell it, he has a right to the increase in payment he would get than if he’d sold the blocks of wood. When a person restores a beat-up old classic car to pristine condition, he has earned the payment for the increase in value to the car. When a person paints a lovely painting, he owns the painting, and has a right to the increase in payment over the cost of the canvas and paints. And, (dum dum dum,) when an author carefully chooses and arranges words to create a greater effect or impact than they had in the dictionary, the resulting arrangement of words is his, or if he did them for somebody else, then he has a right to compensation for the arrangement of words.
This is a concept called ‘added value’ and is one of the major foundations of society. When a person adds value to something, that added value is theirs. If they own the raw materials upon which they performed their work, then the work is theirs, with all it’s added value tied up in conrete form within the result. Now, most of the time people are adding value to somebody else’s stuff; this is called ‘earning a wage’. But when you add value to something of your own, or even create something entirely out of nothing, that thing that you created is yours.
Most ‘value added’ is immaterial; you’re not so much creating things ex nihilo, you’re altering something that already exists. When a carbenter builds a table, he is chopping away wood, not adding it; still, he is adding value, and owns that value until he sells it. The same thing goes for a writer; they are arranging words, not creating them, yet they are still adding value, and the results of their labor are still theirs until they sell them. (Before anybody says anything silly, it’s possible to only partially sell their rights. Any author who requires his name remain on his book has clearly not handed over all his rights to it.)
When you take the results of somebody’s labor without their permission or consent, you’re stealing from them. There are some, rare, cases when it’s morally correct to kill somebody, just as there are some, rare, cases when it’s morally correct to torture someone. Copying a work and refusing to pay the stated price for it is morally equivalent to getting your hair cut at a barber’s and then, instead of paying, saying “ha ha ha, you can’t catch me!” and walking away; or hiring somebody to build you a table, and then, once he’s brought it into your house and set it up in the living room, throwing him out without paying for it.
And you know what? I think you, Mr2001, are perfectly aware of this. (I also think you’re going to deny it and jeer at me for ‘reading your mind’; go right ahead.) Your hell-bent insistence at referring to an artist’s specific work as generic ‘information’, your dead-on insistince that an author has as little to with the book he wrote as unrelated people do, your position that a copy is a copy, and if the author makes it and gives it to someone or if that someone just takes a copy is all the same- in my personal opinion these are a desperate, deliberate assult on the author’s ownership of his content, because if you can pretend the author doesn’t have any connection to his work, then it isn’t immoral to take it without compensation. That’s what your arguements seem designed to do; the certainly don’t have nothing to do with protecting free speech, or whatever.
Of course you’ll deny it. Loudly. With vehemence. And with personal attacks. That’s fine. And what the hey, I could be wrong. If it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck, maybe it is a chicken.
But let me just say, you haven’t a chance in hell of convincing me that an author is unrelated to his work. Hopefully, you won’t be able to convince anyone else, either; the goal of this board is not to spread misinformation.
Okay!
[QUOTE=Mr2001]
Most home users are not the ones ripping TV shows, music, and DVDs, and sharing them on the internet (which is why copy protection that stops the average home user still doesn’t keep the protected content from appearing online).
[/QUOTE]
True but irrelevent. Most (or all) persons ripping are doing it from home. They’re certainly not going to be doing it from work, on the company servers. You have to have at least some brains to rip a movie.
[QUOTE=Mr2001]
By “such a way”, you mean lying about who wrote it? I don’t think anyone here has expressed support for that. If you want to prosecute people for making false or misleading claims about the authorship of works they distribute, I’m with you 100%.
[/QUOTE]
I was answering “Someone who thinks another person across the country with a P2P client or word processor can actually make something “happen” to his art, however, is probably mentally ill - or he’s about to win $1 million from James Randi by proving paranormal activity.”
This would be ‘shifting the goalposts’, I believe. I did, after all, respond to what you actually wrote.
[QUOTE=Mr2001]
There’s just something about people fighting against freedom of speech that makes my blood boil. Sorry.
[/QUOTE]
This is not about freedom of speech.
[QUOTE=Mr2001]
You know, in a way, it’s charming how you keep making wild guesses at my goals or motives, even though you’re wrong each time. If at first you don’t succeed and all that. But there comes a time when you have to be honest with yourself and admit that you really can’t read my mind.
[/QUOTE]
When I’m honest with myself, I have to doubt that I’m wrong each time.
[QUOTE=Mr2001]
People aren’t given the choice to pay “any money at all”. If a DVD costs $15, you can either pay $15 to buy it, or pay nothing and not buy it.
The question has been answered, though. You think anyone who’s willing to spend money on the production or enjoyment of a movie will be willing to pay for a copy, and I can only disagree. I’d offer myself as an example, but I have actually paid for DVDs and CDs, so while I can say that I’d rather pay for production and would pay for the production of more movies than I would pay for copies of, I can’t say I’m entirely unwilling to pay for copies.
[/QUOTE]
Emphasis mine. Interesting how, just a few sentences after mocking me for ‘reading your mind’, you then proceed to tell me what I think. Straw Man.
And as if that weren’t enough, that’s clearly not what I meant when I said “people who aren’t willing to pay any money at all.” Equivocation, again.
[QUOTE=Mr2001]
Ah yes, the old “if it worked we’d be doing it” line - never mind that no one has actually tried it because they already have a profitable business model. Forgive me if I’m not moved by his comments.
[/QUOTE]
If that was all that had been said, I might have something to forgive you for. Argument By Selective Reading.
[QUOTE=Mr2001]
It’s not my system, so I’m not going to worry about these implementation details right now. I’m sure you can find detailed explanations on the web from the people who actually prefer this model.
[/QUOTE]
Okay, so you don’t want to defend the position; fair enough. So it still stands that you haven’t proposed a better model with which to wave away the damage to society that would be caused if a glut of copiers drew movie production down to Chinese levels.
[QUOTE=Mr2001]
Sure. But why’d you bring it up if you don’t want to talk about it? 
[/QUOTE]
I didn’t want to talk about it. I was specifically telling you not to use it as a model of beneficial consequences. You did anyway.
[QUOTE=Mr2001]
That says more about the people giving the looks than it does about the nature of software or programming. If source code is information, then so is a novel.
[/QUOTE]
No, it’s not, but you could at least form the argument that at least some of it is information, without relying on scores of fallacies.